Is Emenim overrated????

[illogics]

cosign.

If Eminem was from Brooklyn, Queens are thee East Coast & black. niggas wouldve been saying he better then Jay, but since he from Midwest, white & rap about the things they dont relate to, MC's like Canibus aka The walking dictionary with no ability to craft a song & others are better

I don't understand your logic. Everything you said would equal Eminem being a completely different artist so of course his reception would be different.

 

[Question Authority]

cosign.

If Eminem was from Brooklyn, Queens are thee East Coast & black. niggas wouldve been saying he better then Jay, but since he from Midwest, white & rap about the things they dont relate to, MC's like Canibus aka The walking dictionary with no ability to craft a song & others are better

I agree with this and that's what I've been trying to say this entire time.

Niggas dislike Em because he's white. There's no way to sugarcoat that shit anymore. It's too obvious.

He killed Jay on Renegade...and niggas is still not satisfied.

He committed first degree murder in that BET Cipher against Black Thought and Mos Def...and niggas is still not satisfied.

He murked both Masta Ace and Biggie on their respective collabos...and niggas is still not satisfied.

He shitted on Wayne, Drake, and Kanye...and niggas is still not satisfied.

He released two critically acclaimed, best selling albums...and niggas is still not satisfied.

Em's race is his biggest disadvantage...that's what I think stops him being mentioned amongst the GOATS. If he was black, it wouldn't be a problem. But, because he's white and arguably the best rapper alive right now, niggas are bitter.

Sad that we're in 2010 and people are still stuck on color.

 

[illogics]

I agree with this and that's what I've been trying to say this entire time.

Niggas dislike Em because he's white. There's no way to sugarcoat that shit anymore. It's too obvious.

He killed Jay on Renegade...and niggas is still not satisfied.

He committed first degree murder in that BET Cipher against Black Thought and Mos Def...and niggas is still not satisfied.

He murked both Masta Ace and Biggie on their respective collabos...and niggas is still not satisfied.

He shitted on Wayne, Drake, and Kanye...and niggas is still not satisfied.

He released two critically acclaimed, best selling albums...and niggas is still not satisfied.

Em's race is his biggest disadvantage...that's what I think stops him being mentioned amongst the GOATS. If he was black, it wouldn't be a problem. But, because he's white and arguably the best rapper alive right now, niggas are bitter.

Sad that we're in 2010 and people are still stuck on color.

His race, His content, His antics, His poor discography, His flow replacing actually making sense (like the BET Cypher which LYRICALLY, black thought murdered harder than eminem) are all reason why some don't see him as GOAT. Get mad if you want to.

 

[Question Authority]

Poor discography...according to whom? Those who can't relate to his subject matter?

Regardless of how the people in this thread feel, Em has three critically acclaimed, best selling albums.

SSLP, MMLP, and TES were all not only highly successful commercially, but were all critically lauded, and even rank on "Best Albums" lists.

 

[illogics]

SSLP, MMLP, and TES were all not only highly successful commercially, but were all critically lauded, and even rank on "Best Albums" lists.

Now let me ask you this.....by WHO? Rolling Stone magazine?

 

[Question Authority]

Now let me ask you this.....by WHO? Rolling Stone magazine?

Amongst other publications...

 

[Yung_Souf_Money]

while 50 cent beefin with rick ross and other rappers,Eminem beating everybody in sales.50 cent need to stop being the puppet in this rap game and make good music for people to hear

 

[illogics]

Amongst other publications...

lol, aight chief.

 

[isayas]

HAHAHAHAHAHA@ Em having a poor discography.

 

[5th Letter]

I agree with this and that's what I've been trying to say this entire time.

Niggas dislike Em because he's white. There's no way to sugarcoat that shit anymore. It's too obvious.

He killed Jay on Renegade...and niggas is still not satisfied.

He committed first degree murder in that BET Cipher against Black Thought and Mos Def...and niggas is still not satisfied.

He murked both Masta Ace and Biggie on their respective collabos...and niggas is still not satisfied.

He shitted on Wayne, Drake, and Kanye...and niggas is still not satisfied.

He released two critically acclaimed, best selling albums...and niggas is still not satisfied.

Em's race is his biggest disadvantage...that's what I think stops him being mentioned amongst the GOATS. If he was black, it wouldn't be a problem. But, because he's white and arguably the best rapper alive right now, niggas are bitter.

Sad that we're in 2010 and people are still stuck on color.

Are seriously gonna count the Big collabo?

 

[illogics]

HAHAHAHAHAHA@ Em having a poor discography.

When talking about great Eminem albums, MMLP is the only one in the conversation. Everything before and after are forgettable.

 

[isayas]

When talking about great Eminem albums, MMLP is the only one in the conversation. Everything before and after are forgettable.

That's to you. I formulate my own opinions. Infinite, SSLP, MMLP, TES, & Relapse are all classics.

 

[isayas]

Are seriously gonna count the Big collabo?

Seriously that verse that B.I.G. was from like '93.

 

[Question Authority]

When talking about great Eminem albums, MMLP is the only one in the conversation. Everything before and after are forgettable.

SMH.

SSLP and TES are forgettable?

You do realize that they are both critically acclaimed albums...rated highly by critics and consumers all across the board.

 

[sundiata82]

Eminem is hella overrated.

This chump don't even make my top ten.....REAL TALK

 

[illogics]

SMH.

SSLP and TES are forgettable?

You do realize that they are both critically acclaimed albums...rated highly by critics and consumers all across the board.

Here we go again with this same argument. On any Hip-Hop forum you go to, how often do you see threads on SSLP or TES?

 

[sundiata82]

On a side note: What the fuck happened to all my posts????
Did everybody's post number get resetted?...SMH

 

[illogics]

That's to you. I formulate my own opinions. Infinite, SSLP, MMLP, TES, & Relapse are all classics.

Eminem wouldn't even call all those albums Classics. You're officially a stan. I'll take your words with a grain of salt from here on out.

 

[Question Authority]

Here we go again with this same argument. On any Hip-Hop forum you go to, how often do you see threads on SSLP or TES?

People still refuse to give Em his props.

Niggas just can't accept that the white dude from the trailer park is better than their favorite black rappers. Even in this thread, I see people saying "Em has no classics", but the dude has three critically acclaimed, best selling albums. What else does he need to do?

Don't pretend to be that naive son.

 

[Question Authority]

Eminem wouldn't even call all those albums Classics. You're officially a stan. I'll take your words with a grain of salt from here on out.

Lmao. I agree.

5 is definitely pushing it.

3 seems like a plausible number...with a possible 4, if you include Infinite.