The Official Eminem Discussion Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter New Editor
  • Start date Start date
I don't get why everyone thinks that the MMLP was Em's classic album. It was good, but is it because it was his album that catapulted him to a hip hop household name? I don't think that can make for a classic, anyone can break down a door with an album but it not be considered a classic.

The Eminem Show, so far, has been his only real hip hop album. Opening it up from White America, being able to say, "Yeah, I realize I'm white and I'm different and blacks may not be able to relate, but I'm still gonna do it" was ballsy. He stated the obvious but it came from his mouth, not someone elses.

Cleanin' out my Closet wasn't your usual, oh kill my mother, it's her fault type of deal. It was the more serious, like okay, here it is raw type of deal.

Say Goodbye to Hollywood, his goodbye ode to hip hop was amazing. Even though he didn't "leave", he wanted to. A feeling anyone in hip hop can relate to. The hard work, the troubles etc etc.

Till I Collpase, "..spilling my heart through this pen.." is exactly what he did the whole album.

This album was very mature for an Eminem album. A breath of fresh air. A slight bit lyrically lighter, but still not taking away from himself.

TES is by far his best album, imo, taking up a 10/10 if not, 9.5/10 rated album.

For those who cannot agree, I don't see why. This album has everything that was complained about that wasn't on albums such as Relapse or Encore. If you can deny this album, then you're simply a hater. You don't have to love it, but at least see it as classic or even CLOSE to a classic Eminem album.
 
Last edited:
I agree. The reason why ppl are gonna come in here and say its not is cause of the production. Was it top notch? no but his lyrics are A+ and the production is tolerable just like most of Nas's albums.
 
Last edited:
Yeh it's a certified classics and arguably Eminem's best Album it's a very deep and personal Album

The Marshall Mathers LP is historic though that Album went far beyond Hip-Hop it's an genre historic Album

The Slim Shady LP is arguably his best Album too

that's 3 universally accepted classics with THe Marshall Mathers LP being like a Hip-Hop Bible that history, crowds packing out stadiums when that Album came out, people buying posters, people just going crazy for Eminem lol
 
Last edited:
rip.dilla;724388 said:
'Sing For The Moment'... the realest shit Marshall wrote

By far, yes. I think it's one of the most well put together hip hop tracks that explain a hip hop mentality.
 
Last edited:
ShadyTeam;724389 said:
Yeh it's a certified classics and arguably Eminem's best Album it's a very deep and personal Album

The Marshall Mathers LP is historic though that Album went far beyond Hip-Hop it's an genre historic Album

The Slim Shady LP is arguably his best Album too

that's 3 universally accepted classics with THe Marshall Mathers LP being like a Hip-Hop Bible that history, crowds packing out stadiums when that Album came out, people buying posters, people just going crazy for Eminem lol

I'm a huge Eminem fan but I don't accept MMLP or SSLP as classics only because of it's content. It's not diverse, it's all solely one subject usually. Not saying it's, "not hip hop" it is, but to it's own extent. It's a branch off, horrorcore more so. It's not as fragile as TES, this was Eminem's make or break for hip hop, where he can get SERIOUS respect. In that, he did. It was, here's my lyrical ability, my serious side of the story, and my love for hip hop album. That's what made it a classic.
 
Last edited:
The Eminem Show is a classic, agreed. The only thing that may hold it back is the production, but I am with the opinion that the beats perfectly suit eminem's rapping.

I think its slims best album.
 
Last edited:
Capo1;725249 said:
The Eminem Show is a classic, agreed. The only thing that may hold it back is the production, but I am with the opinion that the beats perfectly suit eminem's rapping.

I think its slims best album.

Beat's on the Album were mad dope

Superman

Till I Collapse

Say Goodbye To Hollywood

White America

With Out Me

Square Dance

Soldier

Drip's

Do you own The Slim Shady LP & The Marshall Mathers LP
 
Last edited:
SSLP is the real classic, fuck all this TES/MMLP nonsense. Especially TES with it's overproduced tracks and r&b hooks
 
Last edited:
Guys le's be real man...A good album it is, classic it isn't...And you're tryna say definite classic?...Nah man...MMLP was his best effort...TES was good, but, outta the 15 songs ( obviously not includin' skits) 5 are not up to scratch...Drips, When the Music Stops, Without Me, Hailie's Song and Say What You Say...And fuck it, through My Dad's Gone Crazy in there...Them songs are not good enough...In an album its cool to have a song or 2 not be on them high levels but the album still be considered classic, but, there are waay too many sub-par tracks
 
Last edited:
choppa_style;725682 said:
SSLP is the real classic, fuck all this TES/MMLP nonsense. Especially TES with it's overproduced tracks and r&b hooks

this makes sense to me, SSLP > TES > MMLP

fuck you dretox btw
 
Last edited:

Members online

Trending content

Thread statistics

Created
-,
Last reply from
-,
Replies
5,448
Views
2,826
Back
Top
Menu
Your profile
Post thread…