When I'm Gone by Eminem how do u rate this Song?

[achewon87]

So basically a promotion thread because your not saying anything...

 

[GunTown]

The last good song by a drugged out Em. You can hear that he was still fighting off the previous night's hangover, but the story of that song was deep as hell. I thought for a while that he was gonna kill himself after that song, so I appreciated it for what it was. And When I'm Gone>>>>>>>>>>>anything off Encore.

Yeah it's 1 of those songs that is really personal. I think what people have to realize is people listen to hip hop for different reasons this 1 of those songs that puts listeners in a zone and connects to people who like this type of Hip Hop

I'm not gonna say a person has to relate to appreciate deep Songs but i feel if 1 can relate that can make a difference

 

[GunTown]

I think it's a classic song because of the lyrics and message in the lyrics really deep lyrics, had a lotta emotion, was really personal, had a classic hook, classic flow, classic beat, great delivery. Can relate to the Song. 1 of those Songs that helps u through difficult situations

how are u gonna explain why its classic by using the word classic? are all personal songs classic? don trip letter to his son classic? will smith just the two of us classic? nas daughters classic?

Of course not all personal songs are classic. U gotta make your personal songs engaging and interesting to the listener make them catchy while having the depth, personal lyrics, message. U also have to have the charisma. That is a natural gift only certain song writters have

It's like having speed if u an athlete whatever sport u are in speed is natural u can coach other things learn other aspects of a sport but u are born with speed or u simply don't have it.

 

[semi-auto-mato]

I think it's a classic song because of the lyrics and message in the lyrics really deep lyrics, had a lotta emotion, was really personal, had a classic hook, classic flow, classic beat, great delivery. Can relate to the Song. 1 of those Songs that helps u through difficult situations

how are u gonna explain why its classic by using the word classic? are all personal songs classic? don trip letter to his son classic? will smith just the two of us classic? nas daughters classic?

Of course not all personal songs are classic. U gotta make your personal songs engaging and interesting to the listener make them catchy while having the depth, personal lyrics, message. U also have to have the charisma. That is a natural gift only certain song writters have

It's like having speed if u an athlete whatever sport u are in speed is natural u can coach other things learn other aspects of a sport but u are born with speed or u simply don't have it.

the lyrics aint amazing and the message is what exactly? u still yet to explain that one to us...hey ur boy said cuz u dont understand him dont mean that he nice

 

[GunTown]

I think it's a classic song because of the lyrics and message in the lyrics really deep lyrics, had a lotta emotion, was really personal, had a classic hook, classic flow, classic beat, great delivery. Can relate to the Song

Which lyrics?...what's the message he is trying to convey?...

What made the hook, flow, beat classic...delivery is flow so that's redundant to say...

Why/how do you relate to the song?...

About his responsibilities to his daughter, his legacy towards her when he dies, her being his biggest motivation in life, the difficulties of parenting nd how tough it actually is, how he wants his daughter to remember him. I think the lyrics in every verse and the hook are classic

I think the hook is classic because it's really catchy and stays stuck in your head and because of the melody and the emotion in the hook. His Flow was effortless and so smooth in the Song tha's why it's classic Flow, The beat was perfect for the type of emotion on the song and the Flow. It was a beat that dark but a banger at the same time

I relate because parent and understand the difficulties of parenting especially coming from a poor enviroment. How hard u have to work to provide for your family. I relate to wanting to do the very best for my kid

 

[GunTown]

I think it's a classic song because of the lyrics and message in the lyrics really deep lyrics, had a lotta emotion, was really personal, had a classic hook, classic flow, classic beat, great delivery. Can relate to the Song. 1 of those Songs that helps u through difficult situations

how are u gonna explain why its classic by using the word classic? are all personal songs classic? don trip letter to his son classic? will smith just the two of us classic? nas daughters classic?

Of course not all personal songs are classic. U gotta make your personal songs engaging and interesting to the listener make them catchy while having the depth, personal lyrics, message. U also have to have the charisma. That is a natural gift only certain song writters have

It's like having speed if u an athlete whatever sport u are in speed is natural u can coach other things learn other aspects of a sport but u are born with speed or u simply don't have it.

the lyrics aint amazing and the message is what exactly? u still yet to explain that one to us...hey ur boy said cuz u dont understand him dont mean that he nice

They are amazing to me because i feel lyrics with a message, emotion, story telling, passion delivered in an engaging way are the best and are what makes great lyrics. What is said in the lyrics what you are saying and meaning in the lyrics are the most important factors in great lyrics

The message is about his responsbilities as a father, the difficulkties of being a parent, the legacy he leaves on his daughter wen he dies, his daughter being the biggest motivation and inspiration in his life, how much he thinks about his daughter where ever he is, how his life has affected his daughter

Listen to the Song then judge it

 

[just.might.b.ok]

How can u say u want whats best for your bastard kid when you're a fucking cocaine addict thats spends all day here posting about shitty music?

Poor bastard must be deas by now.

 

[DarthRozay]

I give it a shit out of shit. It topped the shit charts and held the spot for #1 shittiest song for the most time the year it was released

 

[dwade206]

I give it a shit out of shit. It topped the shit charts and held the spot for #1 shittiest song for the most time the year it was released

...ain't that some shit

 

[achewon87]

Hailey's Song is better...

 

[NothingButTheTruth]

It's a good song.

 

[semi-auto-mato]

I think it's a classic song because of the lyrics and message in the lyrics really deep lyrics, had a lotta emotion, was really personal, had a classic hook, classic flow, classic beat, great delivery. Can relate to the Song. 1 of those Songs that helps u through difficult situations

how are u gonna explain why its classic by using the word classic? are all personal songs classic? don trip letter to his son classic? will smith just the two of us classic? nas daughters classic?

Of course not all personal songs are classic. U gotta make your personal songs engaging and interesting to the listener make them catchy while having the depth, personal lyrics, message. U also have to have the charisma. That is a natural gift only certain song writters have

It's like having speed if u an athlete whatever sport u are in speed is natural u can coach other things learn other aspects of a sport but u are born with speed or u simply don't have it.

the lyrics aint amazing and the message is what exactly? u still yet to explain that one to us...hey ur boy said cuz u dont understand him dont mean that he nice

They are amazing to me because i feel lyrics with a message, emotion, story telling, passion delivered in an engaging way are the best and are what makes great lyrics. What is said in the lyrics what you are saying and meaning in the lyrics are the most important factors in great lyrics

The message is about his responsbilities as a father, the difficulkties of being a parent, the legacy he leaves on his daughter wen he dies, his daughter being the biggest motivation and inspiration in his life, how much he thinks about his daughter where ever he is, how his life has affected his daughter

Listen to the Song then judge it

i have heard several times as well as many other parental songs. im not sure what makes it a classic. a good song but not close to song others. he choose to be a star...he chased his dream so why is crying about being gone? he should do a better job showing his daughter he loves her more than he loves u his fans (hey he said she said that to him). the nigga need to listen ed o.g. be a father (i bet u never heard that song huh?) lmao.

i will give u credit though...u been reading some of the recent threads on goats cuz now u are throwing the word charisma around and trying to sell us on em's charisma now.

its not a classic song...nowhere near a classic song...dont take my word for it...look at the responses here..majority rules and the reason is voting...its a loud no!

 

[dalyricalbandit]

 

[GunTown]

I think it's a classic song because of the lyrics and message in the lyrics really deep lyrics, had a lotta emotion, was really personal, had a classic hook, classic flow, classic beat, great delivery. Can relate to the Song. 1 of those Songs that helps u through difficult situations

how are u gonna explain why its classic by using the word classic? are all personal songs classic? don trip letter to his son classic? will smith just the two of us classic? nas daughters classic?

Of course not all personal songs are classic. U gotta make your personal songs engaging and interesting to the listener make them catchy while having the depth, personal lyrics, message. U also have to have the charisma. That is a natural gift only certain song writters have

It's like having speed if u an athlete whatever sport u are in speed is natural u can coach other things learn other aspects of a sport but u are born with speed or u simply don't have it.

the lyrics aint amazing and the message is what exactly? u still yet to explain that one to us...hey ur boy said cuz u dont understand him dont mean that he nice

They are amazing to me because i feel lyrics with a message, emotion, story telling, passion delivered in an engaging way are the best and are what makes great lyrics. What is said in the lyrics what you are saying and meaning in the lyrics are the most important factors in great lyrics

The message is about his responsbilities as a father, the difficulkties of being a parent, the legacy he leaves on his daughter wen he dies, his daughter being the biggest motivation and inspiration in his life, how much he thinks about his daughter where ever he is, how his life has affected his daughter

Listen to the Song then judge it

i have heard several times as well as many other parental songs. im not sure what makes it a classic. a good song but not close to song others. he choose to be a star...he chased his dream so why is crying about being gone? he should do a better job showing his daughter he loves her more than he loves u his fans (hey he said she said that to him). the nigga need to listen ed o.g. be a father (i bet u never heard that song huh?) lmao.

i will give u credit though...u been reading some of the recent threads on goats cuz now u are throwing the word charisma around and trying to sell us on em's charisma now.

its not a classic song...nowhere near a classic song...dont take my word for it...look at the responses here..majority rules and the reason is voting...its a loud no!

It all comes down to taste it's a classic Song imo 1 of the best Songs i ever heard

Songs like this are why i listen to Hip Hop

It connects on a personal live and as i said it helped me get through some difficult times in my life

 

[semi-auto-mato]

I think it's a classic song because of the lyrics and message in the lyrics really deep lyrics, had a lotta emotion, was really personal, had a classic hook, classic flow, classic beat, great delivery. Can relate to the Song. 1 of those Songs that helps u through difficult situations

how are u gonna explain why its classic by using the word classic? are all personal songs classic? don trip letter to his son classic? will smith just the two of us classic? nas daughters classic?

Of course not all personal songs are classic. U gotta make your personal songs engaging and interesting to the listener make them catchy while having the depth, personal lyrics, message. U also have to have the charisma. That is a natural gift only certain song writters have

It's like having speed if u an athlete whatever sport u are in speed is natural u can coach other things learn other aspects of a sport but u are born with speed or u simply don't have it.

the lyrics aint amazing and the message is what exactly? u still yet to explain that one to us...hey ur boy said cuz u dont understand him dont mean that he nice

They are amazing to me because i feel lyrics with a message, emotion, story telling, passion delivered in an engaging way are the best and are what makes great lyrics. What is said in the lyrics what you are saying and meaning in the lyrics are the most important factors in great lyrics

The message is about his responsbilities as a father, the difficulkties of being a parent, the legacy he leaves on his daughter wen he dies, his daughter being the biggest motivation and inspiration in his life, how much he thinks about his daughter where ever he is, how his life has affected his daughter

Listen to the Song then judge it

i have heard several times as well as many other parental songs. im not sure what makes it a classic. a good song but not close to song others. he choose to be a star...he chased his dream so why is crying about being gone? he should do a better job showing his daughter he loves her more than he loves u his fans (hey he said she said that to him). the nigga need to listen ed o.g. be a father (i bet u never heard that song huh?) lmao.

i will give u credit though...u been reading some of the recent threads on goats cuz now u are throwing the word charisma around and trying to sell us on em's charisma now.

its not a classic song...nowhere near a classic song...dont take my word for it...look at the responses here..majority rules and the reason is voting...its a loud no!

It all comes down to taste it's a classic Song imo 1 of the best Songs i ever heard

Songs like this are why i listen to Hip Hop

It connects on a personal live and as i said it helped me get through some difficult times in my life

ok got it ur father wasnt there but that doesnt make it a classic song...its a song u like. u alone do not decide what is classic. ur not really a hip hop head..ur an em fan. if he made a country album u be all in the country forums talking about he the goat and garth brooks and kenny rogers are trash to people he loved that shit all they life. i been hip hop from the beginning. i love the shit and u and ur thinking disrespect this shit.

niggas on this forum been hip hop since beatboxing and break dancing and every other day u come on here to tell them em has 50 billion trillion classic songs. sad part is most of those niggas would agree with u and say em is a great rapper (which he is) but that aint enough for u.

u do realize if em was to read these threads he tell u to seek help. its not healthy

 

[GunTown]

I think it's a classic song because of the lyrics and message in the lyrics really deep lyrics, had a lotta emotion, was really personal, had a classic hook, classic flow, classic beat, great delivery. Can relate to the Song. 1 of those Songs that helps u through difficult situations

how are u gonna explain why its classic by using the word classic? are all personal songs classic? don trip letter to his son classic? will smith just the two of us classic? nas daughters classic?

Of course not all personal songs are classic. U gotta make your personal songs engaging and interesting to the listener make them catchy while having the depth, personal lyrics, message. U also have to have the charisma. That is a natural gift only certain song writters have

It's like having speed if u an athlete whatever sport u are in speed is natural u can coach other things learn other aspects of a sport but u are born with speed or u simply don't have it.

the lyrics aint amazing and the message is what exactly? u still yet to explain that one to us...hey ur boy said cuz u dont understand him dont mean that he nice

They are amazing to me because i feel lyrics with a message, emotion, story telling, passion delivered in an engaging way are the best and are what makes great lyrics. What is said in the lyrics what you are saying and meaning in the lyrics are the most important factors in great lyrics

The message is about his responsbilities as a father, the difficulkties of being a parent, the legacy he leaves on his daughter wen he dies, his daughter being the biggest motivation and inspiration in his life, how much he thinks about his daughter where ever he is, how his life has affected his daughter

Listen to the Song then judge it

i have heard several times as well as many other parental songs. im not sure what makes it a classic. a good song but not close to song others. he choose to be a star...he chased his dream so why is crying about being gone? he should do a better job showing his daughter he loves her more than he loves u his fans (hey he said she said that to him). the nigga need to listen ed o.g. be a father (i bet u never heard that song huh?) lmao.

i will give u credit though...u been reading some of the recent threads on goats cuz now u are throwing the word charisma around and trying to sell us on em's charisma now.

its not a classic song...nowhere near a classic song...dont take my word for it...look at the responses here..majority rules and the reason is voting...its a loud no!

It all comes down to taste it's a classic Song imo 1 of the best Songs i ever heard

Songs like this are why i listen to Hip Hop

It connects on a personal live and as i said it helped me get through some difficult times in my life

ok got it ur father wasnt there but that doesnt make it a classic song...its a song u like. u alone do not decide what is classic. ur not really a hip hop head..ur an em fan. if he made a country album u be all in the country forums talking about he the goat and garth brooks and kenny rogers are trash to people he loved that shit all they life. i been hip hop from the beginning. i love the shit and u and ur thinking disrespect this shit.

niggas on this forum been hip hop since beatboxing and break dancing and every other day u come on here to tell them em has 50 billion trillion classic songs. sad part is most of those niggas would agree with u and say em is a great rapper (which he is) but that aint enough for u.

u do realize if em was to read these threads he tell u to seek help. its not healthy

Well it did reach top 5 on the billboard chart so obviously a lotta people like it for it to have been such a huge hit reaching the top 5. It's 1 of his biggest and highest charting songs ever actually

I listen to rappers like

Eminem

Styles P

DMX

Z-Ro

Devin The Dude

Max B

YG

Nipsey Hussle

2pac

Kid Cudi

Rich Homie Quan

To me Soing writting>>>>>>>>>>>>>anything else

That's why i listen to rappers who are great song writters and dislike rappers who i feel are not good song writers even tho they may be able to rap. Rapping is the easy part but the hardest part is song writting, making songs a huge amount relate to, writting succesful songs and hits. I look for the whole package lyrics, melody, creativity, emotion, catchy hooks, passion, diversity, charisma, flow. To me u gotta have the all round package that's why Em is the GOAT imo and why i listen to the rappers i listed to name a few.

I been listening to Hip Hop since the mid 90's i'm a huge fan. Certain Songs like this 1 and others have helped me over come a lotta personal hardships

As u can see with a few of the rappers i listed that i listen to some are underground like Z-Ro so i'm a fan of both underground and mainstream rappers. Z-Ro which is underground is a legend to me i can relate to his music as well

I like Artistry in Hip Hop

 

[Built 4 cuban linx]

Y'all not going to change her mind, why the fuck you keep asking her questions? IGNORE THE BITCH

I didn't post this for the lols, it was a serious question. You can't bitch that she's trolling and still add to her threads making them do numbers

 

[semi-auto-mato]

I think it's a classic song because of the lyrics and message in the lyrics really deep lyrics, had a lotta emotion, was really personal, had a classic hook, classic flow, classic beat, great delivery. Can relate to the Song. 1 of those Songs that helps u through difficult situations

how are u gonna explain why its classic by using the word classic? are all personal songs classic? don trip letter to his son classic? will smith just the two of us classic? nas daughters classic?

Of course not all personal songs are classic. U gotta make your personal songs engaging and interesting to the listener make them catchy while having the depth, personal lyrics, message. U also have to have the charisma. That is a natural gift only certain song writters have

It's like having speed if u an athlete whatever sport u are in speed is natural u can coach other things learn other aspects of a sport but u are born with speed or u simply don't have it.

the lyrics aint amazing and the message is what exactly? u still yet to explain that one to us...hey ur boy said cuz u dont understand him dont mean that he nice

They are amazing to me because i feel lyrics with a message, emotion, story telling, passion delivered in an engaging way are the best and are what makes great lyrics. What is said in the lyrics what you are saying and meaning in the lyrics are the most important factors in great lyrics

The message is about his responsbilities as a father, the difficulkties of being a parent, the legacy he leaves on his daughter wen he dies, his daughter being the biggest motivation and inspiration in his life, how much he thinks about his daughter where ever he is, how his life has affected his daughter

Listen to the Song then judge it

i have heard several times as well as many other parental songs. im not sure what makes it a classic. a good song but not close to song others. he choose to be a star...he chased his dream so why is crying about being gone? he should do a better job showing his daughter he loves her more than he loves u his fans (hey he said she said that to him). the nigga need to listen ed o.g. be a father (i bet u never heard that song huh?) lmao.

i will give u credit though...u been reading some of the recent threads on goats cuz now u are throwing the word charisma around and trying to sell us on em's charisma now.

its not a classic song...nowhere near a classic song...dont take my word for it...look at the responses here..majority rules and the reason is voting...its a loud no!

It all comes down to taste it's a classic Song imo 1 of the best Songs i ever heard

Songs like this are why i listen to Hip Hop

It connects on a personal live and as i said it helped me get through some difficult times in my life

ok got it ur father wasnt there but that doesnt make it a classic song...its a song u like. u alone do not decide what is classic. ur not really a hip hop head..ur an em fan. if he made a country album u be all in the country forums talking about he the goat and garth brooks and kenny rogers are trash to people he loved that shit all they life. i been hip hop from the beginning. i love the shit and u and ur thinking disrespect this shit.

niggas on this forum been hip hop since beatboxing and break dancing and every other day u come on here to tell them em has 50 billion trillion classic songs. sad part is most of those niggas would agree with u and say em is a great rapper (which he is) but that aint enough for u.

u do realize if em was to read these threads he tell u to seek help. its not healthy

Well it did reach top 5 on the billboard chart so obviously a lotta people like it for it to have been such a huge hit reaching the top 5. It's 1 of his biggest and highest charting songs ever actually

ok up to ur old tricks again with the chart topping shit. jay z got more number 1 albums them em does so jay is the goat! u do agree with this dont u?

 

[GunTown]

I think it's a classic song because of the lyrics and message in the lyrics really deep lyrics, had a lotta emotion, was really personal, had a classic hook, classic flow, classic beat, great delivery. Can relate to the Song. 1 of those Songs that helps u through difficult situations

how are u gonna explain why its classic by using the word classic? are all personal songs classic? don trip letter to his son classic? will smith just the two of us classic? nas daughters classic?

Of course not all personal songs are classic. U gotta make your personal songs engaging and interesting to the listener make them catchy while having the depth, personal lyrics, message. U also have to have the charisma. That is a natural gift only certain song writters have

It's like having speed if u an athlete whatever sport u are in speed is natural u can coach other things learn other aspects of a sport but u are born with speed or u simply don't have it.

the lyrics aint amazing and the message is what exactly? u still yet to explain that one to us...hey ur boy said cuz u dont understand him dont mean that he nice

They are amazing to me because i feel lyrics with a message, emotion, story telling, passion delivered in an engaging way are the best and are what makes great lyrics. What is said in the lyrics what you are saying and meaning in the lyrics are the most important factors in great lyrics

The message is about his responsbilities as a father, the difficulkties of being a parent, the legacy he leaves on his daughter wen he dies, his daughter being the biggest motivation and inspiration in his life, how much he thinks about his daughter where ever he is, how his life has affected his daughter

Listen to the Song then judge it

i have heard several times as well as many other parental songs. im not sure what makes it a classic. a good song but not close to song others. he choose to be a star...he chased his dream so why is crying about being gone? he should do a better job showing his daughter he loves her more than he loves u his fans (hey he said she said that to him). the nigga need to listen ed o.g. be a father (i bet u never heard that song huh?) lmao.

i will give u credit though...u been reading some of the recent threads on goats cuz now u are throwing the word charisma around and trying to sell us on em's charisma now.

its not a classic song...nowhere near a classic song...dont take my word for it...look at the responses here..majority rules and the reason is voting...its a loud no!

It all comes down to taste it's a classic Song imo 1 of the best Songs i ever heard

Songs like this are why i listen to Hip Hop

It connects on a personal live and as i said it helped me get through some difficult times in my life

ok got it ur father wasnt there but that doesnt make it a classic song...its a song u like. u alone do not decide what is classic. ur not really a hip hop head..ur an em fan. if he made a country album u be all in the country forums talking about he the goat and garth brooks and kenny rogers are trash to people he loved that shit all they life. i been hip hop from the beginning. i love the shit and u and ur thinking disrespect this shit.

niggas on this forum been hip hop since beatboxing and break dancing and every other day u come on here to tell them em has 50 billion trillion classic songs. sad part is most of those niggas would agree with u and say em is a great rapper (which he is) but that aint enough for u.

u do realize if em was to read these threads he tell u to seek help. its not healthy

Well it did reach top 5 on the billboard chart so obviously a lotta people like it for it to have been such a huge hit reaching the top 5. It's 1 of his biggest and highest charting songs ever actually

ok up to ur old tricks again with the chart topping shit. jay z got more number 1 albums them em does so jay is the goat! u do agree with this dont u?

No i don't

The reason i bought up it being a top 5 charting single is because u said i like it that doesn't others like the song just because i do but i gave u a concrete example that many people like it besides just me as it is a song a lotta people purchased to chart so highly

U don't have a single chart that highly unless a lotta people like it and i imagine this being common sense is that the people who do like it do for the same reasons as me some prefer this type of hip hop and these type of songs are why they listen to hip hop

U have to look at it logically songs people can relate to like this are gonna leave a bigger impression on people than songs that are just spitting for the sake of it and rhyming for the sake of it mainly just showcasing Flow and sacrificing everything else. Because in these type of Songs u not only got message, emotion, can relate but u also get the Flow, good rhyming.

As i said it's about having the whole package and getting everything in a song every aspect being great so that's why a song like this eaves a bigger impression on people and is more memorable than other Songs that have a different style

 

[semi-auto-mato]

I think it's a classic song because of the lyrics and message in the lyrics really deep lyrics, had a lotta emotion, was really personal, had a classic hook, classic flow, classic beat, great delivery. Can relate to the Song. 1 of those Songs that helps u through difficult situations

how are u gonna explain why its classic by using the word classic? are all personal songs classic? don trip letter to his son classic? will smith just the two of us classic? nas daughters classic?

Of course not all personal songs are classic. U gotta make your personal songs engaging and interesting to the listener make them catchy while having the depth, personal lyrics, message. U also have to have the charisma. That is a natural gift only certain song writters have

It's like having speed if u an athlete whatever sport u are in speed is natural u can coach other things learn other aspects of a sport but u are born with speed or u simply don't have it.

the lyrics aint amazing and the message is what exactly? u still yet to explain that one to us...hey ur boy said cuz u dont understand him dont mean that he nice

They are amazing to me because i feel lyrics with a message, emotion, story telling, passion delivered in an engaging way are the best and are what makes great lyrics. What is said in the lyrics what you are saying and meaning in the lyrics are the most important factors in great lyrics

The message is about his responsbilities as a father, the difficulkties of being a parent, the legacy he leaves on his daughter wen he dies, his daughter being the biggest motivation and inspiration in his life, how much he thinks about his daughter where ever he is, how his life has affected his daughter

Listen to the Song then judge it

i have heard several times as well as many other parental songs. im not sure what makes it a classic. a good song but not close to song others. he choose to be a star...he chased his dream so why is crying about being gone? he should do a better job showing his daughter he loves her more than he loves u his fans (hey he said she said that to him). the nigga need to listen ed o.g. be a father (i bet u never heard that song huh?) lmao.

i will give u credit though...u been reading some of the recent threads on goats cuz now u are throwing the word charisma around and trying to sell us on em's charisma now.

its not a classic song...nowhere near a classic song...dont take my word for it...look at the responses here..majority rules and the reason is voting...its a loud no!

It all comes down to taste it's a classic Song imo 1 of the best Songs i ever heard

Songs like this are why i listen to Hip Hop

It connects on a personal live and as i said it helped me get through some difficult times in my life

ok got it ur father wasnt there but that doesnt make it a classic song...its a song u like. u alone do not decide what is classic. ur not really a hip hop head..ur an em fan. if he made a country album u be all in the country forums talking about he the goat and garth brooks and kenny rogers are trash to people he loved that shit all they life. i been hip hop from the beginning. i love the shit and u and ur thinking disrespect this shit.

niggas on this forum been hip hop since beatboxing and break dancing and every other day u come on here to tell them em has 50 billion trillion classic songs. sad part is most of those niggas would agree with u and say em is a great rapper (which he is) but that aint enough for u.

u do realize if em was to read these threads he tell u to seek help. its not healthy

Well it did reach top 5 on the billboard chart so obviously a lotta people like it for it to have been such a huge hit reaching the top 5. It's 1 of his biggest and highest charting songs ever actually

ok up to ur old tricks again with the chart topping shit. jay z got more number 1 albums them em does so jay is the goat! u do agree with this dont u?

No i don't

The reason i bought up it being a top 5 charting single is because u said i like it that doesn't others like the song just because i do but i gave u a concrete example that many people like it besides just me as it is a song a lotta people purchased to chart so highly

U don't have a single chart that highly unless a lotta people like it and i imagine this being common sense is that the people who do like it do for the same reasons as me some prefer this type of hip hop and these type of songs are why they listen to hip hop

and i use ur argument to say many people like jay z...more no. 1 albums than elvis. hell the good white folk worship elvis. u can find at least 5 of them right now who will swear they saw him alive yesterday. so by ur logic jay z should be a god. charts dont make classics nor do they make goats.

o yeah i never said the song was wack...said it aint a classic and the people posting in this thread have told u that. ur response is well i like it so its classic....ur a sore loser