USA TODAY: Top 10 NFL QBs...

[FlyFreeCt]

Better than Ryan yes based off playoff and a SB win but better than Ben naw...

Don't know what people see in Ben Roethlisberger smh..I'll never understand this shit....Put Philip Rivers on Pittsburgh and he might have 3 Super Bowls..

 

[coop9889]

You wouldn't with 100% certainty take Brees over Manning or Brady, all else being equal.

Brees is a CLOSE third, but he is still 3rd.

Thats why he is in the 2nd tier.

 

[newOldSchool]

I'm not really mad about the top 10 but Sanchez seeing any list blows is crazy. I'm sorry but if the Jets had Romo with that defense I'm not so sure they would have lost to the Steelers.

 

[joeyfkncrakk]

I think my tier list is most legit list on here.. Rodgers got one up on Philip and I feel he outperformed Drew last year and by comparison in SB seasons.. Aaron played with a lot less talent and injuries put his team on back basically single handedly on offense.. If Rivers can get 1 in a year or 2Ill put him above Rodgers til then Arod is a top 3 qb... ur dumb af if you have Schaub behind Freeman or Flacco, Schaub been beastin like 3 yrs str8.. I personally think Romo is top 10 worthy bcus there's not many great qbs playin.. Romo is only a playoff win or 2 b4 being hailed best dallas QB rating-wise.. Big Ben is not on Rivers level so we can leave it at that.. If Rivers was a steeler Pittsburgh would br unstoppable.. Mike Vick might be the best QB if he can repeat wat he did last year keep it 1000

Brady

Manning

Rodgers

Brees

PRivers

Vick

Big Ben

Ryan

Romo

Schuab

Eli

JFreeman

Bradford

Cutler

McNabb

Flacco

Stafford

Cassel

Sanchez

 

[R.D.]

nawww, mine was the best

Tier 1:
Manning, Brady

Tier 2:
Rodgers, Rivers, Brees,Vick , Rothlisberger

Tier 3:
Ryan, Cutler, Romo

Tier 4:
E Manning, Schaub, Freeman,

Tier 5:
Cassel, Sanchez, Flacco

 

[joeyfkncrakk]

I can understand moving Rodgers down one but how Brees not in the elite 1's he's been consistent and has as many sb's as Manning... but Cutler ain't better than Eli,Freeman, or Schaub.. Cutler is a career loser and pick master.. other than that I won't bytch too much

nawww, mine was the best

Tier 1:

Manning, Brady

Tier 2:

Rodgers, Rivers, Brees,Vick , Rothlisberger

Tier 3:

Ryan, Cutler, Romo

Tier 4:

E Manning, Schaub, Freeman,

Tier 5:

Cassel, Sanchez, Flacco

 

[MR.CJ]

Ben is a product of a run heavy offense and a defense that has been great since his 1st season..He's a "game manager"..yea he'll extend plays on occassion but he's not as good as people make him out to be...That 1st super bowl win was the worst QB performance by any winning QB in super bowl history...He'e like right at 10 on my list.

but he made it up in his 2nd super bowl win.

dude was clutch

 

[MR.CJ]

lol @ eli being better than big ben

[video=youtube;l1dnqKGuezo]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l1dnqKGuezo&feature=player_embedded[/video]

 

[vageneral08]

but he made it up in his 2nd super bowl win.

dude was clutch

remember homles made the catch

 

[MR.CJ]

remember homles made the catch

and big ben threw the ball

calm down vageneral08 im not saying big ben>>>peyton

 

[R.D.]

I can understand moving Rodgers down one but how Brees not in the elite 1's he's been consistent and has as many sb's as Manning... but Cutler ain't better than Eli,Freeman, or Schaub.. Cutler is a career loser and pick master.. other than that I won't bytch too much

If you are trying to make a case for Brees being on Peyton's level, There is no way i can even listen to your argument. And Cutler is better than Eli, Freeman, and Schaub IMO. Eli is just not very good imo. Freeman had one good season, wowww. Schaub cant finish a season and he's a loser who has the luxury of playing with a top 2 receiver.

 

[vageneral08]

and big ben threw the ball

calm down vageneral08 im not saying big ben>>>peyton

no catch no points....meaning loss

 

[MR.CJ]

no catch no points....meaning loss

no throw no catch no points....meaning loss

 

[vageneral08]

no throw no catch no points....meaning loss

lol they had no choice but to throw it

 

[joeyfkncrakk]

If you are trying to make a case for Brees being on Peyton's level, There is no way i can even listen to your argument. And Cutler is better than Eli, Freeman, and Schaub IMO. Eli is just not very good imo. Freeman had one good season, wowww. Schaub cant finish a season and he's a loser who has the luxury of playing with a top 2 receiver.

The past 2 years Drew and Peyton performance wise been neck and neck... Matt Schaub just dropped 4K for the 3 str8 year, Schaub is a damn good qb, its his the D that's been terrible cuz he keeps his team in the game til the secondary blows 1

 

[nujerz84]

If you are trying to make a case for Brees being on Peyton's level, There is no way i can even listen to your argument. And Cutler is better than Eli, Freeman, and Schaub IMO. Eli is just not very good imo. Freeman had one good season, wowww. Schaub cant finish a season and he's a loser who has the luxury of playing with a top 2 receiver.

Cutler in no way shape or form is he better than Eli...hes never had a good season...a born loser, worst decision maker and more int prone than Manning. Cutler is trash strong arm and nothing else.

 

[R.D.]

Cutler in no way shape or form is he better than Eli...hes never had a good season...a born loser, worst decision maker and more int prone than Manning. Cutler is trash strong arm and nothing else.

Nothing in the posts convinces anybody Cutler isnt better

 

[joeyfkncrakk]

Cutler in no way shape or form is he better than Eli...hes never had a good season...a born loser, worst decision maker and more int prone than Manning. Cutler is trash strong arm and nothing else.

Like I said Cutler is a born loser.. Phillip Rivers used to shyt on him all the time.. . And how could u even compare that loser Cutler to a SB MVP.. like it or not Eli got the job done that Cutler never ever will.. Cutler is sorrier than a begging hobo from the Gaslamp District

 

[R.D.]

Like I said Cutler is a born loser.. Phillip Rivers used to shyt on him all the time.. . And how could u even compare that loser Cutler to a SB MVP.. like it or not Eli got the job done that Cutler never ever will.. Cutler is sorrier than a begging hobo from the Gaslamp District

What does Eli do better ?