Rapper Ranking Project: Rapper #4 - Nas

[mosincredible]

Alright, I'm going to call this. Not enough people voted when asked in an earlier post, so I just made the adjustments I said I'd make. That brings his score to 42.

I actually went back through the topics and averaged the scores given just cause I'm curious to see how they match up. I threw out scores with no explanations. Those were mostly all 5s, but there were a couple trollishly low scores too. Here are the final averages:

Jay-Z - 38.3

BIG - 40.3

Pac - 36.8

Nas - 42.1

The hilarious thing is that the people that insisted that averaging was the way I should do it were Jay and Pac dickriders. Well Jay's score went up, but so did Biggie's and the Nas score is the same, so he's still behind them. And Pac actually fell about a point while everyone else went up. So what excuse do you dudes have now? I'm carrying both sets of scores through the topics now.

You can't do that.

You can't throw away scores because you don't agree with them. Imagine if politics worked like that. Two candidates running for an election and the person in charge of counting the votes threw out votes that they disagreed with.

Count all the votes or stop this foolishness.

Yeah I can. I've said before that the only scores that have any meaning are the ones with explanations. If someone comes in here and says "So and so is the GOAT, all 5s." I'm not counting it. If they do like you did and give all fives but actually explain, then I counted it. It's not about whether I agree with the scores or not. I didn't agree with most of them. It's about whether the person attempted to go by the rules of the categories or just blindly gave the max score to boost their favorite rapper.

You didn't say that in your O/P.

I gave Biggie all 5s. If you said that I have to give explanations I would have, but you didn't say that do I didn't.

I know I didn't say it in the OP. I wasn't averaging anything at first remember. I didn't even want people to give their own scores. I was providing a baseline score, and I wanted people to provide arguments in order to get that score closer to something everyone agreed with. That's still the ultimate goal of these threads. I just calculated those averages because people have been asking for them and because I was curious. I left out the unexplained all 5 scores because they aren't really in line with the spirit of the thread at all.

2. No one person's vote is more important than another person

This alone pulls out objectivity because 90% of this board has no idea how to be objective. They regularly let shit that has nothing to do with the music affect their opinions.

 

[The Lonious Monk]

Alright, I'm going to call this. Not enough people voted when asked in an earlier post, so I just made the adjustments I said I'd make. That brings his score to 42.

I actually went back through the topics and averaged the scores given just cause I'm curious to see how they match up. I threw out scores with no explanations. Those were mostly all 5s, but there were a couple trollishly low scores too. Here are the final averages:

Jay-Z - 38.3

BIG - 40.3

Pac - 36.8

Nas - 42.1

The hilarious thing is that the people that insisted that averaging was the way I should do it were Jay and Pac dickriders. Well Jay's score went up, but so did Biggie's and the Nas score is the same, so he's still behind them. And Pac actually fell about a point while everyone else went up. So what excuse do you dudes have now? I'm carrying both sets of scores through the topics now.

You can't do that.

You can't throw away scores because you don't agree with them. Imagine if politics worked like that. Two candidates running for an election and the person in charge of counting the votes threw out votes that they disagreed with.

Count all the votes or stop this foolishness.

Yeah I can. I've said before that the only scores that have any meaning are the ones with explanations. If someone comes in here and says "So and so is the GOAT, all 5s." I'm not counting it. If they do like you did and give all fives but actually explain, then I counted it. It's not about whether I agree with the scores or not. I didn't agree with most of them. It's about whether the person attempted to go by the rules of the categories or just blindly gave the max score to boost their favorite rapper.

You didn't say that in your O/P.

I gave Biggie all 5s. If you said that I have to give explanations I would have, but you didn't say that do I didn't.

I know I didn't say it in the OP. I wasn't averaging anything at first remember. I didn't even want people to give their own scores. I was providing a baseline score, and I wanted people to provide arguments in order to get that score closer to something everyone agreed with. That's still the ultimate goal of these threads. I just calculated those averages because people have been asking for them and because I was curious. I left out the unexplained all 5 scores because they aren't really in line with the spirit of the thread at all.

2. No one person's vote is more important than another person

This alone pulls out objectivity because 90% of this board has no idea how to be objective. They regularly let shit that has nothing to do with the music affect their opinions.

Exactly. People just can't seem to accept that for these threads I purposely made it so that objectivity was more important than equal representation. We get plenty of popularity contest threads on here. That's not what I wanted to do.

 

[genocidecutter]

Alright, I'm going to call this. Not enough people voted when asked in an earlier post, so I just made the adjustments I said I'd make. That brings his score to 42.

I actually went back through the topics and averaged the scores given just cause I'm curious to see how they match up. I threw out scores with no explanations. Those were mostly all 5s, but there were a couple trollishly low scores too. Here are the final averages:

Jay-Z - 38.3

BIG - 40.3

Pac - 36.8

Nas - 42.1

The hilarious thing is that the people that insisted that averaging was the way I should do it were Jay and Pac dickriders. Well Jay's score went up, but so did Biggie's and the Nas score is the same, so he's still behind them. And Pac actually fell about a point while everyone else went up. So what excuse do you dudes have now? I'm carrying both sets of scores through the topics now.

I don't mind this my point was never to make anybody score be higher or lower just have a neutral score that included everybody..... I mean it's the IC we all know who gonna have the top score so this is fine with me *shrugs*

If that's what you want, then you got it. Going forward I'll keep track of my adjusted baseline and the average of the submitted scores. Only Pac dropped. I'm a little surprised by that to be honest since his fans fought the hardest.

Next Rapper - Eminem

We do not need that thread again.

 

[power_wisdom]

Alright, I'm going to call this. Not enough people voted when asked in an earlier post, so I just made the adjustments I said I'd make. That brings his score to 42.

I actually went back through the topics and averaged the scores given just cause I'm curious to see how they match up. I threw out scores with no explanations. Those were mostly all 5s, but there were a couple trollishly low scores too. Here are the final averages:

Jay-Z - 38.3

BIG - 40.3

Pac - 36.8

Nas - 42.1

The hilarious thing is that the people that insisted that averaging was the way I should do it were Jay and Pac dickriders. Well Jay's score went up, but so did Biggie's and the Nas score is the same, so he's still behind them. And Pac actually fell about a point while everyone else went up. So what excuse do you dudes have now? I'm carrying both sets of scores through the topics now.

You can't do that.

You can't throw away scores because you don't agree with them. Imagine if politics worked like that. Two candidates running for an election and the person in charge of counting the votes threw out votes that they disagreed with.

Count all the votes or stop this foolishness.

Yeah I can. I've said before that the only scores that have any meaning are the ones with explanations. If someone comes in here and says "So and so is the GOAT, all 5s." I'm not counting it. If they do like you did and give all fives but actually explain, then I counted it. It's not about whether I agree with the scores or not. I didn't agree with most of them. It's about whether the person attempted to go by the rules of the categories or just blindly gave the max score to boost their favorite rapper.

You didn't say that in your O/P.

I gave Biggie all 5s. If you said that I have to give explanations I would have, but you didn't say that do I didn't.

I know I didn't say it in the OP. I wasn't averaging anything at first remember. I didn't even want people to give their own scores. I was providing a baseline score, and I wanted people to provide arguments in order to get that score closer to something everyone agreed with. That's still the ultimate goal of these threads. I just calculated those averages because people have been asking for them and because I was curious. I left out the unexplained all 5 scores because they aren't really in line with the spirit of the thread at all.

2. No one person's vote is more important than another person

This alone pulls out objectivity because 90% of this board has no idea how to be objective. They regularly let shit that has nothing to do with the music affect their opinions.

Exactly. People just can't seem to accept that for these threads I purposely made it so that objectivity was more important than equal representation. We get plenty of popularity contest threads on here. That's not what I wanted to do.

Yeah, but when I said for impact Nas should get a 5 for Illmatic and all the mc that are inspired by him. Both friends and foes, you started talking about impact in other shit. Is it about the music or not?

 

[The Lonious Monk]

Alright, I'm going to call this. Not enough people voted when asked in an earlier post, so I just made the adjustments I said I'd make. That brings his score to 42.

I actually went back through the topics and averaged the scores given just cause I'm curious to see how they match up. I threw out scores with no explanations. Those were mostly all 5s, but there were a couple trollishly low scores too. Here are the final averages:

Jay-Z - 38.3

BIG - 40.3

Pac - 36.8

Nas - 42.1

The hilarious thing is that the people that insisted that averaging was the way I should do it were Jay and Pac dickriders. Well Jay's score went up, but so did Biggie's and the Nas score is the same, so he's still behind them. And Pac actually fell about a point while everyone else went up. So what excuse do you dudes have now? I'm carrying both sets of scores through the topics now.

You can't do that.

You can't throw away scores because you don't agree with them. Imagine if politics worked like that. Two candidates running for an election and the person in charge of counting the votes threw out votes that they disagreed with.

Count all the votes or stop this foolishness.

Yeah I can. I've said before that the only scores that have any meaning are the ones with explanations. If someone comes in here and says "So and so is the GOAT, all 5s." I'm not counting it. If they do like you did and give all fives but actually explain, then I counted it. It's not about whether I agree with the scores or not. I didn't agree with most of them. It's about whether the person attempted to go by the rules of the categories or just blindly gave the max score to boost their favorite rapper.

You didn't say that in your O/P.

I gave Biggie all 5s. If you said that I have to give explanations I would have, but you didn't say that do I didn't.

I know I didn't say it in the OP. I wasn't averaging anything at first remember. I didn't even want people to give their own scores. I was providing a baseline score, and I wanted people to provide arguments in order to get that score closer to something everyone agreed with. That's still the ultimate goal of these threads. I just calculated those averages because people have been asking for them and because I was curious. I left out the unexplained all 5 scores because they aren't really in line with the spirit of the thread at all.

2. No one person's vote is more important than another person

This alone pulls out objectivity because 90% of this board has no idea how to be objective. They regularly let shit that has nothing to do with the music affect their opinions.

Exactly. People just can't seem to accept that for these threads I purposely made it so that objectivity was more important than equal representation. We get plenty of popularity contest threads on here. That's not what I wanted to do.

Yeah, but when I said for impact Nas should get a 5 for Illmatic and all the mc that are inspired by him. Both friends and foes, you started talking about impact in other shit. Is it about the music or not?

I pointed out that one album couldn't get you a 5 and gave you everything else considered for the Impact score. All were music and HipHop related. Plus I said several times that I would up the Impact score and asked for input on the proposed score. At this point y'all just complaining to complain.

 

[power_wisdom]

Alright, I'm going to call this. Not enough people voted when asked in an earlier post, so I just made the adjustments I said I'd make. That brings his score to 42.

I actually went back through the topics and averaged the scores given just cause I'm curious to see how they match up. I threw out scores with no explanations. Those were mostly all 5s, but there were a couple trollishly low scores too. Here are the final averages:

Jay-Z - 38.3

BIG - 40.3

Pac - 36.8

Nas - 42.1

The hilarious thing is that the people that insisted that averaging was the way I should do it were Jay and Pac dickriders. Well Jay's score went up, but so did Biggie's and the Nas score is the same, so he's still behind them. And Pac actually fell about a point while everyone else went up. So what excuse do you dudes have now? I'm carrying both sets of scores through the topics now.

You can't do that.

You can't throw away scores because you don't agree with them. Imagine if politics worked like that. Two candidates running for an election and the person in charge of counting the votes threw out votes that they disagreed with.

Count all the votes or stop this foolishness.

Yeah I can. I've said before that the only scores that have any meaning are the ones with explanations. If someone comes in here and says "So and so is the GOAT, all 5s." I'm not counting it. If they do like you did and give all fives but actually explain, then I counted it. It's not about whether I agree with the scores or not. I didn't agree with most of them. It's about whether the person attempted to go by the rules of the categories or just blindly gave the max score to boost their favorite rapper.

You didn't say that in your O/P.

I gave Biggie all 5s. If you said that I have to give explanations I would have, but you didn't say that do I didn't.

I know I didn't say it in the OP. I wasn't averaging anything at first remember. I didn't even want people to give their own scores. I was providing a baseline score, and I wanted people to provide arguments in order to get that score closer to something everyone agreed with. That's still the ultimate goal of these threads. I just calculated those averages because people have been asking for them and because I was curious. I left out the unexplained all 5 scores because they aren't really in line with the spirit of the thread at all.

2. No one person's vote is more important than another person

This alone pulls out objectivity because 90% of this board has no idea how to be objective. They regularly let shit that has nothing to do with the music affect their opinions.

Exactly. People just can't seem to accept that for these threads I purposely made it so that objectivity was more important than equal representation. We get plenty of popularity contest threads on here. That's not what I wanted to do.

Yeah, but when I said for impact Nas should get a 5 for Illmatic and all the mc that are inspired by him. Both friends and foes, you started talking about impact in other shit. Is it about the music or not?

I pointed out that one album couldn't get you a 5 and gave you everything else considered for the Impact score. All were music and HipHop related. Plus I said several times that I would up the Impact score and asked for input on the proposed score. At this point y'all just complaining to complain.

Nas had the whole Hip-Hop community debating if hip-hop was dead. He made it cool for the east and west coast to work together. Rapper from Planet Asia have redone his songs. Ezail , Mf Doom, 9 wonders and others have remixed whole albums. How is that not major impact?

 

[JJ_Evans]

This site is full of Nas and Meek Mill stans. Yall disgust me

2Pac is the greatest to ever do this rap thing. Point blank period!

 

[jim1000]

Nas is pretty close to the perfect MC, but he doesn't deserve a perfect score.

Take Catalog for instance. He's got a big catalog and that is due to his longevity, so he deserves credit for that, but not every album in that catalog is strong. Nastradamus is pretty weak as albums from good artists go. And I personally think Double CDs are a bad decision in general, but even in the context of measure Street's Disciple against other Double CDs, it's one of the weaker ones. Compare that to someone like Pac. Sure, Illmatic is arguably better than any of Pac's albums, but all of Pac's studio albums are good. I don't believe he has the low points that Nas had which is why I gave him a 5.

2 bad albums out of 11 isn't a bad record. And Street Disciple wasn't as bad as Gift and a Curse. He had a lot of bangers on it too. Theif Theme, These are our heroes, Street Disciple, Disciples, Rest of my life, Moment in time, Nazereth Savage, U.B.R, War, Getting Married. I don't think it was that bad. I like it. And Nas have whole albums with themes. Hip-Hop is dead had a theme. Untitled, and God son had a theme and so did Life is good. There are not too many rappers with 9 really great albums mix with at least 4-6 classic or critical acclaimed albums in their discography.

I said this before and I will say it again. Street's Disciple disk 1 is a classic by itself. Not one bad song on Disk 1. I'm surprised you didn't mention reason or Live Now. I agree SD is not as bad as some here make it out to be.

 

[JJ_Evans]

Nas is pretty close to the perfect MC, but he doesn't deserve a perfect score.

Take Catalog for instance. He's got a big catalog and that is due to his longevity, so he deserves credit for that, but not every album in that catalog is strong. Nastradamus is pretty weak as albums from good artists go. And I personally think Double CDs are a bad decision in general, but even in the context of measure Street's Disciple against other Double CDs, it's one of the weaker ones. Compare that to someone like Pac. Sure, Illmatic is arguably better than any of Pac's albums, but all of Pac's studio albums are good. I don't believe he has the low points that Nas had which is why I gave him a 5.

2 bad albums out of 11 isn't a bad record. And Street Disciple wasn't as bad as Gift and a Curse. He had a lot of bangers on it too. Theif Theme, These are our heroes, Street Disciple, Disciples, Rest of my life, Moment in time, Nazereth Savage, U.B.R, War, Getting Married. I don't think it was that bad. I like it. And Nas have whole albums with themes. Hip-Hop is dead had a theme. Untitled, and God son had a theme and so did Life is good. There are not too many rappers with 9 really great albums mix with at least 4-6 classic or critical acclaimed albums in their discography.

I said this before and I will say it again. Street's Disciple disk 1 is a classic by itself. Not one bad song on Disk 1. I'm surprised you didn't mention reason or Live Now. I agree SD is not as bad as some here make it out to be.

You have 180 posts in 7 years. Who are you really?

 

[jim1000]

Nas is pretty close to the perfect MC, but he doesn't deserve a perfect score.

Take Catalog for instance. He's got a big catalog and that is due to his longevity, so he deserves credit for that, but not every album in that catalog is strong. Nastradamus is pretty weak as albums from good artists go. And I personally think Double CDs are a bad decision in general, but even in the context of measure Street's Disciple against other Double CDs, it's one of the weaker ones. Compare that to someone like Pac. Sure, Illmatic is arguably better than any of Pac's albums, but all of Pac's studio albums are good. I don't believe he has the low points that Nas had which is why I gave him a 5.

2 bad albums out of 11 isn't a bad record. And Street Disciple wasn't as bad as Gift and a Curse. He had a lot of bangers on it too. Theif Theme, These are our heroes, Street Disciple, Disciples, Rest of my life, Moment in time, Nazereth Savage, U.B.R, War, Getting Married. I don't think it was that bad. I like it. And Nas have whole albums with themes. Hip-Hop is dead had a theme. Untitled, and God son had a theme and so did Life is good. There are not too many rappers with 9 really great albums mix with at least 4-6 classic or critical acclaimed albums in their discography.

But 4 isn't a bad score though. 4 means that he stands out even among good to great rappers. And if he truly had 2 bad albums, 6 great albums, and 4 classics, he'd definitely get a 5. But objectively speaking, even as a Nas fan, I don't think his discography breaks down that favorably. I Am is actually one of my favorite Nas albums, but it's not even close to classic. The same goes for God's Son. He's got 2 or 3 classics, 2 or 3 subpar albums, and the rest are just good. That's more like a 4 than a 5.

2 or 3 subpar albums?? I will give you Nastradamus but what other album was subpar to you?? IAM is criminally underrated though. GS may not be a classic but its a damn great album and a very good follow up to Stillmatic. GS imo is damn near close to classic.

 

[jim1000]

Also Nas got rappers like Cam and Jim Jones saying he was an influence on them as rappers. Prodigy said it too. J Cole, Dave East, Eziel too. They have classes on Nas lyrics in colleges. The Outlawz admitted they were happy when Pac made peace with Nas because he was one of their favorites. Game got into beef with 50 because he was a Nas fan. He got a classic movie. A couple documentaries too.

And to add to this you have southern rappers that have Nas high on their list. Scarface had Nas number 6 on his list while his top 5 had all OG rappers from the 80s. Nas definitely gets love from all regions. Nas is also HUGE in Africa. Dude is definitely an international Superstar for a guy that is so low key.

 

[jim1000]

Ok, no one agrees with the Impact score. I asked if 4 was a good compromise. You guys are making good arguments that it deserves to be raised, but a 5 would put him on Jay and 2Pac's level and above Big based on previous scoring. Do ya'll really think that Nas holds that much influence in the industry? I mean let's be real, someone like 50 has had more of an impact than Nas. His music hasn't been as good or meaningful, but for a while every move he made had an effect on pretty much everyone else coming out in NYC. Can you really say that's ever been the case for Nas?

50 has more impact than Nas in the Hip hop industry?? My nigga you can't be serious with this. How many people have you heard say that 50 was their favorite rapper?? What impact did 50 bring besides vitamin water??

 

[jim1000]

Ok, but can you admit that you are a little biased with your assessments?

SD is typically spoken about nearly as badly as Nastradamus, so that's two that are bad.

And who calls all those albums classics? Mostly Nas fans right? What average Hip Hop fan is running around talking about the Lost Tapes or God's Son are classics? Hell, I'm a Nas fan and I don't even believe that. I think the majority of his albums are good to great, but he has some that aren't all that. As a result, I'd say a 5 is high for his Catalog, but what about a 4.5. That would mean that he for sure has a Top 10 Catalog. Would you agree with that?

If Streets Disciple and Nastradamus are Nas's worst albums then he gets a strong 5 for catalog. Those two albums are better than most people's albums.

And if you compare those two albums to anybody else who has a 20+ year career, anybody else probably has two or three albums that aren't as strong as their best albums

LL Cool J

Eminem

Jay Z

Rakim

KRS One

Kool G Rap

Masta Ace

Snoop

Ice Cube

Outkast

The Roots

WuTang (Method Man, Ghostface, Raekwon)

The Lox (Jadakiss, Styles P, Sheek Louch)

Cam'ron

Too $hort

Master P

E-40

^^^ Thats 20 artists that have been around for 20+years. How many of them can you say have a better catalog than Nas?

TBH I'd say none.

 

[jim1000]

Nas is pretty close to the perfect MC, but he doesn't deserve a perfect score.

Take Catalog for instance. He's got a big catalog and that is due to his longevity, so he deserves credit for that, but not every album in that catalog is strong. Nastradamus is pretty weak as albums from good artists go. And I personally think Double CDs are a bad decision in general, but even in the context of measure Street's Disciple against other Double CDs, it's one of the weaker ones. Compare that to someone like Pac. Sure, Illmatic is arguably better than any of Pac's albums, but all of Pac's studio albums are good. I don't believe he has the low points that Nas had which is why I gave him a 5.

2 bad albums out of 11 isn't a bad record. And Street Disciple wasn't as bad as Gift and a Curse. He had a lot of bangers on it too. Theif Theme, These are our heroes, Street Disciple, Disciples, Rest of my life, Moment in time, Nazereth Savage, U.B.R, War, Getting Married. I don't think it was that bad. I like it. And Nas have whole albums with themes. Hip-Hop is dead had a theme. Untitled, and God son had a theme and so did Life is good. There are not too many rappers with 9 really great albums mix with at least 4-6 classic or critical acclaimed albums in their discography.

I said this before and I will say it again. Street's Disciple disk 1 is a classic by itself. Not one bad song on Disk 1. I'm surprised you didn't mention reason or Live Now. I agree SD is not as bad as some here make it out to be.

You have 180 posts in 7 years. Who are you really?

Oh so I need a million post to be cool now?? Got it.

 

[JJ_Evans]

Nas is pretty close to the perfect MC, but he doesn't deserve a perfect score.

Take Catalog for instance. He's got a big catalog and that is due to his longevity, so he deserves credit for that, but not every album in that catalog is strong. Nastradamus is pretty weak as albums from good artists go. And I personally think Double CDs are a bad decision in general, but even in the context of measure Street's Disciple against other Double CDs, it's one of the weaker ones. Compare that to someone like Pac. Sure, Illmatic is arguably better than any of Pac's albums, but all of Pac's studio albums are good. I don't believe he has the low points that Nas had which is why I gave him a 5.

2 bad albums out of 11 isn't a bad record. And Street Disciple wasn't as bad as Gift and a Curse. He had a lot of bangers on it too. Theif Theme, These are our heroes, Street Disciple, Disciples, Rest of my life, Moment in time, Nazereth Savage, U.B.R, War, Getting Married. I don't think it was that bad. I like it. And Nas have whole albums with themes. Hip-Hop is dead had a theme. Untitled, and God son had a theme and so did Life is good. There are not too many rappers with 9 really great albums mix with at least 4-6 classic or critical acclaimed albums in their discography.

I said this before and I will say it again. Street's Disciple disk 1 is a classic by itself. Not one bad song on Disk 1. I'm surprised you didn't mention reason or Live Now. I agree SD is not as bad as some here make it out to be.

You have 180 posts in 7 years. Who are you really?

Oh so I need a million post to be cool now?? Got it.

Not a million, but definitely more than 180 in 7 years.

Something is fishy about you popping up now, spamming the thread with all the Nas love.

 

[The Lonious Monk]

Nas is pretty close to the perfect MC, but he doesn't deserve a perfect score.

Take Catalog for instance. He's got a big catalog and that is due to his longevity, so he deserves credit for that, but not every album in that catalog is strong. Nastradamus is pretty weak as albums from good artists go. And I personally think Double CDs are a bad decision in general, but even in the context of measure Street's Disciple against other Double CDs, it's one of the weaker ones. Compare that to someone like Pac. Sure, Illmatic is arguably better than any of Pac's albums, but all of Pac's studio albums are good. I don't believe he has the low points that Nas had which is why I gave him a 5.

2 bad albums out of 11 isn't a bad record. And Street Disciple wasn't as bad as Gift and a Curse. He had a lot of bangers on it too. Theif Theme, These are our heroes, Street Disciple, Disciples, Rest of my life, Moment in time, Nazereth Savage, U.B.R, War, Getting Married. I don't think it was that bad. I like it. And Nas have whole albums with themes. Hip-Hop is dead had a theme. Untitled, and God son had a theme and so did Life is good. There are not too many rappers with 9 really great albums mix with at least 4-6 classic or critical acclaimed albums in their discography.

But 4 isn't a bad score though. 4 means that he stands out even among good to great rappers. And if he truly had 2 bad albums, 6 great albums, and 4 classics, he'd definitely get a 5. But objectively speaking, even as a Nas fan, I don't think his discography breaks down that favorably. I Am is actually one of my favorite Nas albums, but it's not even close to classic. The same goes for God's Son. He's got 2 or 3 classics, 2 or 3 subpar albums, and the rest are just good. That's more like a 4 than a 5.

2 or 3 subpar albums?? I will give you Nastradamus but what other album was subpar to you?? IAM is criminally underrated though. GS may not be a classic but its a damn great album and a very good follow up to Stillmatic. GS imo is damn near close to classic.

I personally don't think Street's Disciple is all that great. It has some good tracks, but a lot of filler.

Ok, no one agrees with the Impact score. I asked if 4 was a good compromise. You guys are making good arguments that it deserves to be raised, but a 5 would put him on Jay and 2Pac's level and above Big based on previous scoring. Do ya'll really think that Nas holds that much influence in the industry? I mean let's be real, someone like 50 has had more of an impact than Nas. His music hasn't been as good or meaningful, but for a while every move he made had an effect on pretty much everyone else coming out in NYC. Can you really say that's ever been the case for Nas?

50 has more impact than Nas in the Hip hop industry?? My nigga you can't be serious with this. How many people have you heard say that 50 was their favorite rapper?? What impact did 50 bring besides vitamin water??

Plenty of people said 50 was their favorite in his heyday, and while long term Nas probably wins out. There was a short time when 50 was in the limelight to a larger degree than Nas ever has been. It's not necessarily a good thing, but he pretty much made beef and dissension the "in" thing in NYC for a while.

 

[5 Grand]

Plenty of people said 50 was their favorite in his heyday, and while long term Nas probably wins out. There was a short time when 50 was in the limelight to a larger degree than Nas ever has been. It's not necessarily a good thing, but he pretty much made beef and dissension the "in" thing in NYC for a while.

Actually when Ether dropped Nas had the throne for about a year. This was before GRODT. Eminem had more pop appeal and sold more records, but amongst Hip Hop heads Nas owned 2002.

He released 3 classics in the span of one year (Stillmatic, Lost Tapes, God's Son)

 

[The Lonious Monk]

Plenty of people said 50 was their favorite in his heyday, and while long term Nas probably wins out. There was a short time when 50 was in the limelight to a larger degree than Nas ever has been. It's not necessarily a good thing, but he pretty much made beef and dissension the "in" thing in NYC for a while.

Actually when Ether dropped Nas had the throne for about a year. This was before GRODT. Eminem had more pop appeal and sold more records, but amongst Hip Hop heads Nas owned 2002.

He released 3 classics in the span of one year (Stillmatic, Lost Tapes, God's Son)

True, like I said, the most shine Nas has ever gotten was as a result of his battle with Jay. And by shine, I'm just talking about general acclaim. Hardcore HipHop fans have always given him his due.

 

[jim1000]

Nas is pretty close to the perfect MC, but he doesn't deserve a perfect score.

Take Catalog for instance. He's got a big catalog and that is due to his longevity, so he deserves credit for that, but not every album in that catalog is strong. Nastradamus is pretty weak as albums from good artists go. And I personally think Double CDs are a bad decision in general, but even in the context of measure Street's Disciple against other Double CDs, it's one of the weaker ones. Compare that to someone like Pac. Sure, Illmatic is arguably better than any of Pac's albums, but all of Pac's studio albums are good. I don't believe he has the low points that Nas had which is why I gave him a 5.

2 bad albums out of 11 isn't a bad record. And Street Disciple wasn't as bad as Gift and a Curse. He had a lot of bangers on it too. Theif Theme, These are our heroes, Street Disciple, Disciples, Rest of my life, Moment in time, Nazereth Savage, U.B.R, War, Getting Married. I don't think it was that bad. I like it. And Nas have whole albums with themes. Hip-Hop is dead had a theme. Untitled, and God son had a theme and so did Life is good. There are not too many rappers with 9 really great albums mix with at least 4-6 classic or critical acclaimed albums in their discography.

I said this before and I will say it again. Street's Disciple disk 1 is a classic by itself. Not one bad song on Disk 1. I'm surprised you didn't mention reason or Live Now. I agree SD is not as bad as some here make it out to be.

You have 180 posts in 7 years. Who are you really?

Oh so I need a million post to be cool now?? Got it.

Not a million, but definitely more than 180 in 7 years.

Something is fishy about you popping up now, spamming the thread with all the Nas love.

Why do I need more than 180?? Who are you the administrator?? I've been active and read a lot of threads here but I don't post as much but that doesn't make me any less of a hip hop fan than you. I didn't know that niggas are actually checking for post count on these forums now. SMDH!!

 

[jim1000]

Nas is pretty close to the perfect MC, but he doesn't deserve a perfect score.

Take Catalog for instance. He's got a big catalog and that is due to his longevity, so he deserves credit for that, but not every album in that catalog is strong. Nastradamus is pretty weak as albums from good artists go. And I personally think Double CDs are a bad decision in general, but even in the context of measure Street's Disciple against other Double CDs, it's one of the weaker ones. Compare that to someone like Pac. Sure, Illmatic is arguably better than any of Pac's albums, but all of Pac's studio albums are good. I don't believe he has the low points that Nas had which is why I gave him a 5.

2 bad albums out of 11 isn't a bad record. And Street Disciple wasn't as bad as Gift and a Curse. He had a lot of bangers on it too. Theif Theme, These are our heroes, Street Disciple, Disciples, Rest of my life, Moment in time, Nazereth Savage, U.B.R, War, Getting Married. I don't think it was that bad. I like it. And Nas have whole albums with themes. Hip-Hop is dead had a theme. Untitled, and God son had a theme and so did Life is good. There are not too many rappers with 9 really great albums mix with at least 4-6 classic or critical acclaimed albums in their discography.

But 4 isn't a bad score though. 4 means that he stands out even among good to great rappers. And if he truly had 2 bad albums, 6 great albums, and 4 classics, he'd definitely get a 5. But objectively speaking, even as a Nas fan, I don't think his discography breaks down that favorably. I Am is actually one of my favorite Nas albums, but it's not even close to classic. The same goes for God's Son. He's got 2 or 3 classics, 2 or 3 subpar albums, and the rest are just good. That's more like a 4 than a 5.

2 or 3 subpar albums?? I will give you Nastradamus but what other album was subpar to you?? IAM is criminally underrated though. GS may not be a classic but its a damn great album and a very good follow up to Stillmatic. GS imo is damn near close to classic.

I personally don't think Street's Disciple is all that great. It has some good tracks, but a lot of filler.

Ok, no one agrees with the Impact score. I asked if 4 was a good compromise. You guys are making good arguments that it deserves to be raised, but a 5 would put him on Jay and 2Pac's level and above Big based on previous scoring. Do ya'll really think that Nas holds that much influence in the industry? I mean let's be real, someone like 50 has had more of an impact than Nas. His music hasn't been as good or meaningful, but for a while every move he made had an effect on pretty much everyone else coming out in NYC. Can you really say that's ever been the case for Nas?

50 has more impact than Nas in the Hip hop industry?? My nigga you can't be serious with this. How many people have you heard say that 50 was their favorite rapper?? What impact did 50 bring besides vitamin water??

Plenty of people said 50 was their favorite in his heyday, and while long term Nas probably wins out. There was a short time when 50 was in the limelight to a larger degree than Nas ever has been. It's not necessarily a good thing, but he pretty much made beef and dissension the "in" thing in NYC for a while.

In short term yes which was around 2003 but overall impact?? Even 50 himself will tell you that Nas has more impact than him. Even his own soldier Banks put Nas in his top 5 and excluded 50 from his list.

SD may not be all that great to you which is fine and I understand that because of disc 2 but I wouldn't go as far and say it was subpar overall.