Panegyric Victory
WWE officials were confident Williams would win the tournament to set up a showdown with Austin, but had no plans for Gunn following his victory. The BFA winner appeared sporadically on WWE TV in the months that followed, feuding with his former tag team partner Holly, and the man he famously knocked out in the tournament, Williams, in poorly developed storylines with little payoff. Pro Wrestling Torch’s Wade Keller wrote numerous times in their newsletter about how WWE was wasting Gunn’s talent, and that with Austin having few top tier opponents at the time, Gunn could have made for a good challenger for “The Rattlesnake.”
Gunn Faces Enormous Odds
After months of floundering in WWE, while working tours in Japan when the office allowed him to, a BFA match wasbooked between Gunn and Butterbean. Known as the “King of the 4 Rounders,” ‘Bean was a 400 pound super heavyweight boxing champion and multi-time Tough Man contest winner; he had previously defeated Mero in a worked match for WWE in 1997, but this time the fight was going to be real.
The plus-sized puncher was a gimmick boxer, and he looked like shit, but he was still a legitimately trained pugilist with over 40 fight to his name when he squared off against Gunn, who WWE gave weeks to prepare. At the time, many within WWE believed the wrestler had a good chance of winning; after all, they thought, he had mowed through the other BFA contestants. The deck was certainly stacked against Gunn, however, with takedowns, the one skill he likely had over Butterbean being disallowed in this match, he said in an interview. (Technically BFA matches allowed takedowns, and Michael Cole made reference to them being legal before the match, but neither fighter attempted one, and this may have been part of an undisclosed agreement with Butterbean.)
Butterbean
Butterbean
There’s been plenty of speculation that WWE set Gunn up to fail as punishment for ruining their planned Austin vs. Williams match, and anyone who understands the company’s culture knows that’s possible. Regardless of whether or not the bout was intended to humiliate him, it was certainly bad business to put the guy who was seen as the toughest in WWE against a boxer fans didn’t know or care much about, that also happened to fight much better than his appearance would suggest. The best case scenario was Gunn beats up someone who aesthetically looked half as good as anyone in the BFA, and the small percentage of fans who knew who Butterbean was were impressed by that. (It’s also likely WWE officials were ignorant to the talent necessary to box, and really didn’t care if Gunn lost, so they put together the match as a special attraction ignoring what defeat meant for Gunn’s career.)
Bradshaw said in a blog he wrote on the tournament that Butterbean was willing to lose a worked match, according to what the wrestlers had been told, and Meltzer clarified the boxer had originally signed with WWE to do pro wrestling matches, not shoot fights. WWE, however, wanted to make it a shoot. The company seemed insistent on putting together real fights, even though their fans didn’t want to see them, and they threw a monkey wrench in building up storylines, the lifeblood of pro wrestling. The BFA gave the fans real fights, but failed to deliver the same drama and showmanship as the predetermined ones had.
Bart Gunn biting off more than he can chew
Bart Gunn biting off more than he can chew
The wrestler versus boxer showdown took place at WWE’s biggest annual event of the year, WrestleMania, on Mar. 28, 1999. A well put together promotional package aired before the fight, and polled Gunn’s trainers and others on who they thought would win. The consensus was a victory for the wrestler, who came out in a traditional boxing robe looking like a star. The judges for the bout were former boxer and real life inspiration for Rocky, Chuck Wepner, Mike Tyson’s old trainer, Kevin Rooney, and WWE Hall of Famer, Gorilla Monsoon. Reffing the bout was active boxer at the time, Vinny Pazienza.
The doughy ‘Bean looked like the antithesis of a wrestling star coming to the squared-circle, but performed like the trained boxer he was in it. The enormous striker immediately tee’d off on the overmatched Gunn, knocking him down in the first 30 seconds. The stunned wrestler told the ref he was ready to continue after wobbling to his feet, and was then hit with a devastating combo before being felled for good. It was a fitting end to one of the most ill-conceived ideas in the history of pro wrestling, a business that had spent decades presenting simulated fights as real.