Classic Or Not Vol 102 REVISITED.........My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy

[IgboNegro]

Niggas must have been hibernating during Gall 2010, Ye had the game on lock.

 

[S2J]

If 100 people are polled, and its basically 50/50, that album cant possibly be classic.

 

[unspoken_respect]

https://youtu.be/Jg5wkZ-dJXA

This video was dope.. I remember when he had major music channels all premiering his short film simultaneously to coincide with the release of the album

He had White people serving Black people at a feast on a table in the vid. The symbolism of that scene was bold

Everything he was doing was dope and creative. I made sure to watch any performance or video that he made.

 

[The Recipe]

If 100 people are polled, and its basically 50/50, that album cant possibly be classic.

You gotta point but the rules are first to 25 and there were 25 yes b4 25 no's.

 

[IceBergTaylor]

If 100 people are polled, and its basically 50/50, that album cant possibly be classic.

You gotta point but the rules are first to 25 and there were 25 yes b4 25 no's.

Which is why I was confused as to how this was still open. You cant ask if something is classic than moderate how the votes go lol

 

[BDBIID]

Niggas George Bushin the votes.

Yoooooooooouuuuuuuuu noooooooooooottttttttt loooooooooooowwwwwwww.

 

[ericb4prez]

If 100 people are polled, and its basically 50/50, that album cant possibly be classic.

You gotta point but the rules are first to 25 and there were 25 yes b4 25 no's.

What if it only got to 25 yes votes because niggaz that would have voted no hadn't seen it yet

 

[CeLLaR-DooR]

Votin' is good

 

[supergangster]

 

[Preach2Teach]

Keep this shit open for a year let's see how it plays out.

 

[The Recipe]

If 100 people are polled, and its basically 50/50, that album cant possibly be classic.

You gotta point but the rules are first to 25 and there were 25 yes b4 25 no's.

What if it only got to 25 yes votes because niggaz that would have voted no hadn't seen it yet

The rules is the the rules b thats the case with all that shit in the vault including any thing them kung fu bruce leroy niggas got in the vault.

 

[Stew]

Yooooo lmao I'm dead at the voting since I checked the other day

 

[Gee_has_hot_picture]

not even close to his best two albums, but if people think its a classic thats fine.

i personally hate this album for only one reason, the critics praising it led to the wack Yeezus album, and hes fallen off ever since

This shits nothing like Yeezus and what led to yeezus was ye being frustrated he said it was him taking his figurative ball home. #Facts

what led to yeezus was kanye ego being even more over infalted by the critics sucking his dick

you are right he thought he could do anything, but he couldnt, yeezus was on that "relapse" level of bad for a huge commercial artist.

btw there is a ton of similar sound mixing between the albums(aka random loud noises of ass ruining possibly good beats)

 

[The Recipe]

not even close to his best two albums, but if people think its a classic thats fine.

i personally hate this album for only one reason, the critics praising it led to the wack Yeezus album, and hes fallen off ever since

This shits nothing like Yeezus and what led to yeezus was ye being frustrated he said it was him taking his figurative ball home. #Facts

what led to yeezus was kanye ego being even more over infalted by the critics sucking his dick

you are right he thought he could do anything, but he couldnt, yeezus was on that "relapse" level of bad for a huge commercial artist.

btw there is a ton of similar sound mixing between the albums(aka random loud noises of ass ruining possibly good beats)

He explains why he made the album in a few interviews Ill take his explanation over what you think.

 

[Stew]

Yooooo lmao I'm dead at the voting since I checked the other day

I want some level headed minds to help me figure out what I should do with this. If you're a Kanye superfan/hater don't chime in.

 

[The Recipe]

Bruh its first to 25, vault it or burn the whole classic or not thread down and re do everything over according to what you do with this album. You decided to redo it so dont use the redo as an excuse. If your going to make special rules about redos you need to do that before you start a poll you cant change the rules after the fact.

 

[The Recipe]

Dont do the classic or not threads if you cant do it unbiased you wouldnt leave an Outkast or TI claasic or not thread open for days after it met the vault requirments.

 

[Stew]

Bruh its first to 25, vault it or burn the whole classic or not thread down and re do everything over according to what you do with this album. You decided to redo it so dont use the redo as an excuse. If your going to make special rules about redos you need to do that before you start a poll you cant change the rules after the fact.

Redos never had a rule and You're a Kanye superfan so miss me wit this shit.

 

[The Recipe]

Bruh its first to 25, vault it or burn the whole classic or not thread down and re do everything over according to what you do with this album. You decided to redo it so dont use the redo as an excuse. If your going to make special rules about redos you need to do that before you start a poll you cant change the rules after the fact.

Redos never had a rule and You're a Kanye superfan so miss me wit this shit.

If they never had a special rule that means it adheres to the normal rules. Everybody on the site is a superfan of hip hop or they wouldnt spend countless hours here posting about hip hop so miss me with that shit.

 

[unspoken_respect]

To get into the Vault

1. 15-0 = IN

2. If its a blowout(example 16 YES votes to 4 NO votes) 20 YES votes= IN

2. If the votes are somewhat close....25 YES votes= IN

3. If the votes are really close and alias are involved.I will extend the voting to 30 YES votes and remove those alias votes to get IN

See, the game been over with. Ol, if we had more time we would have won posters. The vault has lost its integrity.