Rate the disography Vol.4 Jay-z

[genocidecutter]

Classic: Reasonable Doubt, Vol. 2... Hard Knock Life, The Blueprint

Near Perfect: The Blueprint2: The Gift & The Curse, The Black Album, Vol. 3... Life and Times of S. Carter, In My Lifetime, Vol. 1

Average: The Dynasty: Roc La Familia

Weak: Magna Carta Holy Grail, American Gangster

Wack: The Blueprint 3, Kingdom Come

Didn't rate the collab albums

 

[Vader_F_Kennedy]

Near perfect

I actually like kingdom come

 

[TheManInBlack4.0]

Above average.

 

[_Lefty]

Original thread. Mind blown.

 

[macadonwoo]

CLASSIC- Reasonable Doubt,,Black album ,The Blueprint

NEAR PERFECT-Vol 2 , Dynasty roc la Famila , American Gangsta

AVERAGE -Vol 1, Vol 3 ,blueprint 2 , Blueprint 3

WEAK- Kingdome Come,Magna Carta Holy Grail

WACK- N/A

 

[KneeGro_DuperMan]

Recently I've decided to give him the classic nod on the BA. Every track is fire & over time it grew on me. So on that note.....

RD, BA

Vol1, BP1, BP2 (its just too many tracks) AG, Vol2

Dynasty, WTT

MCHG, KC, BP3, Vol3

 

[GetoBoy]

Overall I'll give him classic catalog.... It's hard to give the type of quality jay has for 17 different projects not counting the countless features I mean how many others have even 17 projects period let alone of any kind of quality.... For that reason alone his catalog gets the classic stamp but to break em down IMO

Classics: RD, Vol. 2, BP, BA

Near Perfect: Vol. 1, AG, Roc La

Average: Vol. 3, BP2, BP3, MCHG

Weak: KD

Wack: N/A

 

[Mister B.]

Classic: Blueprint

Near Perfect: Reasonable Doubt, Vol. 2, Black Album

Solid: Vol. 1, Vol. 3, American Gangster

Average: BP 2

Weak: MCHG

Wack: BP 3, Roc La Familia, Kingdom Come

I don't count collab albums.