Who was better? Grant Hill or T-Mac

[nycest_1]

eff all the other BS you talking bout

Who ?

No he wasnt. Yall gotta stop using opinions, bad ones at that to support your opinions

so tell me what activity for a wing player grant hill couldn't do that mcgrady could.
crossover?
quick first step?
change in direction?
jump shot?
better defender?

i'll give you more hops but thats about it

 

[nycest_1]

Word wtf are win shares and Per

I swear to god I never heard of that shit

I notice cats stay talkin about win shares on here

Watchin the games>>>>Any of those geek fantasy stats

like i said those stats don't tell niggaz that back then half court basketball dominated, players could back someone down from the 3 pt line and kill the clock, the opposing center could very well camp out in the lane to prevent scoring as long as there was someone near by and that players like jeff fucking hornecek and dan fucking marjerle were seen as respectable defenders because they could keep a fucking hand extended on the hip of a player driving to the basket on em (no homo)

 

[major pain]

Dominique Wilkins>>>>>>>>T -mac

He put up better scoring numbers,shot better fg % and averaged 30.3,29,and 30.7 ppg in 3 straight years

Difference is his team was winning games and advancing in the playoffs

In the 80's vs teams like the bucks,pistons ,pacers and celtics(they couldnt beat boston)

I dont think any one player ever did it all by himself. Dont know why people expect Tmac to be any different. That 'never got out first round' argument is flawed if you put the situation under the microscope.

 

[C.Melendez]

imma be the UNC asshole fan who says what can either one of them do that that Stackhouse couldn't

back on topic imma say Grant Hill especially with the rule changes that TMac played in....his frail ass back would've been done in no time

 

[blank..]

Weird thread comparing two injury riddled players.

I seen T-Mac play more than Grant Hill (in his hey-day) so I wont judge.

But I seen T-Mac do some amazing shit only knock on him is obviously the first round virgin situation and obviously his back issues.

I watched a game the Rockets played against the Sonics at the old Key Arena and he was in a zone they had this cat called Mikael Gelable on him (dont know if anybody remember him)..

Anyway a few weeks later the Sonics released him.. he just got abused in every way.

The 13 points in 81 seconds against the Spurs.

62 points against the Nuggets.. To be fair that Nuggets team was atrocious. They had Voshon Lenard on him I think or Dermarr Johnson.

He had phenomenal talent but injury and bad luck overwhelmed him.

 

[bignorm73]

No.

...............

You crazy. Hill was basically his teams point guard in college and the pros.

Led team in assists.

 

[Jdilla26]

Grant>>>>>>>>T-Mac

 

[BlackAX410]

A lot of T-Mac hate in here dude made scoring look effortless and had one of the quickest first steps ever but tbh I aint see Grant play during his prime I heard a lot about wat he did Chasin Benjamins pretty much closed the thread by posting their best season stats head to head[video=youtube;MYkypj3n8mw]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MYkypj3n8mw[/video][video=youtube;6x1p46_uc7Q]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6x1p46_uc7Q[/video]

 

[Ibex]

T-mac was a better scorer, but Grant was the better passer, rebounder, and defender. Grant>>>>

 

[playmaker88]

Stop misusing the word hate.. hater hating.. because someone doesnt agree with you

 

[deeroc22]

Grant Hill.....and cosign FUCK DUKE

 

[BlackAX410]

Stop misusing the word hate.. hater hating.. because someone doesnt agree with you

Sayin all he could do was score nd bringing up the 2nd round virgin thing like Grant wasn't in the same boat is ridiculous. Even wit the bad back in Houston he could give you 25 5 and 5 easy. His playoff average for his career was 29 ppg, 7 rpg, nd 6 apg so it wasn't like he would straight up dissapear and was completely 1 dimensional

 

[R.D.]

T-mac was a better scorer, but Grant was the better passer, rebounder, and defender. Grant>>>>

lies lies lies

ill take mcgrady from toronto defense over hill at any point

McGrady was a better passer at every point in his career

 

[6ft5]

I'll take Grant Hill, While T Mac is great I don't think he did anything to make the players around him better(I'm a Rocets fan) Grant was able to make everyone around him play better (just ask Allen Houston's contract) Hill was great before the injuries and made the adjustments after to still be able to perform on a very good level after the injuries.

 

[kAjUn]

this guy right here

 

[jaxn]

remember when T-Mac first went to Orlando??? He was signed to be Grant Hill's Scottie Pippen

/thread

 

[ty-boogie]

Grant Hill by far. Grant was all around nice. T-Mac was offensively a threat.

 

[huey]

remember when T-Mac first went to Orlando??? He was signed to be Grant Hill's Scottie Pippen

/thread

really? interesting..

 

[6ft5]

I'll take Larry Johnson in his prime over Tmac

 

[playmaker88]

Whoa! look at the stats on her... you man check that girls stats. she winnin