The Reason Moderators' Thread - For Discussion and Improvements

[KillaCham]

"Critic" sounds too cliche. I like "AllHipHop Review Board"

I feel what @YoungGoldie is saying with the scoring. You say try not to look at it from a school perspective buuut Im sure 90% of us have at least made it to the 10th grade lol we may be able to not look at it like that but most of the board will. Just a thought.

My own opinion is trolling will be inevitable and for this to work right, I think it should be 0 tolerance. You have some people that hate certain rappers for whatever reason(probably not even heard the album at hand) and could possibly ruin a rating. How do we take that into factor or we just have to deal with it?

Word I did find the name a bit corny but it was just a play on metacritic name. I'm cool with AllHipHop Review Board. Props Goldie. LOL @ the bolded. You sure that many? I mean, the explanations would be in the OP accommodated by colors. *shrug*

As far as potential trolling, I did think about that and honestly... professional reviews show bias too and there isn't much of a way to stop that. One reason for the word limits is to make sure people aren't throwing out bs ratings without actually listening to whatever they're scoring. It's impossible to write 150 words about an album you haven't heard, you know? I figure that if someone takes the time to type up a review to back up a score ... as long as it isn't 150 characters of some ridiculous and irrelevant bullshit I say fuck it. The stans will balance out the haters. Honest choughts?

 

[Stew]

No doubt, run it.

Just to be 100, no score will be taken into consideration without a legit review, correct? Meaning, nobody can just come into the thread and put "Shit was kimchi juice, 3/10"? We good on flagging those @ThatDamnJay‌? 2 mod flags should get that shit outta there anyway.

 

[KillaCham]

No doubt, run it.

Just to be 100, no score will be taken into consideration without a legit review, correct? Meaning, nobody can just come into the thread and put "Shit was kimchi juice, 3/10"? We good on flagging those @ThatDamnJay‌? 2 mod flags should get that shit outta there anyway.

:tu

 

[KillaCham]

 

[_Goldie_]

Are you starting it today or tomorrow?

 

[KillaCham]

Are you starting it today or tomorrow?

Was thinking about dropping the thread in an hour.

 

[KillaCham]

Wrong thread. hi guys

 

[_Jay_]

No doubt, run it.

Just to be 100, no score will be taken into consideration without a legit review, correct? Meaning, nobody can just come into the thread and put "Shit was kimchi juice, 3/10"? We good on flagging those @ThatDamnJay‌? 2 mod flags should get that shit outta there anyway.

the underlined.

 

[KillaCham]

@KillaCham‌ here's the drop for the AHH front page:
http://allhiphop.com/2014/12/10/joi...j-coles-latest-album-2014-forest-hills-drive/

GOATTTTttttttttttttttt

 

[KillaCham]

I wanna start a single to review tomorrowish but don't have many options. I'd rather something new but there hasn't been much excitement as far as new singles dropping. We have Nipsey Hussle and Drake/Quan but don't really think those would get many reviews.

 

[Stew]

I'm gonna start the yearly Hip Hop awards tonight tomorrow. Any suggestions on doing anything differently?

Album

Song

Artist

Group

Freshman

Producer

...

 

[_Goldie_]

Ill think about a single @KillaCham‌

Best mixtape

Best Collab

Best song Feature

@Stew‌

 

[KillaCham]

http://community.allhiphop.com/discussion/89257/reason-awards-vote-for-the-nominees-stage-1-of-2

There's a few ideas in there. On mobile and too much to copy and paste.

 

[KillaCham]

Damn I tried to do waayyyy too much that year lol

 

[_Goldie_]

@KillaCham‌ , Im not really a fan of Krits , but it seems like most of the IC is. I think "Soul Food" from Krit might be a good choice. The video just dropped today.

 

[Stew]

I hate that he named that track what he did. Wonder how Goodie Mob feels about it.

 

[DOPEdweebz]

We got to find a way to MAKE posters go to other rooms. Stop huddling in certain threads or rooms... or we can start deleting more rooms do to "poor traffic". We're selling this great board short by refusing to participate in other sections and "supporting" the behavior by appeasing the lazy.

Btw I know we can all fall under this category if being "complacent".

 

[_Goldie_]

Im all with that plan bro, Im one of the only mfs who makes threads in the rnb forum. But this album is historic, and needs to be seen. Ill continue doing what Ive been doing and post all rnb content in the rnb forum, but not this one bruh.

 

[Stew]

What album? the D'angelo album that's stickied in The Reason? @YoungGoldie‌

 

[_Goldie_]

Yea , I stickied it when I logged on this morning.