How is Manning Betta Than Brady??????

  • Thread starter Thread starter New Editor
  • Start date Start date
usmarin3;166102 said:
Peyton Manning = A Rod of football

Brady = Jeter

Coming from a yankees fan, this couldn't be more true. But I think A-Rod is past his troubles now.
 
Last edited:
blazini;166220 said:
Don't for get he had Marvin all those years and their D was great also.

Please spare your breath....they had great D?????? I know you talking about another team
 
Last edited:
ghost!;166185 said:
but yet brady won a sb with wr like t.brown, d.givens, d.branch..and..and for the rec. let's not forget he had r.wayne and d.clark...a W.R. and TE that were better then what brady had for his SB runs...

best qb with medicore playoffs stats..yea ooookay

Im sorry but if your trying to use Brady to make your point, no point in arguing, Brady is just Belechik's puppet IMO. Their 11-5 record from a year ago proves to me Tom Brady is overhyped
 
Last edited:
biggar;111677 said:
He has 20000 more passing yards then Brady, 148 more TD's then Brady, and a better comp % then Brady.

I know Brady has been in the league 2 fewer years than Manning, but the numbers still wouldn't add up.

Brady had way better Defenses than Manning. Thats why he got the SB's

SO TRUE!!!

Manning has never had they type of defenses that Brady has had... like they say, Defense wins championships....
 
Last edited:
rap doctor;166359 said:
Im sorry but if your trying to use Brady to make your point, no point in arguing, Brady is just Belechik's puppet IMO. Their 11-5 record from a year ago proves to me Tom Brady is overhyped

Do all colts fans sound as stupid as you post...Brady's bellichick's puppet but he is nationally known throughout the nfl as one of the top QBs not just in the league but all time...smh yup they went 11-5 and ddint go to the super bowl w/o him..but when he was QB'ing they went to 4 SBs and won 3...smh ur hurting bad arent' you..
 
Last edited:
da scope;166395 said:
SO TRUE!!!

Manning has never had they type of defenses that Brady has had... like they say, Defense wins championships....

so what's manning excuse this year...colts defense was tops in the league..happened?
 
Last edited:
Because Brady came from an amazing system and has an amazing coach behind him who developed the veteran offensive line, defense, and kicking squad which helped propelled Brady to stardom. Where's Vinatieri's credit? What about Vrabel, Bruschi, Harrison, McGinniest? Brady wasn't the only factor in those games, he was "A" factor, but he wasn't THEE factor. Without Vinatieri, he's another John Elway pre-Terrell Davis. Is Brady top 10? Yes. Is he a HOFer? Of course. However, to deny the help Brady had that the Colts didn't...is ridiculous.
 
Last edited:
dr. zero_ahh;166522 said:
Because Brady came from an amazing system and has an amazing coach behind him who developed the veteran offensive line, defense, and kicking squad which helped propelled Brady to stardom. Where's Vinatieri's credit? What about Vrabel, Bruschi, Harrison, McGinniest? Brady wasn't the only factor in those games, he was "A" factor, but he wasn't THEE factor. Without Vinatieri, he's another John Elway pre-Terrell Davis. Is Brady top 10? Yes. Is he a HOFer? Of course. However, to deny the help Brady had that the Colts didn't...is ridiculous.

so....i guess the SB in 06.....manning won it all by hisself..i guess for manning's whole career his great offense that he has had aint a factor in his sucess

plz katz like u do this all the time..over exaggerate the props brady gets...and never pay attention to this same over exaggeration that manning gets, had they won..u along with everyone else would of said hands down Manning is the goat...never bring up his offense, never bring up his defense that clearly is alot better, and let's not forget that the cols went out an got Vinatieri (sp) too!
 
Last edited:
ghost!;166547 said:
so....i guess the SB in 06.....manning won it all by hisself..i guess for manning's whole career his great offense that he has had aint a factor in his sucess

plz katz like u do this all the time..over exaggerate the props brady gets...and never pay attention to this same over exaggeration that manning gets, had they won..u along with everyone else would of said hands down Manning is the goat...never bring up his offense, never bring up his defense that clearly is alot better, and let's not forget that the cols went out an got Vinatieri (sp) too!

No he didnt and thats the point so lets stop comparing them based on rings when the whole team is responsible for winning games. Compare them based on individual stats and BAM youll see, theres no comparison
 
Last edited:
ghost!;166547 said:
so....i guess the SB in 06.....manning won it all by hisself..i guess for manning's whole career his great offense that he has had aint a factor in his sucess

plz katz like u do this all the time..over exaggerate the props brady gets...and never pay attention to this same over exaggeration that manning gets, had they won..u along with everyone else would of said hands down Manning is the goat...never bring up his offense, never bring up his defense that clearly is alot better, and let's not forget that the cols went out an got Vinatieri (sp) too!

Exactly people are acting like he wasn't carried to his one and only Superbowl victory by the Colts defense that one year. He had all day to throw the ball yesterday and still managed to throw a pick six one of the only times that they got to him. Basically Manning needs an array of offensive weapons, a great o-line, and a defense to play lights out in order to win a Superbowl. How does this speak to his greatness, he needs everything to align in order to win the Superbowl.
 
Last edited:
rap doctor;166599 said:
No he didnt and thats the point so lets stop comparing them based on rings when the whole team is responsible for winning games. Compare them based on individual stats and BAM youll see, theres no comparison

u do realize if u put his playoffs stats and record up against brady he loses right?? ha ha ha...
 
Last edited:
ghost!;166608 said:
u do realize if u put his playoffs stats and record up against brady he loses right?? ha ha ha...

Ill give you that but we talking bout overall
 
Last edited:
txboi_09;166606 said:
Exactly people are acting like he wasn't carried to his one and only Superbowl victory by the Colts defense that one year. He had all day to throw the ball yesterday and still managed to throw a pick six one of the only times that they got to him. Basically Manning needs an array of offensive weapons, a great o-line, and a defense to play lights out in order to win a Superbowl. How does this speak to his greatness, he needs everything to align in order to win the Superbowl.

You should no longer discuss football
 
Last edited:
People forget Elway was 0-3 in Super Bowls and played like shit in 2 of those games getting blown out and was avg in the game against the Giants. I think Manning will get another chance to win a title.
 
Last edited:
rap doctor;166690 said:
You should no longer discuss football

He wasn't carried by his defense to his lone superbowl win? These are the amazing numbers he put up during the superbowl run.

Year W | L Att Com Pct Yards Yds/Att Long Td Int QB Rating

2006 3-0 115 72 62.6 787 6.8 52 2 6 66.8

Please explain to me how this is impressive considering he always has a cold ass oline, he had clark, wayne, and harrison, and Addai and Dominic Rhodes were running well especially in the Superbowl. Not to mentioned dude beat Rex Grossman who may quiet possibly be the worst QB to ever reach a SUperbowl.
 
Last edited:
nujerz84;166710 said:
People forget Elway was 0-3 in Super Bowls and played like shit in 2 of those games getting blown out and was avg in the game against the Giants. I think Manning will get another chance to win a title.

Hell, he didnt play that well in the one against favre. Terrell davis saved his ass
 
Last edited:

Members online

Trending content

Thread statistics

Created
-,
Last reply from
-,
Replies
99
Views
202
Back
Top
Menu
Your profile
Post thread…