sdotcarter111
New member
Vaas;5339541 said:2.) Shit makes perfect sense b. The whole point of the elaborate plan was to get Brunhilda (?) for the low low. Going to that white devil and making an outrageously claim meant that you would have to fulfill your part of the deal before you get the legal documents signing her over to you. Thus the whole plan of getting the desert honkey's interest by making a more then generous offer for a nigger fighter to mask getting brunhilda on sale.
I understand that. What i'm saying is there's nothing to prove Candie wouldn't have sold her for 3 bills anyway. He was letting the fighter go only for 12k because he was a prize mule and cashcow. Brumhilda was one of dozens of slave bitches in his possession. She, along with every other slave woman, wasn't worth shit. She was a repeat runaway slave who they put in a hotbox for a week to punish. How much worth you really think she had to them crackas?
There were good reasons they couldn't have just walked in there and bought Brumhilda. None of them had anything to do with the horse/farm metaphor.
Even assuming, for the sake of argument, the price would have been double for her had they been able to just walk in there and buy her - an extra $300 would have been worth not having to go through the whole charade and risk everyone's life (and eventually Schultz did lose his life). Not to mention that Candie would have sent someone after them when they didn't come back for the fighter. All that's not worth a few extra bills?
Bottom line, the movie's reasoning for not just buying her fell on its face on false logic and assumptions. Specially when there were other, better reasons they couldn't have done it. I'm not saying the shit ruined the movie, it didn't even bother me. I only brought the shit up in passing. Its only now turning into an argument.
Last edited: