6.5/10
All the elements were there to make an awesome movie but WB dropped the ball.
I know people have criticized this to death so I'll be brief.
THE GOOD:
- The Superman Debate.
It was a very well thought out discussion on whether Superman is a God or whether he's good or bad and what happens if you lose control of him. What if Supes decides not to play nice? What are we going to do about all this collateral damage he causes? The intellectual back and forth is a great reason for Bats to be wary of Supes and the fact that Supes destroyed his property and killed his friend in collateral damage is reason enough to fight him.
- The Batman debate
Does Bats go too far? The question Clark asks himself as he hears story after story about Batman whooping ass and branding people in Gotham. Supes may understand Bats anguish and his dislike for criminals but that shouldn't give him carte blanche to be almost as bad as the people he fights. This is reason enough for Supes to step in, he thinks Bats is on the edge of becoming a villain himself.
- Wonder Woman
Despite the fact I think she shouldn't have been in it at all I do like her appearances. She could have been the mediator to stop the fight between Supes and Bats or at least been put in a more meaningful role if she had to be in it but...
- The fight
Well done, good psychology and style but too short.
ON THE FENCE:
- BatFleck
Gun toting shooting people Batman isn't for me. This version of Batman is based on The Dark Knight comic and he specifically says "Guns are the weapons of cowards." in that comic.
- Wonder Woman
I think she was inconsequential. She really didn't serve a purpose in the grand scheme of things, was an afterthought put in for fan service.
- Doomsday
Kinda came out of nowhere but was needed to bring Bats and Supes together. A threat bigger than their beef forces them to put hard feelings aside.
THE BAD:
- Martha
Really B? Supes has X ray vision, superspeed and strength and some random goons can hide his mother from him? You really think Supes sucks at hide & seek bruh? WITH X RAY VISION? Stop it. He found Lois in the desert, im sure he can find Martha on his own.
- Lex Luthor
Discount Michael Sera just wasn't that good. He was better than I imagined but Kevin Spacey and Gene Hackman he is not. Lex deserves a Spacey level actor to play him.
- Lex plot
Forcing Supes to kill Bats because he stole his kryptonite is wack.
- Superman was framed
Unnecessary here. It expanded Lois character but we really didn't need more Lois.
- Wonder Woman steals a file only for it to be found anyway and no mention of who was looking for it or why.
- Doomsday fight
Just uninteresting. WW was there to add muscle but in the end ahe really did nothing to stop Doomsday at all. Bats didn't to anything either.
- Too damn long.
This movie tried too hard feel epic.
Its not as bad as it is not what it should have been. Its a classic case of WB setting high expectations only for it to miss the mark. If you came in with lower expectations then it probably isn't so bad.