x the unknown
New member
fuckin tim all the way
#1hiphopjunki3
New member
TheGOAT;9240562 said:
When John Lucas was the coach of the Spurs, David put up some monster numbers because he ran damn near all the offense through him in all facets. High, Mid and Low post action. David was a monster but just couldn't get over the hump in the playoffs.
#1hiphopjunki3
New member
TheGOAT;9262399 said:
David is my favorite player of all time and even I said Tim is the greatest Spurs player. Shit, David even said Tim is the greatest and if it wasn't for Tim he might have never got rings
#1hiphopjunki3;9262542 said:
And i bet tim would say David is the greatest
2 of the nicest stars ever with no egos.
My point is rings dont matter as much as yall say when comparing individual greatness. Its a team sport and 2 different eras of ball.
David is arguably the greater individual player which is what the thread is asking
PanchoYoSancho
New member
TheGOAT;9240562 said:
GOAT shit. Duncan was 2 blocks away from doing this...in the championship clinching Game 6 of the 2003 Finals.
TheGOAT;9262399 said:
So we're comparing Robert Horry to Tim Duncan now?? Stop it.
Last edited:
#1hiphopjunki3
New member
TheGOAT;9262771 said:
They do come off as being some of the nicer guys to lace them up and I'm sure Tim would say the same about David as far as being the greatest Spurs player ever but winning matters and Tim won more than David.
There definitely could be an argument that Tim had better talent to help win championships as opposed to David in his prime but Tim (even his rookie season) was still the center piece of it all, even when David was there.
David amassed crazy numbers and should be looked at as one of the all time greats like he is but Tim also amassed crazy numbers and he won championships to boot. Either way both were great players and I'm sure any Spurs fan is proud to say they got the pleasure to watch them both play the entirety of their careers in San Antonio.
TrapperOfTheYear
New member
Come on man this thread is disrespectful
dalyricalbandit
Moderator
Imo If the played each other in their prime DRob might've got the W
KneeGro_DuperMan
New member
D.Rob was a beast fam
x the unknown
New member
TheGOAT;9262399 said:
hell nah
x the unknown
New member
TheGOAT;9310746 said:
i respect that there
its....JOHN B
New member
No its not close between DRob and Duncan I cant even believe this thread is still going, intangibles set them apart Timmy is the biggest reason of the Spurs success of the past 18 years, 2 time mvp 3 time finals mvp 5 time champion the greatest player at his position where DRob was probably the 4th best center of his generation, also the stats are way too close over the course of their careers but Timmy's playoff stats are killing DRob's so in reality DRob doesn't have the upperhand in any aspect outside of athleticism
its....JOHN B
New member
dalyricalbandit;9286495 said:
And Scottie Pippen might have beat Larry Bird one on one...who cares?
its....JOHN B;9314446 said:
Tim had better teams than Robinson
Career stats are very close which is why this is a good comparison.
Yea Tim has better playoff track. He was on a better team. David played in a generation when big men were still big men. Tim was a big man during the era the center position basically disappeared.
Similar threads
