all depends but imo no but many ppl will tell u that it is...pesonally if u dont have uncharted 2 get that single player is better and multiplayer is better
the sp in red dead gets kinda boring after awhile same shit over and over(i know thats every game but u know) the multiplayer has free roam and is decent but again not as good as uncharted...the only positive really is that the game is new and ppl are on it heavy(and maybe free roam)
it all depends on what games you already have and what games you dont me having over 60 games there really wasnt nunin else to buy except for this game.....
but read some reviews watch some vids because i got bored with gta as well so of course to me this would be boring(saints row 2 really the only game like that that kept my attention)