Which one of these guys is the biggest star? Vol. 3

[jono]

Somehow CM Punk was cut off as an option but he is in the race officially. I guess you'd just have to write him in.

 

[Peezy_Jenkins]

Gotta go with Jeff, edge was the main guy on smack down but prolly no higher third or fourth in line overall punk was a distant second to cena, I think hardy and rey mysterio were closer to being "the guy" than those two, they even would sometimes get faint boos in the background like cena(obviously his are louder but yeah)

 

[jono]

Jeff's pops were immense. If he had stayed he would have rivaled Cena in reactions.

I guess it's a little unfair considering we basically watched Jeff grow up on WWF TV. Dude was like 17 when he started.

 

[SuperSoaker]

Cm punk longest reigning champ of our era. better matches and promos.

Plus the feud with jeff puts him over hardy.

But out of the two options jeff edge is so damn overrated.

 

[Already Home_17]

edge was the triple h of the ruthless aggression era. he wasn't the guy, but the guy who faced the guy. he was the main heel the top babyface needed to square off against. from his tag team days to his main event days that was his role and he was great at it

cm punk was never as popular as Jeff Hardy. go back and look at the wwe in 08-09. if the crowd wasn't wearing cena shirts and headbands they were wearing hardy face paint and arm sleeves. his pops were the loudest of the night

and it seemed like he never got a legit shot to prove himself as world champion. 3 reigns that lasted a total of 2 months

 

[DOPEdweebz]

Jeff was on his way to being Cenas equivalent or as close as you could b4 he left. Even if CM Punk was in this poll, even as a hardcore smark, Id still vote Jeff Hardy.

 

[Peezy_Jenkins]

I agree with hardy not being given the best chance, I'm sure he was great for business back then

 

[playboy buddy rose]

if c.m. punk didn't leave the way he did (even though he had a valid point) i would have voted for him..but give hardy credit he had a drive that can't be matched by very few.the powers to be held back hardy for as long as they could but he overcame the odds (much like c.m. punk)

 

[lookdude]

Where is Matt hardy

 

[Copper]

nigga got 3 pictures and 2 options

 

[Copper]

alot of revisionist thinking in here though

 

[eternal soldier]

From a business standpoint, I'd say CM Punk because of his sales being the only close to Cena's

From a fans point of view, Jeff was always more popular because of his style (pause lol)

Edge was definitely good. Not fresh into retirement hall of fame entry good, but he has a lot of classic moments that can be considered as well as Jeff and Punk.

 

[Peezy_Jenkins]

Hardys sales were definitely up there too, and as I mentioned rey mysterio had to be up there as well

 

[DOPEdweebz]

alot of revisionist thinking in here though

So you're saying CM Punk was a bigger star in 2012 than Jeff Hardy in 2009?

 

[dalyricalbandit]

World Heavyweight Championship (2 times)[141][302]

WWE Championship (1 time)[12][13]

WWF/E Intercontinental Championship (4 times)[43]

WWF Hardcore Championship (3 times)[45]

WWF Light Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[44]

WWE European Championship (1 time)[12][57]

World Tag Team Championship (6 times) – with Matt Hardy[12][303]

WCW Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Matt Hardy[7]

Terri Invitational Tournament[37] – with Matt Hardy

Eleventh Grand Slam Champion

Eighteenth Triple Crown Champion

Slammy Award for Extreme Moment of the Year (2008) Swanton Bomb to Randy Orton from the top of the Raw set (Raw, January 14) [304]

Slammy Award for Extreme Moment of the Year (2009) Jumping from ladder onto CM Punk at SummerSlam

looking back son did him

crazy how Edge has the most title wins in history tho