Top 10 black QB's of all time

[DaBull]

Mcnair should be number 2

 

[goodlookinout]

1. McNair- if I need to win a game he's my guy.

2. Moon- One of the best pure passers ever

3. Cunningham- Dynamic runner and passer

4. McNabb- He was Hell in his Philly days 4sho

5. Vick- Game breaker can blow up your scheme if he breaks out the pocket. erratic thrower but if both were on good luck.

6. Cam Newton- Based on what we've seen so far still can get better and more lethal.

Honorable Mention

Jeff Blake

Aaron Brooks

Jameis Winston

Vince Evans

Kordell Stewart

Vince Evans

Doug Williams

Joe Gilliam

 

[Maywood]

No McNabb ? lol

 

[Moore7s]

Shout-out to Seneca Wallace

 

[aneed123]

byron leftwich and Garrard

 

[buttuh_b]

Deshaun Watson

 

[buttuh_b]

Shout-out to Seneca Wallace

What about Tavaris Jackson?? Haaaa

 

[goodlookinout]

No McNabb ? lol

i smooth 4got him brain fart my bad

 

[Inglewood_B]

Deshaun Watson

If he follow up next season with another solid outing I'm definitely putting him on my list. He's looked legit this year

 

[Rampage12]

"@5 Grand" u buggin

Football is a team sport and is very situational. If I'm starting a franchise I 100% take Marino over Williams.

Winning the Super Bowl doesn’t historically make you a great QB. Trent Dilfer, Brad Johnson and so many others have won but more because of the team around them. They didn’t have the stats, clutch performances or longevity to be considered greats individually.

All time greats like Marino, Dan Fouts & Warren Moon are light years ahead of Williams and others. They just didn’t have the D or didn’t have the breaks to win it all.

Taking Doug Williams overall just because he won a Super Bowl over Marino puts your football common sense on notice.

There's another element of football that you guys didn't address. Namely; performance under pressure.

In Superbowl XXII Williams passed for a Super Bowl record 340 yards and four touchdowns, with one interception.

In Super Bowl XIX, Marino passed for 318 yards, one touchdown pass and two interceptions.

So who's better?

Who would you pick to start in a Superbowl?

Clutch performing & “playing under pressure” is the same damn thing.

Williams played against a average defense and played along with Timmy Smith. Who broke the Super Bowl rushing record & has just as much argument as being the MVP in that game. Without Elway the Broncos in the 80s would of been trash.

Marino played against a highly underrated 49ers D & the best team in the 80s.

Come on bruh. Plus Marino has had clutch performances before. His surrounding cast just wasn’t enough to get a ring.

Just stop.

Think about what your saying.

The most important thing in football is winning the Superbowl. Thats indisputable. In fact, I'd go as far as to say that a QB's regular season statistics are irrelevant. The only thing that matters is who won the Superbowl.

So basically Brad Johnson and Trent Dilfer are better than Marino in your opinion also.

 

[Rampage12]

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

No ones wants to be Charles Barkley, but your logic still dumb as hell when it comes to these NFL QBs.

Explain why you'd rather be Robert Horry than Charles Barkley!

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

No ones wants to be Charles Barkley, but your logic still dumb as hell when it comes to these NFL QBs.

Explain why you'd rather be Robert Horry than Charles Barkley!

Barkley could have 10 titles and no one would still wanna he that nigga. Why you yellin, lol.

Face facts, ya logic is lousy.

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

i aint ask who u rather b i asked who is the better player

OK forget about Robert Horry and Charles Barkley.

Who would you rather be, Doug Williams or Dan Marino?

Well...Dan Marino has more money, a bust in Canton, and is considered to be one of the 10 best QB's of all-time by everyone but you...so Dan Marino. Williams also had a losing record as a starting QB and only threw 7 more TD's than INT's in his career, Marino sustained his greatness for 15 years or so. If your old ass can't understand that then I don't know what to tell you.

 

[infamous114]

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

No ones wants to be Charles Barkley, but your logic still dumb as hell when it comes to these NFL QBs.

Explain why you'd rather be Robert Horry than Charles Barkley!

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

No ones wants to be Charles Barkley, but your logic still dumb as hell when it comes to these NFL QBs.

Explain why you'd rather be Robert Horry than Charles Barkley!

Barkley could have 10 titles and no one would still wanna he that nigga. Why you yellin, lol.

Face facts, ya logic is lousy.

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

i aint ask who u rather b i asked who is the better player

OK forget about Robert Horry and Charles Barkley.

Who would you rather be, Doug Williams or Dan Marino?

Well...Dan Marino has more money, a bust in Canton, and is considered to be one of the 10 best QB's of all-time by everyone but you...so Dan Marino. Williams also had a losing record as a starting QB and only threw 7 more TD's than INT's in his career, Marino sustained his greatness for 15 years or so. If your old ass can't understand that then I don't know what to tell you.

Those pimps in his neighborhood have his brains scrambled

 

[5 Grand]

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

No ones wants to be Charles Barkley, but your logic still dumb as hell when it comes to these NFL QBs.

Explain why you'd rather be Robert Horry than Charles Barkley!

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

No ones wants to be Charles Barkley, but your logic still dumb as hell when it comes to these NFL QBs.

Explain why you'd rather be Robert Horry than Charles Barkley!

Barkley could have 10 titles and no one would still wanna he that nigga. Why you yellin, lol.

Face facts, ya logic is lousy.

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

i aint ask who u rather b i asked who is the better player

OK forget about Robert Horry and Charles Barkley.

Who would you rather be, Doug Williams or Dan Marino?

Well...Dan Marino has more money, a bust in Canton, and is considered to be one of the 10 best QB's of all-time by everyone but you...so Dan Marino. Williams also had a losing record as a starting QB and only threw 7 more TD's than INT's in his career, Marino sustained his greatness for 15 years or so. If your old ass can't understand that then I don't know what to tell you.

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

No ones wants to be Charles Barkley, but your logic still dumb as hell when it comes to these NFL QBs.

Explain why you'd rather be Robert Horry than Charles Barkley!

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

No ones wants to be Charles Barkley, but your logic still dumb as hell when it comes to these NFL QBs.

Explain why you'd rather be Robert Horry than Charles Barkley!

Barkley could have 10 titles and no one would still wanna he that nigga. Why you yellin, lol.

Face facts, ya logic is lousy.

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

i aint ask who u rather b i asked who is the better player

OK forget about Robert Horry and Charles Barkley.

Who would you rather be, Doug Williams or Dan Marino?

Well...Dan Marino has more money, a bust in Canton, and is considered to be one of the 10 best QB's of all-time by everyone but you...so Dan Marino. Williams also had a losing record as a starting QB and only threw 7 more TD's than INT's in his career, Marino sustained his greatness for 15 years or so. If your old ass can't understand that then I don't know what to tell you.

Those pimps in his neighborhood have his brains scrambled

Winning the Superbowl >>>

 

[its....JOHN B]

Michael Bishop

 

[natural born sinners]

1. Doug Williams

2. Michael Vick

3. Donovan McNabb

4. Randall Cunningham

5. Steve McNair

6. Warren Moon

7. Cam Newton

8. Robert Griffin III

9. Daunte Culpepper

10. Charlie Ward

Aye man...get RG3 one good season up outta here. Kappa had a better run then RG3. Also I would put Cam wayyy higher than Vick. Vick was my favorite player while w the falcons and took my NFL fandom to another level. But far as overall QB skills he was more flash than actual skill. Don't get me started on his accuracy, he was easy to neutralize once teams figured out he couldn't beat u from the pocket consistently

 

[Rampage12]

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

No ones wants to be Charles Barkley, but your logic still dumb as hell when it comes to these NFL QBs.

Explain why you'd rather be Robert Horry than Charles Barkley!

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

No ones wants to be Charles Barkley, but your logic still dumb as hell when it comes to these NFL QBs.

Explain why you'd rather be Robert Horry than Charles Barkley!

Barkley could have 10 titles and no one would still wanna he that nigga. Why you yellin, lol.

Face facts, ya logic is lousy.

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

i aint ask who u rather b i asked who is the better player

OK forget about Robert Horry and Charles Barkley.

Who would you rather be, Doug Williams or Dan Marino?

Well...Dan Marino has more money, a bust in Canton, and is considered to be one of the 10 best QB's of all-time by everyone but you...so Dan Marino. Williams also had a losing record as a starting QB and only threw 7 more TD's than INT's in his career, Marino sustained his greatness for 15 years or so. If your old ass can't understand that then I don't know what to tell you.

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

No ones wants to be Charles Barkley, but your logic still dumb as hell when it comes to these NFL QBs.

Explain why you'd rather be Robert Horry than Charles Barkley!

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

No ones wants to be Charles Barkley, but your logic still dumb as hell when it comes to these NFL QBs.

Explain why you'd rather be Robert Horry than Charles Barkley!

Barkley could have 10 titles and no one would still wanna he that nigga. Why you yellin, lol.

Face facts, ya logic is lousy.

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

i aint ask who u rather b i asked who is the better player

OK forget about Robert Horry and Charles Barkley.

Who would you rather be, Doug Williams or Dan Marino?

Well...Dan Marino has more money, a bust in Canton, and is considered to be one of the 10 best QB's of all-time by everyone but you...so Dan Marino. Williams also had a losing record as a starting QB and only threw 7 more TD's than INT's in his career, Marino sustained his greatness for 15 years or so. If your old ass can't understand that then I don't know what to tell you.

Those pimps in his neighborhood have his brains scrambled

Winning the Superbowl >>>

So you think this statement is also true:

Trent Dilfer>>>Dan Marino

See how stupid that sounds old-timer.

 

[Trollio]

So winning championships>>>

So darko>>>melo according to 5 grand

 

[5 Grand]

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

No ones wants to be Charles Barkley, but your logic still dumb as hell when it comes to these NFL QBs.

Explain why you'd rather be Robert Horry than Charles Barkley!

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

No ones wants to be Charles Barkley, but your logic still dumb as hell when it comes to these NFL QBs.

Explain why you'd rather be Robert Horry than Charles Barkley!

Barkley could have 10 titles and no one would still wanna he that nigga. Why you yellin, lol.

Face facts, ya logic is lousy.

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

i aint ask who u rather b i asked who is the better player

OK forget about Robert Horry and Charles Barkley.

Who would you rather be, Doug Williams or Dan Marino?

Well...Dan Marino has more money, a bust in Canton, and is considered to be one of the 10 best QB's of all-time by everyone but you...so Dan Marino. Williams also had a losing record as a starting QB and only threw 7 more TD's than INT's in his career, Marino sustained his greatness for 15 years or so. If your old ass can't understand that then I don't know what to tell you.

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

No ones wants to be Charles Barkley, but your logic still dumb as hell when it comes to these NFL QBs.

Explain why you'd rather be Robert Horry than Charles Barkley!

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

No ones wants to be Charles Barkley, but your logic still dumb as hell when it comes to these NFL QBs.

Explain why you'd rather be Robert Horry than Charles Barkley!

Barkley could have 10 titles and no one would still wanna he that nigga. Why you yellin, lol.

Face facts, ya logic is lousy.

is horry a better player than barkley? hell no but he got rings. rings dont validate who better all the time.

I'd rather be Horry.

Tell the truth, who would you rather be, Robert Horry or Charles Barkley?

i aint ask who u rather b i asked who is the better player

OK forget about Robert Horry and Charles Barkley.

Who would you rather be, Doug Williams or Dan Marino?

Well...Dan Marino has more money, a bust in Canton, and is considered to be one of the 10 best QB's of all-time by everyone but you...so Dan Marino. Williams also had a losing record as a starting QB and only threw 7 more TD's than INT's in his career, Marino sustained his greatness for 15 years or so. If your old ass can't understand that then I don't know what to tell you.

Those pimps in his neighborhood have his brains scrambled

Winning the Superbowl >>>

So you think this statement is also true:

Trent Dilfer>>>Dan Marino

See how stupid that sounds old-timer.

So winning championships>>>

So darko>>>melo according to 5 grand

So you guys are saying; 2nd place >>>being a champion

 

[Moore7s]

@everyone talking to 5grand

He is either a troll with an unlimited battery or he is too dumb for his age.

Mods please close this

 

[tupacfan12]

1. Doug Williams

2. Michael Vick

3. Donovan McNabb

4. Randall Cunningham

5. Steve McNair

6. Warren Moon

7. Cam Newton

8. Robert Griffin III

9. Daunte Culpepper

10. Charlie Ward

Aye man...get RG3 one good season up outta here. Kappa had a better run then RG3. Also I would put Cam wayyy higher than Vick. Vick was my favorite player while w the falcons and took my NFL fandom to another level. But far as overall QB skills he was more flash than actual skill. Don't get me started on his accuracy, he was easy to neutralize once teams figured out he couldn't beat u from the pocket consistently

Naw man Vick>>>>>Newton all day. Vick’s deep ball accuracy was way better especially when he went to Philly plus his athleticism was unmatched possibly HOF worthy.