CoolJoe;6177991 said:
Please tell me what rapping skill Ghostface has over Jay, I'm curious.
You really wanna go there stanley??
Ok.
Delivery -
Ghostface... As many flows as Jay has come with they never packed the punch of a Ghost verse. I never seen a rapper with the same type of energy as Ghost.. sure you got your Busta Rhymes and Mystikals but it feels more like they're yelling at you while Ghost shit is smooth and controlled. Jay usually was more laid back with it, which could at times be boring.
Flow -
Jay.. This has obviously always been Jay's strongest suit when he was in his prime although recently it deteriorated. When Jay was in his prime it reminded me of a point guard dribbling the rock. He had a crafty finesse flow and he was very versatile although he usually stuck with one flow per song while Ghost would be all over the place with it.. This is Jay's specialty. Neither of their rhyme schemes are too complex on the surface but Ghost has some advanced shit if you look at it in-depth.
Lyrics -
Ghostface... This is easy. Jay repeated the same shit a lot of times. If we're putting lyrics under the content category like we should, which isn't to be confused with technical skills, Ghost is blowing Jay out the water. Lyrically, he touched on so many more topics than Jay. You could almost probably make a word pool for Jay off of 2 albums that he would use through out his catalog. And on the more technical side, Ghost used a lot more literary tools in his rhymes. I also think it's funny that Jay came out with a book called Decoded when his bars were mostly always understandable so I don't see why it was necessary, where people are still trying to decipher Ghost's shit.
Storytelling -
Ghostface... Jay is a decent storyteller but not in the same league. Ghost's shit was so vivid and told in a completely unique manner. You can see the whole story in your head. Also he had a much wider variety of stories than Jay.
Originality -
Ghostface... This is a no brainer. It's all about approach and that's something that no one could replicate Ghost in. My son will be rapping all types of onomatopoeias in his verses, basically doing anything he can to capture the listener. It can be argued that Jay was original with his verses too despite the redundant content but think of an Andre 3000. That's the type of original Ghost gives you with his verses. No way anyone else would have thought of it like that. Shit will blow you away.
Wordplay -
Ghostface... Y'all might be surprised I'm going with Ghost because I think Jay is also top 5 in this category but I think people become too focused on his double meaning bars (entendres). While no doubt Jay is extremely witty, I would have to say that half the time those entendres are kinda pointless because the second meaning will be some stupid unrelated shit if not both meanings. Not trying to take away from him because that's a skill in itself but it's a lot more to wordplay than just that. Ghostface puts words together in crazy ways and actually plays off them.
Voice -
Ghostface... Jay got that Parkinsons disease flow with the Steve Urkel voice right now that can get to be intolerable. Honestly, Jay never had a good rapping voice. Shit just sounds bland with no flavor. Ghost on the other hand, got a voice that is perfect for melodic portions of the track. It's easy on the ears.
Emotion -
Ghostface... I'm sorry but anyone who has a soul in their body isn't gon tell you they can feel Jay's shit more than Ghost. Ghost got verses that'll make you break down. I would even venture to say that any individual that can't feel a Ghost verse over a Jay verse is an untrustworthy individual who would never be welcome in my home.
Hits -
Jay... Jay makes more commercially successful music by a long shot. It isn't an easy to maintain the level of skill that Jay did while still being able to crossover. Gotta applaud him for finding that balance.
Production -
Jay... Ghost's production was always on point but Jay got the perfect ear for beats and his sounds are probably more balanced.
Songwriting Ghostface... This includes not just hook making but also the overall versatility of Ghost. Listen to his girl joints b. Like I don't even need to elaborate on this.
Catalog -
Ghostface... Being 100% truthful, Ghost's worst album is better than half of Jay's albums period. and I believe Jay has a top 15 catalog with a couple classics and some great bodies of work. Ghost shit is just too thorough. He has a top 3 catalog easily. Iron Man >>> Reasonable Doubt. Supreme Clientele > Blueprint. Fishscale >> American Gangster. This shows that Ghost was a better rapper for pretty much every phase of his career.
I'm not trying to tear down one artist to big up another but this is just a case of one GOAT being a better RAPPER than another GOAT. You can like one more than the other easily and even say one is greater legacy wise but never ever ever in your life try to dismiss Starks as a goat.