We need to re-visit Peyton Mannings post season career

[dallas' 4 eva]

How soon we forget Drew Brees' days in San Diego...

 

[Shizlansky]

How soon we forget Drew Brees' days in San Diego...

He balled his last year.

And don't forget Brady first 4 years.

 

[ghost!]

stop the caping for this guy. You don't smash the TD record and only record one TD in the superbowl...

Oh...?

07: Brady sets TD record with 50 TDs.

Throws 1 TD in the following Superbowl.

Talkin out ya ass.

Good point.

Do u wanna sit here n compare the two(Brady n Manning) last SB appearances?

 

[ghost!]

First if all Brady is the second best QB of all time IMO.

You wrote all that shit and didn't say nothing.

You didn't understand nothing I wrote.

I ask u a very simple question n you give me what Brees did w no names wides outs at the time. Like Brady ain't done it..n it is better

Plan n simple to answer my question Brees would had the same results state wise as Brady did w that limited offense. Point blank.

 

[ghost!]

*and done it better*

*stat wise*

 

[bow to royalty]

yeah Peyton He's the shit during the regular season, but in the playoffs, it's a different story.

This is the truth that gets side stepped. THIS IS WHY PEYTON GET CRITICIZED not no bullshit..it's only a big game cause he loses. .wtf is that bullshit @‌bowtoroyality ??

stop the caping for this guy. You don't smash the TD record and only record one TD in the superbowl...

I remember the 07 pats losing the superbowl n this forum was flooded w all kind of Brady choked cuz he failed to put up as much points as he did in the reg. season.

So tired of the Manning caping that goes on. And Brady gets his fare share of criticism.

Tell yo boy Manning to play in playoff games like he do in reg. season games...

I understand you getting mad because people are trying to turn this into Brady hate (I'm not). But about the bolded, what I said is true. Hear me out. It's the AFC Championship game vs Brady/Belichick. Since when is that not considered a big game? If he lost that game, he would have caught a LOT of shit. Saying he lost when it counted. But when he won, there was no "he's winning when it counts". That's all I'm saying. Not sure what part of it you think is crazy logic.

 

[ghost!]

yeah Peyton He's the shit during the regular season, but in the playoffs, it's a different story.

This is the truth that gets side stepped. THIS IS WHY PEYTON GET CRITICIZED not no bullshit..it's only a big game cause he loses. .wtf is that bullshit @‌bowtoroyality ??

stop the caping for this guy. You don't smash the TD record and only record one TD in the superbowl...

I remember the 07 pats losing the superbowl n this forum was flooded w all kind of Brady choked cuz he failed to put up as much points as he did in the reg. season.

So tired of the Manning caping that goes on. And Brady gets his fare share of criticism.

Tell yo boy Manning to play in playoff games like he do in reg. season games...

I understand you getting mad because people are trying to turn this into Brady hate (I'm not). But about the bolded, what I said is true. Hear me out. It's the AFC Championship game vs Brady/Belichick. Since when is that not considered a big game? If he lost that game, he would have caught a LOT of shit. Saying he lost when it counted. But when he won, there was no "he's winning when it counts". That's all I'm saying. Not sure what part of it you think is crazy logic.

I'm not getting mad cuz there is heat on brady. I will always expect there to be heat on Brady outside the N.E., niggas don't like that he is great n he can compete w other greats

I said I'm tired of the caping for Manning..and there is plenty caping for Manning. I have never seen so much excuse making for his SB performances..

The AFC CHAMPIONSHIP game you would have to direct that toward anyone ever saying it wasn't a big game cause I have never said it wasnt.

I was more referring to your quote that ppl only pick n choose what is a big game for Manning n what's not base on if he wins that game. N I think that's b.s.

Who are those ppl?

N I would hope SBs>>> afc/nfc games just saying. .

 

[bow to royalty]

yeah Peyton He's the shit during the regular season, but in the playoffs, it's a different story.

This is the truth that gets side stepped. THIS IS WHY PEYTON GET CRITICIZED not no bullshit..it's only a big game cause he loses. .wtf is that bullshit @‌bowtoroyality ??

stop the caping for this guy. You don't smash the TD record and only record one TD in the superbowl...

I remember the 07 pats losing the superbowl n this forum was flooded w all kind of Brady choked cuz he failed to put up as much points as he did in the reg. season.

So tired of the Manning caping that goes on. And Brady gets his fare share of criticism.

Tell yo boy Manning to play in playoff games like he do in reg. season games...

I understand you getting mad because people are trying to turn this into Brady hate (I'm not). But about the bolded, what I said is true. Hear me out. It's the AFC Championship game vs Brady/Belichick. Since when is that not considered a big game? If he lost that game, he would have caught a LOT of shit. Saying he lost when it counted. But when he won, there was no "he's winning when it counts". That's all I'm saying. Not sure what part of it you think is crazy logic.

I'm not getting mad cuz there is heat on brady. I will always expect there to be heat on Brady outside the N.E., niggas don't like that he is great n he can compete w other greats

I said I'm tired of the caping for Manning..and there is plenty caping for Manning. I have never seen so much excuse making for his SB performances..

The AFC CHAMPIONSHIP game you would have to direct that toward anyone ever saying it wasn't a big game cause I have never said it wasnt.

I was more referring to your quote that ppl only pick n choose what is a big game for Manning n what's not base on if he wins that game. N I think that's b.s.

Who are those ppl?

N I would hope SBs>>> afc/nfc games just saying. .

People do pick and choose IMO. That's why Peyton gets 0 credit for beating the Pats. You may be more logical than others then, but this is what I hear. This past yeast it's "Peyton can't win big games. Look what he did in the SB" . Then I point out he won the AFC championship and people act like that's not shit. I'm just saying he wins some, he loses some. But other people act like he loses every time.

SB's are bigger, but conference champion is still an accomplishment. I look at last year as Peyton had a solid playoff year, but didn't get it done. He doesn't have to get 0 credit just because he didn't win the SB.

 

[bow to royalty]

They haven't made it to the playoffs therefore he has more wins.

they havent made it to the playoffs because they arent as good regular season QBs as Peyton.

Making the playoffs is NOT the point..... the point is that once Peyton does make the playoffs, he sucks.

He has been to 3 Super Bowls.

With 3 different head coaches

With two teams

Top 3 all time

So everything you said don't matter.

Since when is "been to 3 superbowls" something to brag about?

^^ this is the stuff I'm talking about.

 

[coop9889]

It is absolutely a matter of 'picking and choosing' what is considered a big game for Manning.

Gets held to a higher standard than most, including Brady. Which is weird to me.

 

[Neophyte Wolfgang]

Manning and Brady both overrated stiff white dudes that had great o lines and teams around them. Mannning is a big game choker and has a losing playoffs and superbowl record

 

[ghost!]

It is absolutely a matter of 'picking and choosing' what is considered a big game for Manning.

Gets held to a higher standard than most, including Brady. Which is weird to me.

When your as decorative as your are in the reg season then turn around n have the type of playoffs n SBs you had. That's what's truly weird.

Chk Manning's playoffs stats n ints..oh wait I'm sorry. ..u can't cuz it's a TEAM SPORT...

 

[Already Home_17]

Manning and Brady both overrated stiff white dudes that had great o lines and teams around them. Mannning is a big game choker and has a losing playoffs and superbowl record

if manning was truly a big game choker, he wouldnt have reached 3 super bowls to begin with. again, thats nitpicking what you consider to be a big game

underachieving is a better word to describe peyton's post-season mediocrity. you cant dismiss how many times he's reached the playoffs, yet you cant ignore the decline in performance himself and his teams have showcased in the playoffs. a 1-2 super bowl record is disappointing, but he had to win his fair share of big games to reach that point to begin with

and his one and only successful super bowl run gets so easily dismissed. didnt he lead one of the biggest comebacks in AFC championship history? against the same team/QB/coach that owned him in the post-season nonetheless? didnt he beat one of the top defenses in that years super bowl? didnt he and the colts offense beat the bears at their own game in weather conditions favoring the opposing team?

funny thing is you dudes probably picked him to lose those two big games, just to dismiss them as soon as he won them. at least give the dude credit when its due

 

[Already Home_17]

It is absolutely a matter of 'picking and choosing' what is considered a big game for Manning.

Gets held to a higher standard than most, including Brady. Which is weird to me.

When your as decorative as your are in the reg season then turn around n have the type of playoffs n SBs you had. That's what's truly weird.

Chk Manning's playoffs stats n ints..oh wait I'm sorry. ..u can't cuz it's a TEAM SPORT...

funny thing is i believe manning has a better TD-INT ratio in the two years he made it to the sb and lost than in the year he made it to the sb and won

but i could be wrong

 

[ghost!]

It is absolutely a matter of 'picking and choosing' what is considered a big game for Manning.

Gets held to a higher standard than most, including Brady. Which is weird to me.

When your as decorative as your are in the reg season then turn around n have the type of playoffs n SBs you had. That's what's truly weird.

Chk Manning's playoffs stats n ints..oh wait I'm sorry. ..u can't cuz it's a TEAM SPORT...

funny thing is i believe manning has a better TD-INT ratio in the two years he made it to the sb and lost than in the year he made it to the sb and won

but i could be wrong

and just because...

 

[bow to royalty]

Manning and Brady both overrated stiff white dudes that had great o lines and teams around them. Mannning is a big game choker and has a losing playoffs and superbowl record

if manning was truly a big game choker, he wouldnt have reached 3 super bowls to begin with. again, thats nitpicking what you consider to be a big game

underachieving is a better word to describe peyton's post-season mediocrity. you cant dismiss how many times he's reached the playoffs, yet you cant ignore the decline in performance himself and his teams have showcased in the playoffs. a 1-2 super bowl record is disappointing, but he had to win his fair share of big games to reach that point to begin with

and his one and only successful super bowl run gets so easily dismissed. didnt he lead one of the biggest comebacks in AFC championship history? against the same team/QB/coach that owned him in the post-season nonetheless? didnt he beat one of the top defenses in that years super bowl? didnt he and the colts offense beat the bears at their own game in weather conditions favoring the opposing team?

funny thing is you dudes probably picked him to lose those two big games, just to dismiss them as soon as he won them. at least give the dude credit when its due

Exactly. You decide before the game whether or not it's a big game...not after. AFC Championship vs the Pats is a big game going in. But win, and no credit for winning a big game. Lose and he lost a big game.

 

[Already Home_17]

It is absolutely a matter of 'picking and choosing' what is considered a big game for Manning.

Gets held to a higher standard than most, including Brady. Which is weird to me.

When your as decorative as your are in the reg season then turn around n have the type of playoffs n SBs you had. That's what's truly weird.

Chk Manning's playoffs stats n ints..oh wait I'm sorry. ..u can't cuz it's a TEAM SPORT...

funny thing is i believe manning has a better TD-INT ratio in the two years he made it to the sb and lost than in the year he made it to the sb and won

but i could be wrong

and just because...

I fail to see what those graphics had anything to do with what I said. maybe I didn't make myself clear

in the post-seasons where he ultimately lost in the Super Bowl, Petyon's TD-INT ratio were better than the post-season where he ultimately won the Super Bowl

 

[ghost!]

Manning and Brady both overrated stiff white dudes that had great o lines and teams around them. Mannning is a big game choker and has a losing playoffs and superbowl record

if manning was truly a big game choker, he wouldnt have reached 3 super bowls to begin with. again, thats nitpicking what you consider to be a big game

underachieving is a better word to describe peyton's post-season mediocrity. you cant dismiss how many times he's reached the playoffs, yet you cant ignore the decline in performance himself and his teams have showcased in the playoffs. a 1-2 super bowl record is disappointing, but he had to win his fair share of big games to reach that point to begin with

and his one and only successful super bowl run gets so easily dismissed. didnt he lead one of the biggest comebacks in AFC championship history? against the same team/QB/coach that owned him in the post-season nonetheless? didnt he beat one of the top defenses in that years super bowl? didnt he and the colts offense beat the bears at their own game in weather conditions favoring the opposing team?

funny thing is you dudes probably picked him to lose those two big games, just to dismiss them as soon as he won them. at least give the dude credit when its due

Exactly. You decide before the game whether or not it's a big game...not after. AFC Championship vs the Pats is a big game going in. But win, and no credit for winning a big game. Lose and he lost a big game.

so basically only Peyton detractors are unfair and illogical but every other QBs detractors are fair and adjective....ok i got it now..check!

 

[ghost!]

It is absolutely a matter of 'picking and choosing' what is considered a big game for Manning.

Gets held to a higher standard than most, including Brady. Which is weird to me.

When your as decorative as your are in the reg season then turn around n have the type of playoffs n SBs you had. That's what's truly weird.

Chk Manning's playoffs stats n ints..oh wait I'm sorry. ..u can't cuz it's a TEAM SPORT...

funny thing is i believe manning has a better TD-INT ratio in the two years he made it to the sb and lost than in the year he made it to the sb and won

but i could be wrong

and just because...

I fail to see what those graphics had anything to do with what I said. maybe I didn't make myself clear

in the post-seasons where he ultimately lost in the Super Bowl, Petyon's TD-INT ratio were better than the post-season where he ultimately won the Super Bowl

ok, and what is your point...so if his ratio was better it meant what?...he lost the superbowl the years they were supposedly better and worse the one year he won..i do not see how that paints him into a better light...it's still not good when you total it up..seems like you are splitting hairs..

*shrug shoulders*

 

[Already Home_17]

It is absolutely a matter of 'picking and choosing' what is considered a big game for Manning.

Gets held to a higher standard than most, including Brady. Which is weird to me.

When your as decorative as your are in the reg season then turn around n have the type of playoffs n SBs you had. That's what's truly weird.

Chk Manning's playoffs stats n ints..oh wait I'm sorry. ..u can't cuz it's a TEAM SPORT...

funny thing is i believe manning has a better TD-INT ratio in the two years he made it to the sb and lost than in the year he made it to the sb and won

but i could be wrong

and just because...

I fail to see what those graphics had anything to do with what I said. maybe I didn't make myself clear

in the post-seasons where he ultimately lost in the Super Bowl, Petyon's TD-INT ratio were better than the post-season where he ultimately won the Super Bowl

ok, and what is your point.....

1. it's ironic

2. it's a team game, a point that you was seemingly mocking your post I responded too. Peyton's stats during his 3 Super Bowl runs sorta proves my point