Why did McNabb fall off so fast?

  • Thread starter Thread starter New Editor
  • Start date Start date
So fast.. ??

He just doest have the will anymore..

He was an elite qb for years. i thought he would show out here.. i mean it still early he can put up some numbers but ithought the team would have more sucess and he would have something to prove to the naysayers.. but....
 
Last edited:
Andy Reid.......That dude just make QB's look good remember a few years back when Mcnabb got hurt he revived Jeff Garcias career,Vicks resurgence,Kolb was worth a probowl corner and a 1st round pick,shit even Mike Kafka looked good when he had his chance against the Falcons.
 
Last edited:
lamontbdc;3489944 said:
old age and learning a new system.

i think they still run the same system he been in since coming into the league

playmaker88;3489953 said:
So fast.. ??

He just doest have the will anymore..

He was an elite qb for years. i thought he would show out here.. i mean it still early he can put up some numbers but ithought the team would have more sucess and he would have something to prove to the naysayers.. but....

i think in philly they did him what they doin cutler in chi-town....refuse to go get elite receivers...and when they did....made it to the superbowl.....and his problem now is what happened to farve in 2009...except farve started the season feedin the rock to AP and managing the game...and as the season went on started throwin more and we kno how that ended

motrilla;3489966 said:
Andy Reid.......That dude just make QB's look good remember a few years back when Mcnabb got hurt he revived Jeff Garcias career,Vicks resurgence,Kolb was worth a probowl corner and a 1st round pick,shit even Mike Kafka looked good when he had his chance against the Falcons.

u do kno jeff garcia has shined whereever he has played.....niners,eagles,and bucs......but u may have a point on andy reid
 
Last edited:
GetMoneyInDaN.O.;3490267 said:
u do kno jeff garcia has shined whereever he has played.....niners,eagles,and bucs......but u may have a point on andy reid

That's true but when he went to Philly as a backup it was because not one team in the league would give him a starting job everybody thought he was done.
 
Last edited:
McNabb has never had mechanics...he was getting by off his athletic ability and strong arm...now his athleticism is almost gone he has to rely on his mechanics like Peyton and Brady...
 
Last edited:
Meagan___Goodz;3490332 said:
McNabb has never had mechanics...he was getting by off his athletic ability and strong arm...now his athleticism is almost gone he has to rely on his mechanics like Peyton and Brady...

I 'd have to agree with that. Since he left the Eagles he's just looked so withdrawn. I think his best years were when he was a scrambling threat. Also the Eagles had the best defense in the NFL for like 3 years straight at one point. When the defense started to dissolve McNabb caught Lebron Syndrome.
 
Last edited:
Internet Thug;3490424 said:
mcnabb has never been a good QB

if he didn't play for andy he'd of been a bust

andy creates QBs

cs, he was never the engine of the eagles offense.. that was WESTBROOK

he was a product of the GREAT defense he had every year much like big ben
 
Last edited:
GetMoneyInDaN.O.;3490267 said:
i think they still run the same system he been in since coming into the league

i think in philly they did him what they doin cutler in chi-town....refuse to go get elite receivers...and when they did....made it to the superbowl.....and his problem now is what happened to farve in 2009...except farve started the season feedin the rock to AP and managing the game...and as the season went on started throwin more and we kno how that ended



u do kno jeff garcia has shined whereever he has played.....niners,eagles,and bucs......but u may have a point on andy reid

Garcia sucked ass in DEtriot and Cleveland he is a str8 up west coast qb
 
Last edited:
traestar;3491777 said:
Dude is just lazy IMO!!

I agree also he is a system QB . Andy Reid made him the QB he was . Thats why he knew that he was done . Much love for Mac 5 , sad to see his career ending like this .
 
Last edited:
Mcnabb was never a good qb.. lol.. ok

Tom brady is a system qb if i ever seen one but that doesnt take away the accolades that are heaped on him.
 
Last edited:
playmaker88;3491879 said:
Mcnabb was never a good qb.. lol.. ok

Tom brady is a system qb if i ever seen one but that doesnt take away the accolades that are heaped on him.

T/s won't like this post
 
Last edited:
Meagan___Goodz;3490332 said:
McNabb has never had mechanics...he was getting by off his athletic ability and strong arm...now his athleticism is almost gone he has to rely on his mechanics like Peyton and Brady...

Yea because mcnabb was running around every play when he led us to the super bowl............... Dudes time is up. Reid didn't make anyone, was the system better for him yes but mcnabb's weakness has always been accuracy on plays of 15 yds and less so how a west coast system "made" him is beyond me. His combination of laziness, old age, and a new system has fucked him. Is he done, yes. Did reid help him, yes. But he didn't "MAKE" anyone.....
 
Last edited:
playmaker88;3491879 said:
Mcnabb was never a good qb.. lol.. ok

Tom brady is a system qb if i ever seen one but that doesnt take away the accolades that are heaped on him.

You definitely right, if somthing happens and he ever leaves the Patriots this dude would be gahbage.

And how can you deny how dope Mcnabb was, dude was cosistent as any qb in the league and a great leader. Now it just seems like he dont have any desire to play the game, like he's already checked out mentally and he's just stacking his money right now honestly.
 
Last edited:
I wouldnt say garbage thats reaching i never really like Tom brady but he benefited greatly from being their with a great organization coach.. offensive line and offensive system..

Mcnabb in his hey day was the best qb with Manning to me.. and the most dangerous for a while because.. you didnt have to have shit at room temp for him.. when it came down to it and you needed to pull a rabbit out of a hat.. he pulled 2 out.. there is underrated value in being able to make shit happen when the conditions are not in your favor
 
Last edited:

Members online

Trending content

Thread statistics

Created
-,
Last reply from
-,
Replies
19
Views
0
Back
Top
Menu
Your profile
Post thread…