Video of Fatal Shooting by Off-Duty Officer in Brooklyn Emerges
The video was grainy, and the men on the street were blurs rendered in black and white. But the clip, recorded by a surveillance camera pointed at a Brooklyn intersection, shows a man approaching the driver’s side window of a car, and then, in an instant, stumbling away before collapsing onto the pavement.
Law enforcement officials said they believed that the video, which circulated late last week, showed the fatal shooting of the man, Delrawn Small, by an off-duty New York City police officer during a traffic dispute on July 4.
“I broke down; I couldn’t stop crying,” Zayanahla Vines, a nephew of Mr. Small, said at a protest in Manhattan on Saturday, recounting his reaction to the footage. “I had to go outside and get a breath of fresh air.”
The clip surfaced as the nation was grappling with videos, broadcast on television and shared widely on social media, of confrontations over the past week between black men and police officers. Mr. Small’s death preceded the fatal shootings of Alton B. Sterling, who was killed early Tuesday by officers in Baton Rouge, La., and Philando Castile, who was killed on Wednesday in Falcon Heights, Minn.
In Mr. Sterling’s case, bystanders recorded the shooting on cellphone video; in Mr. Castile’s, his girlfriend, Diamond Reynolds, broadcast the traffic stop using Facebook Live.
Unlike the other men, Mr. Small, 37, encountered the police officer, identified by law enforcement officials as Wayne Isaacs, when the officer was off duty. The Police Department said that Officer Isaacs, who is also 37, had just completed a 4-p.m.-to-midnight shift and was driving home alone.
The New York State attorney general, Eric T. Schneiderman, has started an investigation into the shooting. A year ago, Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo of New York issued an executive order naming Mr. Schneiderman’s office as a special prosecutor handling police-related civilian deaths.
In a statement issued on Friday, Mr. Schneiderman said the video was being reviewed as part of the investigation. The video was first reported by The New York Post.
As special prosecutor, I am committed to conducting a full, fair and independent investigation of this tragedy,” he said, “and will follow the facts and evidence — including this video evidence — wherever they lead.”
Shortly after midnight on July 4, the authorities said, Officer Isaacs fired his 9-millimeter service pistol after he and Mr. Small stopped at a red light on Atlantic Avenue in the Cypress Hills neighborhood of Brooklyn. Mr. Small’s girlfriend and two children were in the car.
According to a preliminary version of events from the police, Mr. Small got out of his car after stopping at the light, at Bradford Street, and approached Officer Isaacs, punching him through the open car window. Mr. Small was struck by three bullets, in the chest, abdomen and arm, according to the medical examiner.
But in the video, there appeared to be a short window between when Mr. Small approached Officer Isaacs’s car and when he recoiled from the gunfire. The attorney general’s office declined to discuss the video. Law enforcement officials who have reviewed the footage said that it did not provide complete answers to what happened between the two men.
Efforts to reach Officer Isaacs were unsuccessful, and the Patrolmen’s Benevolent Association, the union representing New York’s rank-and-file police officers, declined to comment.
On Saturday night, Mr. Small’s name was invoked along with Mr. Sterling’s and Mr. Castile’s by the protesters who marched through the streets of Lower Manhattan.
“My uncle was killed in cold blood by somebody that was wearing a badge, and that man is still walking free today,” Mr. Vines, 22, said, addressing the hundreds of demonstrators. “We can’t stand for this any longer. It’s not right, and we know it’s not right.”
Wenona Small, who was married to Mr. Small, said that she was disturbed by the video and has struggled to grasp what happened. She had been separated from him for years, she said, but they had remained friends.
“I felt like I was being shot as I watched it,” Ms. Small said. “Nobody deserves to die like that.”