The Bible says the book of Exodus never happened

  • Thread starter Thread starter New Editor
  • Start date Start date
Fosheezy;c-10033460 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10031547 said:
I love the New Testament, but the Old Testament is frankly a bit weird.

Like it's hard for me to understand how Job's story could possibly paint God in anything but a negative light. He pretty much turned his most faithful and righteous servant's life into a living hell just to win a bet with Satan. Kinda crazy.

It is kinda messed up, yea... it wasn’t because some bet though. The scriptures don’t even reveal why Job went through all that and even after it was all done Job was never told by God why he went through it either.

Nah dog, it's pretty clear. Satan goes to God bashing humanity. God brings up Job. Satan says Job is only good because God protects him. God gives Satan permission to take everything from Job as long as he doesn't harm Job. They even revisit the washer when Job's faith holds.

kingblaze84;c-10037705 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10031547 said:
I love the New Testament, but the Old Testament is frankly a bit weird.

Like it's hard for me to understand how Job's story could possibly paint God in anything but a negative light. He pretty much turned his most faithful and righteous servant's life into a living hell just to win a bet with Satan. Kinda crazy.

The funny thing about the Bible is that it itself proves just how demonic and evil the Bible god truly is. If Satan was truly real, he did the right thing turning his back on such an evil being.

I wouldn't say Demonic. Basically God is the creator and he can do what he wants. He makes use of that freedom. There is very little in the Old Testament that he does that isn't justified. It just doesn't jive with our understanding of a merciful God. The theme of the Old Testament is that humans are a shitty creation and we're lucky God didn't just wipe us out. Now what that says about God as a creator is debatable. Lol
 
The Lonious Monk;c-10038484 said:
Fosheezy;c-10033460 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10031547 said:
I love the New Testament, but the Old Testament is frankly a bit weird.

Like it's hard for me to understand how Job's story could possibly paint God in anything but a negative light. He pretty much turned his most faithful and righteous servant's life into a living hell just to win a bet with Satan. Kinda crazy.

It is kinda messed up, yea... it wasn’t because some bet though. The scriptures don’t even reveal why Job went through all that and even after it was all done Job was never told by God why he went through it either.

Nah dog, it's pretty clear. Satan goes to God bashing humanity. God brings up Job. Satan says Job is only good because God protects him. God gives Satan permission to take everything from Job as long as he doesn't harm Job. They even revisit the washer when Job's faith holds.

kingblaze84;c-10037705 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10031547 said:
I love the New Testament, but the Old Testament is frankly a bit weird.

Like it's hard for me to understand how Job's story could possibly paint God in anything but a negative light. He pretty much turned his most faithful and righteous servant's life into a living hell just to win a bet with Satan. Kinda crazy.

The funny thing about the Bible is that it itself proves just how demonic and evil the Bible god truly is. If Satan was truly real, he did the right thing turning his back on such an evil being.

I wouldn't say Demonic. Basically God is the creator and he can do what he wants. He makes use of that freedom. There is very little in the Old Testament that he does that isn't justified. It just doesn't jive with our understanding of a merciful God. The theme of the Old Testament is that humans are a shitty creation and we're lucky God didn't just wipe us out. Now what that says about God as a creator is debatable. Lol

Well it says the Bible god made some mistakes during creation lol. Humans are a reflection of god supposedly, so that speaks for itself. And the Bible god does some pretty fucked up things in the OT, it even admits to creating evil and calamity, what a guy.
 
kingblaze84;c-10043238 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10038484 said:
Fosheezy;c-10033460 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10031547 said:
I love the New Testament, but the Old Testament is frankly a bit weird.

Like it's hard for me to understand how Job's story could possibly paint God in anything but a negative light. He pretty much turned his most faithful and righteous servant's life into a living hell just to win a bet with Satan. Kinda crazy.

It is kinda messed up, yea... it wasn’t because some bet though. The scriptures don’t even reveal why Job went through all that and even after it was all done Job was never told by God why he went through it either.

Nah dog, it's pretty clear. Satan goes to God bashing humanity. God brings up Job. Satan says Job is only good because God protects him. God gives Satan permission to take everything from Job as long as he doesn't harm Job. They even revisit the washer when Job's faith holds.

kingblaze84;c-10037705 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10031547 said:
I love the New Testament, but the Old Testament is frankly a bit weird.

Like it's hard for me to understand how Job's story could possibly paint God in anything but a negative light. He pretty much turned his most faithful and righteous servant's life into a living hell just to win a bet with Satan. Kinda crazy.

The funny thing about the Bible is that it itself proves just how demonic and evil the Bible god truly is. If Satan was truly real, he did the right thing turning his back on such an evil being.

I wouldn't say Demonic. Basically God is the creator and he can do what he wants. He makes use of that freedom. There is very little in the Old Testament that he does that isn't justified. It just doesn't jive with our understanding of a merciful God. The theme of the Old Testament is that humans are a shitty creation and we're lucky God didn't just wipe us out. Now what that says about God as a creator is debatable. Lol

Well it says the Bible god made some mistakes during creation lol. Humans are a reflection of god supposedly, so that speaks for itself. And the Bible god does some pretty fucked up things in the OT, it even admits to creating evil and calamity, what a guy.

This is one thing me and my pastor always disagree on. He says the that God is incapable of mistakes. I say the Bible clearly suggests otherwise. It says that when God saw how murderous humans were, he regretted making them and wished he hadn't done it. To me, that clearly means that God saw making humans as being a mistake. My pastor believes that regret for God doesn't mean what we think it means. That was just the best way of describing God's feelings since his ways are different than ours. I don't buy it. I agree that God's ways may be beyond our understanding, but if the Bible says he regretted something, I'm going to take it at that.

On another note, I don't think God created evil in the way you mean it. After all, evil is kinda defined as being the opposite of God's will, so evil and sin were created more or less as a consequence God's existence and will. God did do some weird things though. Like if you read the story with Pharaoh and Moses, it clearly says that on more than one occasion, Pharaoh was ready to let the Jews go and be done with it all, but God hardened his heart. It's unclear why, but God really wanted to fuck the Egyptians over.
 
Regretting making something doesn’t mean he did anything wrong as “mistake” implies. God made everybody upright.

You think God had direct control over Pharoah when it comes to him letting the Hebrew slaves go?
 
Fosheezy;c-10043954 said:
Regretting making something doesn’t mean he did anything wrong as “mistake” implies. God made everybody upright.

You think God had direct control over Pharoah when it comes to him letting the Hebrew slaves go?

It does if you're supposed to be a perfect being. If God is omnipotent and omniscient, then he was capable of creating truly up right humans and knew what would happen with the humans he did create. If he regretted making humanity, that means he wish he hadn't of done it. What is do you call it when you do something you wish you didn't.

As far as Pharaoh goes, he was going to let the Jews go several times before the final plague and he was done with them after the final plague.

Exodus 9:12 But the Lord hardened Pharaoh’s heart and he would not listen to Moses and Aaron, just as the Lord had said to Moses.

Exodus 10:20 But the Lord hardened Pharaoh’s heart, and he would not let the Israelites go.

Exodus 10:27 But the Lord hardened Pharaoh’s heart, and he was not willing to let them go.

Exodus 11:10 Moses and Aaron performed all these wonders before Pharaoh, but the Lord hardened Pharaoh’s heart, and he would not let the Israelites go out of his country.

Exodus 14:4 And I will harden Pharaoh’s heart, and he will pursue them. But I will gain glory for myself through Pharaoh and all his army, and the Egyptians will know that I am the Lord.” So the Israelites did this.

So basically, Pharaoh starts off being against letting the Israelites go until he has enough of the plagues. After that, God basically keeps him from letting them go. Then after Pharaoh finally is allowed to let them go, God is the one that gets him to pursue the Israelites, all so he can get glory from destroying the Egyptian soldiers.
 
Last edited:
If god created the perfect upright humans we wouldn't we here discussing this, we'd still be like mindless animals with no freewill or self awareness.
 
The Lonious Monk;c-10043846 said:
kingblaze84;c-10043238 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10038484 said:
Fosheezy;c-10033460 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10031547 said:
I love the New Testament, but the Old Testament is frankly a bit weird.

Like it's hard for me to understand how Job's story could possibly paint God in anything but a negative light. He pretty much turned his most faithful and righteous servant's life into a living hell just to win a bet with Satan. Kinda crazy.

It is kinda messed up, yea... it wasn’t because some bet though. The scriptures don’t even reveal why Job went through all that and even after it was all done Job was never told by God why he went through it either.

Nah dog, it's pretty clear. Satan goes to God bashing humanity. God brings up Job. Satan says Job is only good because God protects him. God gives Satan permission to take everything from Job as long as he doesn't harm Job. They even revisit the washer when Job's faith holds.

kingblaze84;c-10037705 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10031547 said:
I love the New Testament, but the Old Testament is frankly a bit weird.

Like it's hard for me to understand how Job's story could possibly paint God in anything but a negative light. He pretty much turned his most faithful and righteous servant's life into a living hell just to win a bet with Satan. Kinda crazy.

The funny thing about the Bible is that it itself proves just how demonic and evil the Bible god truly is. If Satan was truly real, he did the right thing turning his back on such an evil being.

I wouldn't say Demonic. Basically God is the creator and he can do what he wants. He makes use of that freedom. There is very little in the Old Testament that he does that isn't justified. It just doesn't jive with our understanding of a merciful God. The theme of the Old Testament is that humans are a shitty creation and we're lucky God didn't just wipe us out. Now what that says about God as a creator is debatable. Lol

Well it says the Bible god made some mistakes during creation lol. Humans are a reflection of god supposedly, so that speaks for itself. And the Bible god does some pretty fucked up things in the OT, it even admits to creating evil and calamity, what a guy.

This is one thing me and my pastor always disagree on. He says the that God is incapable of mistakes. I say the Bible clearly suggests otherwise. It says that when God saw how murderous humans were, he regretted making them and wished he hadn't done it. To me, that clearly means that God saw making humans as being a mistake. My pastor believes that regret for God doesn't mean what we think it means. That was just the best way of describing God's feelings since his ways are different than ours. I don't buy it. I agree that God's ways may be beyond our understanding, but if the Bible says he regretted something, I'm going to take it at that.

On another note, I don't think God created evil in the way you mean it. After all, evil is kinda defined as being the opposite of God's will, so evil and sin were created more or less as a consequence God's existence and will. God did do some weird things though. Like if you read the story with Pharaoh and Moses, it clearly says that on more than one occasion, Pharaoh was ready to let the Jews go and be done with it all, but God hardened his heart. It's unclear why, but God really wanted to fuck the Egyptians over.

It really is weird that the Bible god could regret making humanity, isn't it all knowing and all powerful, etc etc? So how the hell could he not see us coming? It's all part of the weird contradictions that makes me think the Bible god is just a figment of peoples' imaginations. It drowned the whole world supposedly, yet it failed to create a better version of humans or something that could replace us.

And as far as evil, the Bible god makes clear that HE create calamity and evil, and we all know what those things consist of. Humans can be even more cruel then regular animals, so why would such a "good" god create such things? Doesn't seem godlike to me. I would forgive those things if the Bible god could at least prove it's powerful, or at least half of what it claims to be. I can see why so many Jews are atheist. Otherwise, I do believe there is something out there, but the Bible god makes less and less sense to me and many others these days.
 
Last edited:
BiblicalAtheist ;c-10044277 said:
If god created the perfect upright humans we wouldn't we here discussing this, we'd still be like mindless animals with no freewill or self awareness.

Does free will TRULY exist.....?

Think about it, yes we have many choices in life, but notice some have better choices to choose from since birth. Is that truly free will?
 
kingblaze84;c-10045644 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10043846 said:
kingblaze84;c-10043238 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10038484 said:
Fosheezy;c-10033460 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10031547 said:
I love the New Testament, but the Old Testament is frankly a bit weird.

Like it's hard for me to understand how Job's story could possibly paint God in anything but a negative light. He pretty much turned his most faithful and righteous servant's life into a living hell just to win a bet with Satan. Kinda crazy.

It is kinda messed up, yea... it wasn’t because some bet though. The scriptures don’t even reveal why Job went through all that and even after it was all done Job was never told by God why he went through it either.

Nah dog, it's pretty clear. Satan goes to God bashing humanity. God brings up Job. Satan says Job is only good because God protects him. God gives Satan permission to take everything from Job as long as he doesn't harm Job. They even revisit the washer when Job's faith holds.

kingblaze84;c-10037705 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10031547 said:
I love the New Testament, but the Old Testament is frankly a bit weird.

Like it's hard for me to understand how Job's story could possibly paint God in anything but a negative light. He pretty much turned his most faithful and righteous servant's life into a living hell just to win a bet with Satan. Kinda crazy.

The funny thing about the Bible is that it itself proves just how demonic and evil the Bible god truly is. If Satan was truly real, he did the right thing turning his back on such an evil being.

I wouldn't say Demonic. Basically God is the creator and he can do what he wants. He makes use of that freedom. There is very little in the Old Testament that he does that isn't justified. It just doesn't jive with our understanding of a merciful God. The theme of the Old Testament is that humans are a shitty creation and we're lucky God didn't just wipe us out. Now what that says about God as a creator is debatable. Lol

Well it says the Bible god made some mistakes during creation lol. Humans are a reflection of god supposedly, so that speaks for itself. And the Bible god does some pretty fucked up things in the OT, it even admits to creating evil and calamity, what a guy.

This is one thing me and my pastor always disagree on. He says the that God is incapable of mistakes. I say the Bible clearly suggests otherwise. It says that when God saw how murderous humans were, he regretted making them and wished he hadn't done it. To me, that clearly means that God saw making humans as being a mistake. My pastor believes that regret for God doesn't mean what we think it means. That was just the best way of describing God's feelings since his ways are different than ours. I don't buy it. I agree that God's ways may be beyond our understanding, but if the Bible says he regretted something, I'm going to take it at that.

On another note, I don't think God created evil in the way you mean it. After all, evil is kinda defined as being the opposite of God's will, so evil and sin were created more or less as a consequence God's existence and will. God did do some weird things though. Like if you read the story with Pharaoh and Moses, it clearly says that on more than one occasion, Pharaoh was ready to let the Jews go and be done with it all, but God hardened his heart. It's unclear why, but God really wanted to fuck the Egyptians over.

It really is weird that the Bible god could regret making humanity, isn't it all knowing and all powerful, etc etc? So how the hell could he not see us coming? It's all part of the weird contradictions that makes me think the Bible god is just a figment of peoples' imaginations. It drowned the whole world supposedly, yet it failed to create a better version of humans or something that could replace us.

And as far as evil, the Bible god makes clear that HE create calamity and evil, and we all know what those things consist of. Humans can be even more cruel then regular animals, so why would such a "good" god create such things? Doesn't seem godlike to me. I would forgive those things if the Bible god could at least prove it's powerful, or at least half of what it claims to be. I can see why so many Jews are atheist. Otherwise, I do believe there is something out there, but the Bible god makes less and less sense to me and many others these days.

Well, when you read the Bible as a whole and put some of the pieces together, some of what you have a problem with makes sense.

So God did know that humans would be bad. It's basically a consequence of our free will. We have a choice, we means we can choose not to obey God. So it is inevitable that we would eventually do so. That's pretty much why God let Satan into the Garden of Eden. It was basically a setup because God knew humanity would sin eventually. However, God had a plan to save humanity for sin--Jesus. However, people have to choose Jesus to be saved by him. The Old Testament more or less is there to show us that we can't rise above sin without Jesus and the Holy Spirit. God gave humanity laws and humanity broke them time and time again. With Jesus' death, we are given an opportunity to obtain salvation by choosing God, which is what he always wanted.

Now, I ask for God's forgiveness, but to be frank, the Bible makes him out to be pretty petty. He does almost everything to stroke his own ego. That said, anyone who can create a universe or a race of people has the right to do what God has done. As bad as God seems at times, the reason he is as heavy handed as he is is because of how fucked up humanity is. The whole reason he wanted to kill off humanity with the flood is because people wouldn't stop killing each other.
 
kingblaze84;c-10045651 said:
BiblicalAtheist ;c-10044277 said:
If god created the perfect upright humans we wouldn't we here discussing this, we'd still be like mindless animals with no freewill or self awareness.

Does free will TRULY exist.....?

Think about it, yes we have many choices in life, but notice some have better choices to choose from since birth. Is that truly free will?

Yes.

Freewill as the will to want is free indeed. Free from restrictions and conditions, in stark contrast to current understanding of freewill meaning, you can do whatever you want without restrictions and conditions, which clearly is not true.
 
You could have an opinion, but an opinion is just that. the Bible already answers both the questions of whether God is perfect and whether mankind was made perfect though. Most people that’s not Christian in any instance they find out that the Bible don’t support their preconceived idea of how they think God “should” be, they decide the Bible has to fit their personal view or it’s wrong. That’s how most people think. And that is why most people are lost.
 
The Lonious Monk;c-10045835 said:
kingblaze84;c-10045644 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10043846 said:
kingblaze84;c-10043238 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10038484 said:
Fosheezy;c-10033460 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10031547 said:
I love the New Testament, but the Old Testament is frankly a bit weird.

Like it's hard for me to understand how Job's story could possibly paint God in anything but a negative light. He pretty much turned his most faithful and righteous servant's life into a living hell just to win a bet with Satan. Kinda crazy.

It is kinda messed up, yea... it wasn’t because some bet though. The scriptures don’t even reveal why Job went through all that and even after it was all done Job was never told by God why he went through it either.

Nah dog, it's pretty clear. Satan goes to God bashing humanity. God brings up Job. Satan says Job is only good because God protects him. God gives Satan permission to take everything from Job as long as he doesn't harm Job. They even revisit the washer when Job's faith holds.

kingblaze84;c-10037705 said:
The Lonious Monk;c-10031547 said:
I love the New Testament, but the Old Testament is frankly a bit weird.

Like it's hard for me to understand how Job's story could possibly paint God in anything but a negative light. He pretty much turned his most faithful and righteous servant's life into a living hell just to win a bet with Satan. Kinda crazy.

The funny thing about the Bible is that it itself proves just how demonic and evil the Bible god truly is. If Satan was truly real, he did the right thing turning his back on such an evil being.

I wouldn't say Demonic. Basically God is the creator and he can do what he wants. He makes use of that freedom. There is very little in the Old Testament that he does that isn't justified. It just doesn't jive with our understanding of a merciful God. The theme of the Old Testament is that humans are a shitty creation and we're lucky God didn't just wipe us out. Now what that says about God as a creator is debatable. Lol

Well it says the Bible god made some mistakes during creation lol. Humans are a reflection of god supposedly, so that speaks for itself. And the Bible god does some pretty fucked up things in the OT, it even admits to creating evil and calamity, what a guy.

This is one thing me and my pastor always disagree on. He says the that God is incapable of mistakes. I say the Bible clearly suggests otherwise. It says that when God saw how murderous humans were, he regretted making them and wished he hadn't done it. To me, that clearly means that God saw making humans as being a mistake. My pastor believes that regret for God doesn't mean what we think it means. That was just the best way of describing God's feelings since his ways are different than ours. I don't buy it. I agree that God's ways may be beyond our understanding, but if the Bible says he regretted something, I'm going to take it at that.

On another note, I don't think God created evil in the way you mean it. After all, evil is kinda defined as being the opposite of God's will, so evil and sin were created more or less as a consequence God's existence and will. God did do some weird things though. Like if you read the story with Pharaoh and Moses, it clearly says that on more than one occasion, Pharaoh was ready to let the Jews go and be done with it all, but God hardened his heart. It's unclear why, but God really wanted to fuck the Egyptians over.

It really is weird that the Bible god could regret making humanity, isn't it all knowing and all powerful, etc etc? So how the hell could he not see us coming? It's all part of the weird contradictions that makes me think the Bible god is just a figment of peoples' imaginations. It drowned the whole world supposedly, yet it failed to create a better version of humans or something that could replace us.

And as far as evil, the Bible god makes clear that HE create calamity and evil, and we all know what those things consist of. Humans can be even more cruel then regular animals, so why would such a "good" god create such things? Doesn't seem godlike to me. I would forgive those things if the Bible god could at least prove it's powerful, or at least half of what it claims to be. I can see why so many Jews are atheist. Otherwise, I do believe there is something out there, but the Bible god makes less and less sense to me and many others these days.

Well, when you read the Bible as a whole and put some of the pieces together, some of what you have a problem with makes sense.

So God did know that humans would be bad. It's basically a consequence of our free will. We have a choice, we means we can choose not to obey God. So it is inevitable that we would eventually do so. That's pretty much why God let Satan into the Garden of Eden. It was basically a setup because God knew humanity would sin eventually. However, God had a plan to save humanity for sin--Jesus. However, people have to choose Jesus to be saved by him. The Old Testament more or less is there to show us that we can't rise above sin without Jesus and the Holy Spirit. God gave humanity laws and humanity broke them time and time again. With Jesus' death, we are given an opportunity to obtain salvation by choosing God, which is what he always wanted.

Now, I ask for God's forgiveness, but to be frank, the Bible makes him out to be pretty petty. He does almost everything to stroke his own ego. That said, anyone who can create a universe or a race of people has the right to do what God has done. As bad as God seems at times, the reason he is as heavy handed as he is is because of how fucked up humanity is. The whole reason he wanted to kill off humanity with the flood is because people wouldn't stop killing each other.

Jesus saved humanity? How, WW2 killed over 100 million people maybe, and WW1 killed maybe 20 million. Humans are still doing the same thing fucked up things we've ever done, and I didn't exactly see god doing much to save his "chosen people" during the Holocaust lol. Forgive me for being skeptical, but I just don't see Jesus being all that powerful. How can non-Christians choose the Bible god when there is no evidence it's even a powerful being? The Bible god is always playing a game of hide and seek and for some reason enjoys constantly hiding haha.

We do agree the Bible god seems very petty. I just don't find that to be a godlike quality. Especially when that same Bible god admits to creating evil and calamity, things that are very natural in nature (calamity specifically). I agree humanity is fucked up, but the Bible god is way more fucked up then humans are. Brain eating parasites are natural things, yet the Bible god admits to creating such things. That technically makes the Bible god just as evil as Hitler or Genghis Khan. I see no difference between the three, assuming the Bible god is even real.

In fact, the Bible god, if the Bible is correct, is WAAAAYYY more evil then Hitler and Genghis Khan. What was the purpose of creating brain eating parasites, if not for pure sadistic pleasure? Parasites kill and torture millions every year LOL.....remember, the Bible god admits to creating calamity and everything else. This is why I consider the Bible god a demon instead of a god.
 
Last edited:
BiblicalAtheist ;c-10044277 said:
If god created the perfect upright humans we wouldn't we here discussing this, we'd still be like mindless animals with no freewill or self awareness.

Yea kinda like babies?
 
BiblicalAtheist ;c-10045990 said:
kingblaze84;c-10045651 said:
BiblicalAtheist ;c-10044277 said:
If god created the perfect upright humans we wouldn't we here discussing this, we'd still be like mindless animals with no freewill or self awareness.

Does free will TRULY exist.....?

Think about it, yes we have many choices in life, but notice some have better choices to choose from since birth. Is that truly free will?

Yes.

Freewill as the will to want is free indeed. Free from restrictions and conditions, in stark contrast to current understanding of freewill meaning, you can do whatever you want without restrictions and conditions, which clearly is not true.

We can will to want anything. I can will to be an angel with wings who also has superhuman strength and laser beam eyes like Superman, doesn't mean it can actually happen.

So what you're describing seems more like controlled will. Yes, we can THINK about all kinds of choices, but in reality, only some can really push the boundaries of what is possible. A child dying of various diseases and born with no eyes only has so much free will. That child will be dependent on others for a very long time, if not forever. A person born with no legs and to a very poor family in Ethiopia has very limited choices compared to the children of Michael Jordan or Warren Buffet.

This doesn't sound like free will to me. Limited will might be the more appropriate phrase? But FREE will is a complete dream to millions, if not billions of people out there in the world.
 
Last edited:
kingblaze84;c-10046023 said:
BiblicalAtheist ;c-10045990 said:
kingblaze84;c-10045651 said:
BiblicalAtheist ;c-10044277 said:
If god created the perfect upright humans we wouldn't we here discussing this, we'd still be like mindless animals with no freewill or self awareness.

Does free will TRULY exist.....?

Think about it, yes we have many choices in life, but notice some have better choices to choose from since birth. Is that truly free will?

Yes.

Freewill as the will to want is free indeed. Free from restrictions and conditions, in stark contrast to current understanding of freewill meaning, you can do whatever you want without restrictions and conditions, which clearly is not true.

We can will to want anything. I can will to be an angel with wings who also has superhuman strength and laser beam eyes like Superman, doesn't mean it can actually happen.

So what you're describing seems more like controlled will. Yes, we can THINK about all kinds of choices, but in reality, only some can really push the boundaries of what is possible. A child dying of various diseases and born with no eyes only has so much free will. That child will be dependent on others for a very long time, if not forever. A person born with no legs and to a very poor family in Ethiopia has very limited choices compared to the children of Michael Jordan or Warren Buffet.

This doesn't sound like free will to me. Limited will might be the more appropriate phrase? But FREE will is a complete dream to millions, if not billions of people out there in the world.

That is why I made the point of distinction between the two. You can Will to want something until the day you die, no one can take that away, not even if they kill you. You can want for* anything, there are no restrictions to that. The blind gimped up kid has no freewill in the classical sense, neither do you mind, that freewill does not exist.
 
Last edited:
kingblaze84;c-10046017 said:
Jesus saved humanity? How, WW2 killed over 100 million people maybe, and WW1 killed maybe 20 million. Humans are still doing the same thing fucked up things we've ever done, and I didn't exactly see god doing much to save his "chosen people" during the Holocaust lol. Forgive me for being skeptical, but I just don't see Jesus being all that powerful. How can non-Christians choose the Bible god when there is no evidence it's even a powerful being? The Bible god is always playing a game of hide and seek and for some reason enjoys constantly hiding haha.

We do agree the Bible god seems very petty. I just don't find that to be a godlike quality. Especially when that same Bible god admits to creating evil and calamity, things that are very natural in nature (calamity specifically). I agree humanity is fucked up, but the Bible god is way more fucked up then humans are. Brain eating parasites are natural things, yet the Bible god admits to creating such things. That technically makes the Bible god just as evil as Hitler or Genghis Khan. I see no difference between the three, assuming the Bible god is even real.

In fact, the Bible god, if the Bible is correct, is WAAAAYYY more evil then Hitler and Genghis Khan. What was the purpose of creating brain eating parasites, if not for pure sadistic pleasure? Parasites kill and torture millions every year LOL.....remember, the Bible god admits to creating calamity and everything else. This is why I consider the Bible god a demon instead of a god.

Jesus save humanity by offering humans that choose him an opportunity for salvation. Yes, the world is still full of evil, but with Jesus, people who accept him can be saved and reach Heaven. Without Jesus everyone die and go to Hell.

I'm not really sure what more you want to believe that God is a powerful being. Either you believe the Bible or not. If you believe the Bible, then clearly did numerous things that demonstrate his power. If you don't believe the Bible, I'm not sure why you'd even care about what the Christian faith dictates.

What you're calling evil isn't really evil. The Bible says that God created everything, but things have obviously evolved since creation. There are animals alive now that weren't alive thousands of years ago. However, God did tell Adam and Eve that a world of misery would be their punishment for sinning. Again, you can't compare God to people. Hitler had no right to kill 6 million Jews. God has every right to punish his creation for failing him. You can say that his punishment isn't particularly merciful, but that doesn't make it evil.
 
The Lonious Monk;c-10046529 said:
kingblaze84;c-10046017 said:
Jesus saved humanity? How, WW2 killed over 100 million people maybe, and WW1 killed maybe 20 million. Humans are still doing the same thing fucked up things we've ever done, and I didn't exactly see god doing much to save his "chosen people" during the Holocaust lol. Forgive me for being skeptical, but I just don't see Jesus being all that powerful. How can non-Christians choose the Bible god when there is no evidence it's even a powerful being? The Bible god is always playing a game of hide and seek and for some reason enjoys constantly hiding haha.

We do agree the Bible god seems very petty. I just don't find that to be a godlike quality. Especially when that same Bible god admits to creating evil and calamity, things that are very natural in nature (calamity specifically). I agree humanity is fucked up, but the Bible god is way more fucked up then humans are. Brain eating parasites are natural things, yet the Bible god admits to creating such things. That technically makes the Bible god just as evil as Hitler or Genghis Khan. I see no difference between the three, assuming the Bible god is even real.

In fact, the Bible god, if the Bible is correct, is WAAAAYYY more evil then Hitler and Genghis Khan. What was the purpose of creating brain eating parasites, if not for pure sadistic pleasure? Parasites kill and torture millions every year LOL.....remember, the Bible god admits to creating calamity and everything else. This is why I consider the Bible god a demon instead of a god.

Jesus save humanity by offering humans that choose him an opportunity for salvation. Yes, the world is still full of evil, but with Jesus, people who accept him can be saved and reach Heaven. Without Jesus everyone die and go to Hell.

I'm not really sure what more you want to believe that God is a powerful being. Either you believe the Bible or not. If you believe the Bible, then clearly did numerous things that demonstrate his power. If you don't believe the Bible, I'm not sure why you'd even care about what the Christian faith dictates.

What you're calling evil isn't really evil. The Bible says that God created everything, but things have obviously evolved since creation. There are animals alive now that weren't alive thousands of years ago. However, God did tell Adam and Eve that a world of misery would be their punishment for sinning. Again, you can't compare God to people. Hitler had no right to kill 6 million Jews. God has every right to punish his creation for failing him. You can say that his punishment isn't particularly merciful, but that doesn't make it evil.

The only reason I care a little about what Christian faith dictates is because of some of the preachers I run into on the subway train lol, otherwise it's pretty obvious I'm far from the religious type. I'm skeptical of anything that can't prove itself and therefore I'm skeptical about ALL religions, not just Christianity. I can believe there is a powerful force out there, but I don't see evidence the Bible god is even alive anymore, assuming it ever was alive.

Your faith seems strong, and I certainly respect that. I just don't see how the same Bible god that claims to be good and righteous can also be the same god that admits to creating evil and calamity. The Bible god, if real, seems extremely evil to me because it admits to creating literally ALL of the horrors of the world. Parasites, worms that grow out of peoples' skin and eyes, all kinds of naturally crazy shit. I'm not sure how Christians do it, but I personally could NEVER worship that kind of god. I would feel like I'm worshipping Ted Bundy or Jeffrey Dahmer lol, something more evil then them in fact.

But to each his own. A "god" like the Bible god that holds grudges after 2,000 plus years seems petty as fuck and unworthy of my worship. I'm still puzzled as to why anyone would worship a god like that.
 
Last edited:
The Bible god admits to creating ALL things......so I guess it made these things too......


How is the Bible god not a deranged and twisted evil psychopath then? After all, it made ALL things......right? The people who made up the Bible really fucked up when they said its god made all things LOL......I can only conclude if the Bible god is real, it's a deranged psychopath demon no different then the sickest slave master or the most fucked up scientist from Nazi Germany. Such a being must be a demon, far from a god.

 
Last edited:
kingblaze84;c-10047355 said:
The only reason I care a little about what Christian faith dictates is because of some of the preachers I run into on the subway train lol, otherwise it's pretty obvious I'm far from the religious type. I'm skeptical of anything that can't prove itself and therefore I'm skeptical about ALL religions, not just Christianity. I can believe there is a powerful force out there, but I don't see evidence the Bible god is even alive anymore, assuming it ever was alive.

Your faith seems strong, and I certainly respect that. I just don't see how the same Bible god that claims to be good and righteous can also be the same god that admits to creating evil and calamity. The Bible god, if real, seems extremely evil to me because it admits to creating literally ALL of the horrors of the world. Parasites, worms that grow out of peoples' skin and eyes, all kinds of naturally crazy shit. I'm not sure how Christians do it, but I personally could NEVER worship that kind of god. I would feel like I'm worshipping Ted Bundy or Jeffrey Dahmer lol, something more evil then them in fact.

But to each his own. A "god" like the Bible god that holds grudges after 2,000 plus years seems petty as fuck and unworthy of my worship. I'm still puzzled as to why anyone would worship a god like that.

I get where you're coming from. Any religious person that is honest will have to admit that they questioned their faith at some point. In my opinion, if they haven't they aren't true believers, they've just been indoctrinated. We don't have all the answers and religion is faith based, so everyone is going to run into something that makes them wonder.

I'm a scientist by training so I, like you, like to see empirical evidence for things. You're just not going to get that from Christianity. God wants us to live by faith, so taking that leap is something you have to do. For me, I was raised as a Christian, and went through a (long) phase where I didn't really live like a Christian. I always stayed connected in sense though because even though I didn't understand everything about the Bible (and still don't), I still believed Jesus' teachings were correct. I can definitely say that since I took steps to restore my faith, my life has gotten better. That's not to say everything is perfect or that there are no struggles, but I'm at peace and I've found myself either getting everything I needed/wanted or being able to deal more easily without having. That's really all I needed for me to believe God is real.

As for the other things you're saying, God created everything period. So yes evil and calamity are in that, but it didn't happen in the way you're making it seem. For instance, if God created light, then he also created darkness because darkness is just the absence of light. That doesn't mean that he purposely created a state where people can't see so that they'd stumble and hurt themselves. That's kinda how you're twisting things. From a Biblical standpoint, goodness and harmony come from God. Evil and calamity are analgous to darkness in that they are basically the opposite of those things. God is goodness, so evil is basically anything that opposes him. So in that sense, he created evil, but again, he didn't do it in the way or for the reasons that you're implying. The argument you're making about the worms and parasites seems kinda silly to me though. God created a world with diverse life. Life has evolved since he created it. I don't think God micromanages that type of thing just like I don't believe he's holding the earth and manually spinning it every day. Such misery that you mention was not present in the Garden of Eden, which was the place meant for mankind. It only came about afterwards as part of this imperfect world. What you seem to ignore is that this world is just a stepping stone to the next by Christian faith. So what if you live ~70 years of misery if it leads to you living the rest of eternity in bliss. Just think of Earth as a proving grounds or basic training. It may be rough and you may not understand why you have to go through it all, but if you make it through, things will become clear and it will be worth it in the end. I'm not sure what you mean by God holding a grudge for 2000+ years though.
 

Members online

Trending content

Thread statistics

Created
BiblicalAtheist,
Last reply from
-,
Replies
65
Views
16
Back
Top
Menu
Your profile
Post thread…