DR. JEK;6015810 said:
JM1971;6015140 said:
Why does it seem like people skim through Jay's stuff and not nitpick other artist the same way as Jay get's criticized. What is it about Jay that causes people to debate with all feelings and assumptions rather than doing research and bringing facts? People get overzealous when criticizing him lol.
If anything, Jay has kept it realer than people give him credit for. I think artist like like Nas has displayed more questionable behavior throughout his career than Jay did. But I guess Nas's "image" or what people "perceive" that he stands for and the fact he's the underdog prevents him from getting nitpicked.
If you look at how many passes this guy gets in the rap game, the fact you cant even say Reasonable dought was ahhight instead of a classic without jigga warriors coming in with the same tired bullshit in rebutals, the fact that Jay can bite lyrics, nigga name dropped plenty on his albums without catchin any of the heat The Game catch, gets gorified for shit Nas gets crucified over, got niggas actin like cant nobody outrap him on a song even tho Ye does it repeatedly, .....Come on man, for every 1 person that gives him criticism on this site you know there are 3 people ready to sweep it under the rug and dickryde his money, his marriage to Bey, his past sells like that matters if current shit is good or not, and just plain ol
"call a nigga a hater when they cant refute nothing effectively" ass posters when they hero gets talked about. Niggas act like Jay z finna send them a check n shit. You can save that Jay gets a raw deal shit because niggas turn this shit into a jay z lifetime achievement award ceremony everytime somebody post something meh about what jay say or did.
I agree, overzealous fans are annoying and they can come off as irrational and difficult to have a civilized debate with. But tbh, I've never seen a thread where someone just said anything Jay made was just "aight", the criticism always seems to be in extremes filled with a lot of misinformation and it's like the OP never does their homework before posting, but there's a tone of conviction with their post and they come off as though what they say is fact.....and anyone who doesn't share their viewpoint is a "stan" or whatever. That's how it looks imo. Everything just seems to be in extremes lol. On that note, I do agree that Reasonable Doubt isn't a true classic just off the strength of the lack of impact it had in 96...but it's his best lyrical effort. You also mentioned that Jay bites lyrics, and that's another critic I don't get. Do people honestly believe that Jay is really trying to pass off those lyrics as his own? Why do people feel that way? I never heard anyone critique that about him until after Ether came out. Dude is smart enough to come up with his own quotes, hot lines, ghostwrite for others, and run successful businesses but he's somehow dumb enough to believe that he can pass off lines from famous songs as his own lol? Every artist in hip hop has quoted another rappers lyrics out of respect. The culture in general is built off sampling period. Jay get's quoted so much that it's crazy, but other rappers aren't under the same microscope I guess. Pac quoted Method Man and CL Smooth lyrics on All Eyes on Me ("I came to bring the pain, hardcore to the brain, lets go inside your gastroplane") ("2 years ago, a friend of mine told me Alize and Cristal blows your mind"). Snoop redid and entire Slick Rick song on Doggy Style, Biggie quote Slick Rick on the Hypnotize chorus. I understand a lot of the other criticism about dude to an extent, but not the whole "he's stealing lyrics" thing. What is the definition of biting, because I've seen stuff that was labeled as biten while a similar act gets a pass.
Game's style is just annoying to me lol, I don't think he's a biter, he name drops because he's a fan of the "the game", hence his name is "Game", but his first album was OD annoying to me because he name dropped back to back in every verse on every single track. That's his style though.