What would it take for Peyton Manning to be the GOAT QB in your eyes?

[Maalik]

(Nice Try little brother.........you not there yet lol)

smh @ niggas saying Peyton was the only one who controls the team last week & then saying........after tonight that it was his team fault he lost. smh!!!!!!! and Lmao.

 

[Dick Shitman]

^^^lol @ that top pic of peyton

 

[Stack Money]

Nothing. Peyton took a step back majorly tonight. He's behind Elway, Montana, Brady, Young, Aikman, Farve, and Bradshaw. I place him ahead of Marino because he has a ring. Peyton has regained the title of choker. He had the ball in his hands to at least tie it and he threw a pic 6. You ever see Joe Montana do that in the Super Bowl? Yeah right.

word

[video=youtube;IMk5sMHj58I]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMk5sMHj58I[/video]

Meet Herm Edwards. He will tell you why.

Nah. It was all Peytons fault. Joe Montana would have never thrown a pic 6 with a chance to tie or take the lead in the Super Bowl. Heck even Aikman wouldn't have done that. Peyton choked. Don't try to sugar coat his choke with analysis. Peyton Choked and im bumpin this all night.

[video=youtube;h4UqMyldS7Q]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4UqMyldS7Q[/video]

LMAO

lol, this nigga partyin like his team won. It wasnt all peytons fault but that pick was huge. He didnt seem to be hustling on that last drive either

cause he knew it was over

Watching Peyton crumble is priceless! That pic 6 will forever haunt him. He'll be having nightmares of that throw all off season. It was epic.

this....^^ and niggas know had that been brady who throw that pick 6...there wouldn't have been no logic, angle or arguement that couldn't of stop the haters from posting...ha ha now keep making excuses for manning now....that was all his fault ha ha

co-sign

(Nice Try little brother.........you not there yet lol)

smh @ niggas saying Peyton was the only one who controls the team last week & then saying........after tonight that it was his team fault he lost. smh!!!!!!! and Lmao.

:dead: @ this post

 

[vageneral08]

Nah. It was all Peytons fault. Joe Montana would have never thrown a pic 6 with a chance to tie or take the lead in the Super Bowl. Heck even Aikman wouldn't have done that. Peyton choked. Don't try to sugar coat his choke with analysis. Peyton Choked and im bumpin this all night.

[video=youtube;h4UqMyldS7Q]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4UqMyldS7Q[/video]

C'mon with that bullshit he threw a pic against the bills and they lost the afc championship.....

 

[R.D.]

I knew the game was gonna bring the Peyton haters out but this is disgusting, He is still the best QB in the league and that must hurt some feelings

 

[traestar]

I knew the game was gonna bring the Peyton haters out but this is disgusting, He is still the best QB in the league and that must hurt some feelings

Co-sign, he's still one of the most feared QBs in the league!

 

[allied]

Co-sign, he's still one of the most feared QBs in the league!

I sorry, he can't be the best QB in the leaque and throw that INT with the game on the line. He has one ring while winning the most games last decade, that's not being the best. Not a Manning hater, just stating facts.

 

[R.D.]

I sorry, he can't be the best QB in the leaque and throw that INT with the game on the line. He has one ring while winning the most games last decade, that's not being the best. Not a Manning hater, just stating facts.

Are you serious??? Peyton Manning is the best QB in the league maybe ever, get over it

 

[allied]

Are you serious??? Peyton Manning is the best QB in the league maybe ever, get over it

Once again, he's won the most games last decade but only lead his team to two Superbowl apearances and only ONE ring. Warner lead his team to three. To me that's not being the best QB ever, not by a longshot.

 

[im2fly]

Are you serious??? Peyton Manning is the best QB in the league maybe ever, get over it

I'm sorry but if you have a win percentage of .500 in the playoffs you can't be considered the greatest QB of all time. He might eventually get there but until he actually proves that he can win when it REALLY MATTERS, Montana's going to own that spot. It kills me how people want to put him before Montana. Regular season games and stats don't mean shit without the hardware. You don't hear people putting Marino or Farve on that pedestal and they had the same record breaking stats as Manning does.

 

[R.D.]

WTF is wrong with yall. This aint tennis. its a team sport
Championships do not equal individual greatness

 

[nujerz84]

He would have to win another title and play well in the Superbowl. He was putting Super Bowl MVP numbers last night then he threw the INT. The colts will be back in the hunt next season they get Bob Sanders, Marlin Jackson and Anthony Gonzalez back from injury.

 

[vageneral08]

Once again, he's won the most games last decade but only lead his team to two Superbowl apearances and only ONE ring. Warner lead his team to three. To me that's not being the best QB ever, not by a longshot.

I give the saint there props but really who can match peyton manning's level?....possible tom brady but not this season he didnt drew bees is close but he doesn't have a good season every year like manning stat wise but next season we'll see what happens

 

[vageneral08]

People act like manning some super human qb who is incapable of makin mistakes.They lost to the sorry ass Aint's and won against a inept weak ass bears team that shouldn't even been there.Stop comparing manning to brady,montana he ain t on they level.

lol the saint are not that sorry, i dont know what team you was looking at....people keep talkin about the bears in the other superbowl.....are ya'll forgetting they had the top rank defense in the league????? it wasn't about the offsense it was about the defense

 

[allied]

EXCUSES, EXCUSES, EXCUSES. That's all I'm hearing. You can't have all these threads saying how Manning is better than Brady and is the best QB ever, and when he throws a pick-6 with the game on the line say it's a team sport. I'm not buying that bullshit, sorry. You can't have it both ways.

 

[im2fly]

lol the saint are not that sorry, i dont know what team you was looking at....people keep talkin about the bears in the other superbowl.....are ya'll forgetting they had the top rank defense in the league????? it wasn't about the offsense it was about the defense

Don't pay him no mind man...he still salty about the Saints beating the Vikes....... Poor Tommy..... LOL

 

[vageneral08]

Doggie the bears aint have the top d in the league in 2006 they was like 16th or 18th tommie harris and mike brown aint even play in the super bowl.The ain'ts are one of the weakest sb champs ever.Manning always does this shit choke when the pressures on he did in college and in the nfl.No way colts should of lost to the aint's,no way manning is on bradys level.

well you can't say that this season because brady had a shitty season and the way it ended it didnt make him look any better yeah you can say he was out for an year but manning basically had a similiar situation and won 9 straight games

 

[ghost!]

EXCUSES, EXCUSES, EXCUSES. That's all I'm hearing. You can't have all these threads saying how Manning is better than Brady and is the best QB ever, and when he throws a pick-6 with the game on the line say it's a team sport. I'm not buying that bullshit, sorry. You can't have it both ways.

Thank you!!!! And u can't even call him a brady fan cuz u can see who he reps..it's over for manning's fans...he and you'lll just got knocked down a notch! ha ha i hurts i know!!

 

[im2fly]

Doggie the bears aint have the top d in the league in 2006 they was like 16th or 18th tommie harris and mike brown aint even play in the super bowl.The ain'ts are one of the weakest sb champs ever.Manning always does this shit choke when the pressures on he did in college and in the nfl.No way colts should of lost to the aint's,no way manning is on bradys level.

So so salty.... Poor Tommy..... Saints are weak but held the Colts to only 7 points after the 1st quarter. No matter how you feel it doesn't change the out come dude. Saints are SB44 Champions..... hating is not gonna change that but that all you can do so proceed... LOL

 

[vageneral08]

Don't pay him no mind man...he still salty about the Saints beating the Vikes....... Poor Tommy..... LOL

On some real shit I would like to play the saints again that was good game