NeighborhoodNomad.
New member
The key question, of course, is what was it about the United States in the 1830s that necessitated the development of local, centralized, bureaucratic police forces? One answer is that cities were growing. The United States was no longer a collection of small cities and rural hamlets. Urbanization was occurring at an ever-quickening pace and old informal watch and constable system was no longer adequate to control disorder. Anecdotal accounts suggest increasing crime and vice in urban centers. Mob violence, particularly violence directed at immigrants and African Americans by white youths, occurred with some frequency. Public disorder, mostly public drunkenness and sometimes prostitution, was more visible and less easily controlled in growing urban centers than it had been rural villages (Walker 1996). But evidence of an actual crime wave is lacking. So, if the modern American police force was not a direct response to crime, then what was it a response to?
More than crime, modern police forces in the United States emerged as a response to "disorder." What constitutes social and public order depends largely on who is defining those terms, and in the cities of 19th century America they were defined by the mercantile interests, who through taxes and political influence supported the development of bureaucratic policing institutions. These economic interests had a greater interest in social control than crime control. Private and for profit policing was too disorganized and too crime-specific in form to fulfill these needs. The emerging commercial elites needed a mechanism to insure a stable and orderly work force, a stable and orderly environment for the conduct of business, and the maintenance of what they referred to as the "collective good" (Spitzer and Scull 1977). These mercantile interests also wanted to divest themselves of the cost of protecting their own enterprises, transferring those costs from the private sector to the state.
So we see from the beginning, from being called "the slave patrol" to "police" the sole purpose of "law enforcement" was to protect the interests of the businessmen and keep workers subordinate.
Being that a Law of Nature is the root always feeds the fruit, how can there ever be peace or between The Black Community and the police?
There will never be progress if we refuse to accept the truth. We have been dealing with this same system for centuries. THE SYSTEM IS NOT BROKEN. It's doing exactly what it was designed to do. Oppress. The ONLY solution is to build a "new" or alternative system. Before we build, we may have to dig. Before we plant, we may have to uproot.
Many civilizations lived and thrived without prisons or police. There were rules established where the "criminal" would be dealt with immediately by the community. We don't need police. We need culture. We need to remember, create or recreate, Our culture, Our own rules, regulations and codes of conduct. Of course all culture starts at home, so that might be a whole other thread.
There will NEVER be true justice from an organization rooted in injustice.


