Quentin Tarantino: ‘Roots’ Was Inauthentic

  • Thread starter Thread starter New Editor
  • Start date Start date
I've been re-reading Roots the novel on and off over the past few months. The African involvement in the slave trade was downplayed and it was portrayed as being racially based when the majority of the slaves were prisoners of war, criminals or people who were already slaves and sold by their masters, and certain aspects of traditional African society are misrepresented (Kunta thinks of himself as being from 'the Gambia' and other modern African countries are mentioned by name even though every African country, including Ethiopia and Liberia, is the product of 19th century colonialism, he is aware of and takes pride in other Black civilizations like ancient Ghana and Great Zimbabwe even though this kind of pan-Africanist mentality was probably foreign to most 18th century Mandinkas, ). Apparently, a lot of it was was plagiarized from The African and even many of the aspects claimed by Haley to be true are inaccurate. It's still a good book and one of my favorite 'movies'. Besides that, in terms of the the story itself, I don't see what makes it 'inauthentic'. The violence and brutality of the Middle Passage and slavery is downplayed by the mini-series.
 
Last edited:
blakfyahking;5302785 said:
but unless niggaz stop running to see movies like Django

basically Tarantino wins by basically trolling black people and putting movie viewers' money in his pocket at the same time

SMH @ letting a mofo disrespect you and then you turn around and voluntarily give him your money too

we gotta stop being sheep :(

Bolded is proof that we still ain't learned shit from Roots or our history.
 
kai_valya;5302780 said:
if it was inaccurate in any way, i imagine it'd be that it didn't really capture the true brutality and savagery that was slavery


i've never been a huge fan of dude, he's just ehhh to me, but i always got the impression that he's kinda a prick in real life (same with bill maher although i like bill a lil more), but after seeing this vid it just solidified that opinion of him. he seems like a total tool, lol @ him saying he could kick anyones ass

he is quite ugly too


I'm sure white people weren't cool with it being on TV in the first place. If Haley tried to drop it like it really happened, no way in hell would it have been on TV in those days. And I always thought Tarantino was overrated, never paid to see any of his shit. (Did see some of his movies on TV though).
 
^^it's true that African tribes sold prisoners of war but what do you think happen when they had no more prisoners? They bitch ass was enslaved to and the whites did capture niggas off the strength of them being niggas.

 
I can't speak on Roots, because I'm not gonna see it.

All I'm going to say is that it seems like Tarantino ethered that shit. That's just me...I'm not speaking on behalf of anybody else.
 
Ya'll do realize that the dude didn't just come out of nowhere and say this right? It's not like this was just some random unsolicited comment. He's replying to the criticism that his move badly represents slavery. He's simply saying that Roots is regarded as a "good" movie about slavery but to him it wasn't historically accurate either. He's right there. That said, I don't think they are comparable. Roots may take liberties with the truth but it's a lot closer to the truth than what QT put out.

I hate when people can only defend themselves by shitting on others. You feel like they are falsely criticizing your movie fine, but why bring Roots into it and knock it?
 
QT managed to piss everybody off some black ppl and some white ppl.

Troll of the year

The 1st Roots was good but, those sequels were type suspect

Roots is a great movie.I can't agree w/ QT on this, unless he only saw the sequels then that would make sense
 
Roots came out on network tv in 1977. How much violence was even on network tv at the time? How graphic do folks think the shit was going to get. Shit just look at Batman movies now and back then. Not one drop of blood back in the day. Now they got nukes going off. Very different time period in film making.
 


Hollywood is not having that
lamontbdc;5303771 said:
Roots came out on network tv in 1977. How much violence was even on network tv at the time? How graphic do folks think the shit was going to get. Shit just look at Batman movies now and back then. Not one drop of blood back in the day. Now they got nukes going off. Very different time period in film making.

And don't forget hanging three guys with a noose around their neck from a bridge The dark Knight rises was on some shit I tell ya.
 
Mr.LV;5303818 said:
Hollywood is not having that
lamontbdc;5303771 said:
Roots came out on network tv in 1977. How much violence was even on network tv at the time? How graphic do folks think the shit was going to get. Shit just look at Batman movies now and back then. Not one drop of blood back in the day. Now they got nukes going off. Very different time period in film making.

And don't forget hanging three guys with a noose around their neck from a bridge The dark Knight rises was on some shit I tell ya.

yea they did slide that shit in Batman. Imagine what the fuck they had to go through with the tv network just to get Roots on tv. Whitey wasn't letting that shit go but only so far. Some folks talking like Roots came out in HD 3 years ago and was trying to gloss over the true brutality of slavery. It's 2012 and we have 0 black sitcoms on network tv. So I'm sure in 1977 whitey said hey just do whatever you want
 
didnt read this entire thread but roots was a fictional story so in a sense it was inauthentic. it still served a purpose though
 
GalouDaBklynKing;5303611 said:
Also, Shaka Zulu intro, is Goat. Everytime i hear this song makes me want to punch a racist cracker, word up, son.


GalouDaBklynKing;5303611 said:
Also, Shaka Zulu intro, is Goat. Everytime i hear this song makes me want to punch a racist cracker, word up, son.


I ve been meaning to sample the intro for the longest.....
 
goldenja;5304040 said:
denzel already put this foo in his place

i'm sure spike will too

grind house was coo n a fuck tho

Quentin was like lets talk about this in the backroom

Denzel was like nah we are going air this shit right here in front of the film crew.

Denzel=Mr.Gully
 

Members online

No members online now.

Trending content

Thread statistics

Created
-,
Last reply from
-,
Replies
137
Views
0
Back
Top
Menu
Your profile
Post thread…