The Goat Album Tournament - Semi Finals: Reasonable Doubt VS Doggystyle

[_Menace_]

ive done a similar thread. Where I Doggystlye won the tournament but Illmatic wasnt in it.

Doggystyle will be in the championship

 

[GunTown]

RD hasn't aged well

 

[water ur seeds]

I missed this one, kinda glad I didnt have to choose haha

 

[trilladelic]

doggystyle isnt just an album, its a moment in time..

nostalgia wins all the time..

 

[GunTown]

I just noticed wu tang forever beat 2001. Fuck this tournament.

Co sign

And RD beat so many albums to get this far

Total madness only on the IC

 

[Roster Player #99]

Doggystyle is indeed a classic. RD....listen to that shit then listen to any other album that came out that year....niggas HAD to step their lyrics up after that. It's cats still finding gems in the verses from that.

 

[its....JOHN B]

Not mad at the results it took me a minute to pick one, but I had to go with what I listen to more in the present and I prefer those ski, primo and Clark Kent beats on a more consistent basis, Doggystyle is my childhood and puts me in that nostalgic state of mind but nowadays it's a change of pace album I might listen to it once a year and I'd rather listen to it while I'm smoking but I don't do that much as I used to, they are both as cohesive as the other but I think Doggystyle relies too heavily on production where Reasonsble doubt is great from a production standpoint and lyrically so that's my pick

 

[supergangster]

seriously when you guys gonna ban zorrow. dude is a fucking white pretending to be black. and now his trolling is fucking worse and one of the main reasons why the reason been shit.

I am not fucking white but I don't give a fuck ban me i will leave this site now anyway im tired of all the hate i get on this site nobody likes me here and people make fun of me all the time

 

[Lab Baby]

Dear, God, i wonder could you save me, I cant die......

"Illuminati want my mind, soul and my body"

Nigga gtfo dont act like Jay wrote that shit

"...you was usin it wrong..."

 

[its....JOHN B]

seriously when you guys gonna ban zorrow. dude is a fucking white pretending to be black. and now his trolling is fucking worse and one of the main reasons why the reason been shit.

I am not fucking white but I don't give a fuck ban me i will leave this site now anyway im tired of all the hate i get on this site nobody likes me here and people make fun of me all the time

What kind of tender hearted shit is this?

 

[J.J._Evans]

seriously when you guys gonna ban zorrow. dude is a fucking white pretending to be black. and now his trolling is fucking worse and one of the main reasons why the reason been shit.

I am not fucking white but I don't give a fuck ban me i will leave this site now anyway im tired of all the hate i get on this site nobody likes me here and people make fun of me all the time

What kind of tender hearted shit is this?

It's actually him trolling.

 

[achewon87]

seriously when you guys gonna ban zorrow. dude is a fucking white pretending to be black. and now his trolling is fucking worse and one of the main reasons why the reason been shit.

I am not fucking white but I don't give a fuck ban me i will leave this site now anyway im tired of all the hate i get on this site nobody likes me here and people make fun of me all the time

 

[a_list]

Unapologetically East Coast Bias....Doggystyle classic tho......

 

[_Goldie_]

ive done a similar thread. Where I Doggystlye won the tournament but Illmatic wasnt in it.

Doggystyle will be in the championship

Ur thread was a dud

 

[Louis Devinear]

@_Goldie_ so who won? Or is this gonna be another it was written vs matw fiasco? Lol

 

[esco soprano]

I see what's going on here lmfao.

 

[DR. JEK]

I remember hearing Jay rap over some of them 1970s love songs type shit and wanting to break something! People condone this shit and dump anthems? Idk I just never thought Jay z first album was all that great. Lyric and flow wise you had to respect some of it but if that's all it took for people to think an album is amazing you can say the same thing about canibus first album. I don't see nona the revisionist saying his shit was a classic. I just find this whole reasonable dought stuff hilarious.

 

[DR. JEK]

My phone change the word SIMP anthems to DUMP anthems up there^

 

[Louis Devinear]

People focus on beats to much. Not saying that the beat shouldn't knock but that's not where the emphasis should lye. RD wasn't about production it was more about him getting his point across as being a dope mc. Remember in 96 this nigga was going up against some of the greatest lyricist/artist coming out of nyc. In that aspect he accomplished what he set out to do even if wasn't received to heavy fanfare. It's not where you from its where you at. Where he was at was nyc. Where lyrics reigned supreme. If he would of came out with some happy go lucky shit this nigga would've got booed outta ny. After he started becoming more known and after traveling and dealing with other things outside of New York. He gave niggas vol.2.

He gave the ppl what they wanted. Yeah I know hip hop purist won't like it but it is what it is. But every time this man drop an album. What do they compare it to? RD

 

[TheGOAT]

I liked the beats on RD

The smooth feel, the horns, the Issac Hayes sample... shit was kick back playa made music