LordZuko;c-10049480 said:
You know you got somebody on the ropes when they start bringing up irrelevant shit like time spent posting. That's ad hominem. We grown ups here.
This is where your argument dead ends. You use terms like underrepresented, equity, etc etc. Those are terms that apply to government and government.
Comic books, video games, movies, television are all one thing, art. A creator is bound by no obligation to represent any potential audience. A creator's only responsibility is to represent the image in their mind.
Creators, artists, developers do not have to create a world that is representative of anything including the demographic of this world.
You, as a potential customer decides, votes with your dollar whether or not the artist's work is what you're messing with. You can give your opinion and critique but you have no right to tell a creator what their work should represent. If you feel like there needs to be a creation that represents something in particular then you either make it yourself or you pay someone with talent to do it.
To give these pseudo mandates that art needs to represent any particular group sets an awful precedent. It's a slippery slope towards fascism which left wing/liberals are prone to do.
As a creator of comics and other literature i would be incensed if some asshole told me that i have to put x amount of people in my work because x amount of people buy it. Fuck all the way off. The audacity. I create stories with majority black people and other ethnic groups. I'll be damned if someone tells me i need to make or include these people. So that means on principle i must defend a white boy creating art about majority or even all white people and his interpretation of with any group.
The "fight" to mandate equity and representation in art is a causal cycloid, a vicious cycle where some group can use the legitimate complaint they aren't represented in such and such work. It'll be gays women and poc, next week it's fat girls, asexuals, and biracial Chinese midgets. You can cut the equity pie into countless pieces until it essentially dissolves into individuality or a horrible story built on contrived identity politics.
lol @ ad hominem
you keep repeating my argument is stupid so naturally the question then becomes why spend some much time arguing with a person who you feel is so beneath you and just regurgitating talking points they googled
and its so rich the person who is quick to resort to name calling and cheap character attacks telling anyone to grow up...but i digress...
free speech is vital ...artist can do what they like
but considering we all have to co-exist with each other on this earth some of us feel artist, like everyone else, shouldn't be shielded from criticism. and should be held accountable for the part they play in perpetuating and encouraging anti-social behavior like racism and sexism. or if they have a history of purposely excluding large swaths of ppl from their work
and we as consumers, men and women, have the responsibility for demanding fair representation and more games that portray strong and nuanced female and poc characters
also the majority of comic book artists, game developers working in the industry and in major studios are straight white men and grew up as big fans of comics and video games ...you think that is a coincidence??? lol
i'd argue all the evidence suggest no. and as i've been arguing by promoting diversity it will help attract more poc and women to the fold and get them interested in technology, graphic design at an early age
things that will close the wage gap...and video games have been shown to greatly improve one's cognitive skills
that said, there is a difference between you and a white man creating a fictional new york city, for ex, where ppl of different races and or gender are absent or lacking. the writing of and promoting to prominence productions dominated by “white” characters is about power and influence. expanding these ” roles" to all is about redressing this
that said, this idea this is just not about anyone trying to ruin ur fun is ridiculous and a over simplification of what i or liked minded individuals have argued