TheGOAT;c-10046495 said:
5 Grand;c-10046471 said:
TheGOAT;c-10046384 said:
5 Grand;c-10046353 said:
nawledge_god;c-10046320 said:
Reasonable Doubt Over Cuban Linx And AEOM? Some Revisionist Bullshit
Yeah Reasonable Doubt didn't make a peep when it dropped.
This argument is always dumb
It dont matter what happened in the moment... Carter3 was all the hype when it dropped dont make it better than RD
RD >>>>> all the albums listed in this thread
@ the bolded. Thats a matter of opinion.
Saying Reasonable Doubt didn't make a peep when it dropped is a matter of fact.
RD was a good album, but The Score came out around the same time. That album was huge and it still has replay value.
Whats your point?
The popularity of an album when it 1st dropped dont make it better than another.
Illmatics came out a couple weeks before Beastie Boys Ill Communication
Beastie Boys album was way bigger... Made more "noise"
Illmatic the better album
For an album to stand the test of time and prove itself better in the long run makes it more impressive
1. Ill Communication was a decent album. In fact, I saw them at Lalapalooza with A Tribe Called Quest, Green Day, George Clinton and a handful of other groups I can't remember.
2. Are you saying impact isn't a factor when comparing albums? I can think of some dope albums that didn't have any impact at all.
I'd say an album that made a big impact is inherently better than an album that didn't make an impact...in most cases, Please Hammer Don't Hurt Em notwithstanding.