I'll bit. Begin with my post.
I meant no disrespect but it's still bad reasoning and not just irrational but ultimately harmful. Do you mean your last post? I'll try but I won't do the issue justice and I don't really want to spend a lot of time so my response will be half-assed. I think some of the others made better arguments. Yours wasn't the worst that came to mind.
How does your 1 (probably fictitious encounter) compare to systematic, and institutional racism that has been supported by poor, middle class and affluent Whites for 100's years?
Not all white people have had anything to do with the systematic oppression of colonialism, apartheid, slavery and Jim Crow segregation. There were black slave owners and black people who supported apartheid (ie. police officers) and whites who fought against slavery, apartheid, colonialism and Jim Crow segregation. You treat the concept of people being distinct individuals as some 'abstract' technicality, it's true regardless of whether or not most white people are racist.The encounter is basically comparable because there's no fundamental difference between 'cruelty' (or injustice) carried out in isolated circumstances by specific individuals and cruelty carried out systematically by specific individuals. Black people are
not morally superior to white people. I promise that to you on my life. We make the exact same mistakes that they do. I can't explain this in any way you'll take seriously and I know I sound like an idiot. In every Western country people of African descent reside in we have all of the legal rights that white people have and most of us are, and always have been, physically capable of wronging people on the basis of race.
Whites often times attempt to absolve themselves as being a single individual who's done nothing to support, or perpetuate white supremacy when many of you do so without even knowing. Even if it's a simple stereotype. Because, their is a white person some where with power acting on that stereotype to oppress blacks.
There is a black person somewhere with power acting on negative stereotypes they have to oppress individual white people.
What many whites want American Blacks to do is, forget what whites did and are doing in Africa, Australia, South America, India, etc etc. But that's not what a spiritually branded people do. Our modern day ancestors taught us to care about all suffering Blacks. So, when we say we are fed up it's not Slavery, Jim Crowe, or the assassination of Malcolm. It's the genocide of the Aborigine, Native American, Genocide of Rwanda, Apartheid, Cuban embargo, Vietnam etc etc etc.
White people aren't directly responsible for the Rwandan genocide or the human rights violations committed under many African dictators or warlords like Robert Mugabe, Idi Amin, Joseph Kony, Mobutu Sese Seko, Papa Doc (Haitian) etc. Black and other people of color murder, torture and oppress their 'own' people every day, not to mention outsiders.
Most of the anti-white rhetoric has little to nothing to do with any consistent black unity or black love ideology which is why @zzombie (no offense ) can talk about 'our people this, our people that' and exclude a
black woman who wants to end racism against black people because she's in a relationship with a white man. If he really loved black people, if he was really pro-black, he would love all of them unconditionally whether they agreed with him or not, because all black people are black and blackness is what he values. Black nationalists tend to pick and choose which black people to identify with because it has more to do with fighting a scapegoat and prejudice against outsiders than love for their own.
I love it when whites use research, and statics of our known white supremacist institutions as proof of their not supporting racism and white supremacy.
I believe you would deny credible research and statistics that countered your preconceived notions about race relations under that circular reasoning regardless.
Or use the research, ideologies and findings of our Black Scholars to speak the truth boldly without hesitation.
Why are black scholars the only ones who can produce credible research and findings?