YoungGoldie;7785961 said:Stiff;7785875 said:YoungGoldie;7785831 said:Stiff;7785780 said:Let me put it like this:
When they flew 2 planes into the Towers and on 9/11 about 3,000 died..and everybody was riled up talking about wanting to bring those responsible to justice
Nobody spoke up and said "but, but, but, 10-15,000 Americans kill other Americans every year! How come nobody is riled up about that? In the same month that those people were killed by Al-Qaeda, how may Americans were killed by other Americans? Where's the outrage?"
That would have been a ridiculous thing to say. Any person of prominence who would have said that in the days after 9/11 would have gotten considerable backlash.
If Black people are rallied behind an issue that effects us and exposes one of the many symptoms of White Supremacy, what good does it do to try to dilute the message by pointing the finger back at Black people? What does the crime rate have to drop to before we're allowed to have a focused conversation about the external factors that are putting weight on us and our communities? Not everybody in the hood is in a gang. Not everybody that is out protesting screaming Black Lives Matter hates themselves or has low self-esteem or is trying to kill other Black people. White supremacy though effects EVERYBODY.
I think the song is dope. I definitely don't think Kendrick Lamar is a coon. I appreciate that Kendrick dropped a record about Black consciousness even though it's not from my own point of view because maybe it will inspire an artist to drop a song that will be more in line with my views. I'm definitely checking for the album.
You normally make good points fam, but that was a terrible analogy. Comparing black on black crime (something we can control) to terrorist attacts (something we cant control) ? Word?
Nah you looking at it wrong. It's internal vs external.
We can control black on black crime (internal)
We ultimately can't control police brutality against us or the injustices of the justice system against us, we can only work to influence their occurrences (external)
Americans in general can control our own murder rate (internal)
America can't control whether or not a terrorist launches an attack against America , it can only work to influence their occurrences (external)
And also, depending on your own definition of terrorism I would argue that many police departments nationwide are guilty of terrorist acts, on a small scale. It's all about psychological warfare and I'm sure you won't argue that the police indulge in that.
Basically, I'm comparing the actions of the police and the justice system to terrorism. We in Black America should respond to terrorism with the same attitude regular America does.
I agree 100% fam.
But you said:
Nobody spoke up and said "but, but, but, 10-15,000 Americans kill other Americans every year! How come nobody is riled up about that?
^^ That would be from the perspective of a normal citizen. Again, K.Dot was speaking from the pov of a killer. If he was one of the people who killed a handful of those 10,000, would that not be hypocritical to say?
Absolutely but in this particular instance I kind of have in mind Kendrick's interview with Billboard where he said
What happened to [Michael Brown] should've never happened. Never. But when we don't have respect for ourselves, how do we expect them to respect us? It starts from within
So I guess you could say I'm coming in to the song looking at it kind of slanted. I feel like the 3rd verse was kind of an extension of that mind state, but with some poetic/artistic freedom.