Jimmy Smith>>>>Chris Carter & Michael Irvin

[dmv_use2thewait]

Oh and Jimmy Smith ain't even the best receiver with the last name Smith...pick either one if you know who i'm talking about.

 

[Jdilla26]

In '94 smith was cut by cowboys...............he was picked up by an expansion team jags...........very good reciever but better than irvin...........nah i wouldnt say that the amount of big games irvin killed in u cant even make the comparison.....and smith was the only legitimate reciever on his team i'll give u this jimmy smith is the greatest receiver for the jags of all-time and hof worthy..........but irvin>>>>>smith

 

[R.D.]

not only was he better but he was better after sniffing a shit load of coke the night before the game lol......

You saying that like Jimmy wasn't on coke too

He probably picked it up from Irvin

I expected the Cowboy fans to be upset because you'd like to think Irvin was better than Smith but he wasnt. Just got more exposure and played on a championship team.

and if that squad of Smith (and McCardell), Taylor, and Brunnell was playing for a team in a legitimate market, more people would realilze and remember just how talented of an offense that was. But much like now, nobody is checkin for Jacksonville, Florida unless they want to read some kind of fucked up news headline

 

[Coo Coo Cal's Beanie]

Chris Carter > everybody not name Rice or Moss.

I'm not counting.the dudes that's great but still playing.

ROFL nigga please. T.O. and Irvin is better than Cris Carter

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

Let's be real, the only reason people say Troy was overrated is because he didn't put up gaudy statistics like his peers.

Dude is a winner and was clutch.

 

[Darius]

Let's be real, the only reason people say Troy was overrated is because he didn't put up gaudy statistics like his peers.

Dude is a winner and was clutch.

so was terry bradshaw, but people know better than to act like he was a great quarterback.

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

so was terry bradshaw, but people know better than to act like he was a great quarterback.

People don't think Terry was a great QB?

 

[Shizlansky]

ROFL nigga please. T.O. and Irvin is better than Cris Carter

I said not counting players that still plays, I count T.O. as still playing obviously cuz he ain't retired. Learn to read nigga.

And ill take C.C. over Irvin.

 

[Shizlansky]

People don't think Terry was a great QB?

You didn't know?

 

[Shizlansky]

Aikman not even top 20 at his position. Maybe even not top 25.

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

Overrated? Yes

Not a good QB? never

 

[Shizlansky]

Overrated? Yes

Not a good QB? never

Duh, that's what he is. A good QB.

 

[Coo Coo Cal's Beanie]

I said not counting players that still plays, I count T.O. as still playing obviously cuz he ain't retired. Learn to read nigga.

And ill take C.C. over Irvin.

LMFAO @ counting TO as a player that still plays and he is 38 with no contract offers. You retarded as fucc nigga

 

[R.D.]

Eff that Woody from Toy story looking mufucka Troy Aikman

This thread is about acknowledging Jimmy Smith as the king of the coke head receivers

 

[R.D.]

................................

 

[plocc]

Not only was irvin a better player. He made his teammates better.

That thought that smith is better is blasphemous. Also lets not forget

irvin was putting in work on sunday after partying with bitches and

blow the previous day. Stop playin.

 

[usmarin3]

Irvin would of had 300 more catches if he would of played in a pass first offense, him and Aikman sacrifice numbers for Emmitt

 

[Coo Coo Cal's Beanie]

Irvin would of had 300 more catches if he would of played in a pass first offense, him and Aikman sacrifice numbers for Emmitt

exactly what i was saying. actually he'd prolly have possibly 500 more catches and at least 30 more TDs

 

[R.D.]

You niggas act like we aint have Fred Taylor and FOH with all these excuses for for Irvin numbers. Jimmy aint even play his 1st two years in the league, throw in the suspensions and he missed out on having far better numbers too. If you've never seen Jimmy Smith play, bite your tongue and one game don't count.

 

[Coo Coo Cal's Beanie]

You niggas act like we aint have Fred Taylor and FOH with all these excuses for for Irvin numbers. Jimmy aint even play his 1st two years in the league, throw in the suspensions and he missed out on having far better numbers too. If you've never seen Jimmy Smith play, bite your tongue and one game don't count.

nobody said jimmy smith wasnt great. He is. U picked the wrong player to compare him to. Cris Carter is overrated so its a fair assessment there. But irvin was far better than both them niggas