What division has the best QB's?

[coop9889]

Im basing this as of right now going on Week 4 this year the best performing QB's are in the AFC East. Brady is doing numbers. Fitzpatrick is definetly doing numbers. Sanchez is doing well. Not great but not bad either. Henne is the weak link but the performance of the other 3 make up for his lack.

So by going off that logic, you probably think the Bills, Lions, and Packers are the best 3 teams in the league huh.

You prolly think Cam Newton is the 3rd best QB in the league huh

 

[R.D.]

How is the NFC south better than the North

 

[coop9889]

How is the NFC south better than the North

1st best: Brees = Rodgers

2nd: Ryan >= Stafford

3rd: Freeman > Cutler

4th: Cam > Mcnabb

 

[Stew]

So yall just gonna let all these Falcon groupies take over the poll?

 

[Darius]

its the NFC south. and its not even close. It was the NFC South last year, despite having jimmy clausen...and now with Newton, the NFC South is yet again the best qb division in football

 

[GettinLo]

That's a reasonable opinion. I don't agree with it but it's reasonable.

Cam does have talent but like someone said earlier, give him some more time. You can't compare someone's entire career to sum1 w/ just 3 games. There is a very strong possibility that he has the potential to be better than Matt Ryan but not right now.

Through the 1st 3 games of the season Cam has as many wins as Matt with a worse team... and a higher QB rating (ranked 17th, Ryan 24th) and has led his team to a comeback victory... To me that screams that right now, emphasizing right now... he's playing better that Ryan. I think Ryan is at or near his peak while Cam is still learning on the job and performing better than half of the starting QB's in the league, right now.... Can/will he come back to earth and play like a rookie this year, I believe he will, but forthe time being, today, I think that Cam's the better QB. If he's on the Falcons right now, I think they'd be a more dynamic team than they currently are with Ryan.

 

[5th Letter]

Right now it's looking like the NFC south has the best qbs

 

[R.D.]

1st best: Brees = Rodgers

2nd: Ryan >= Stafford

3rd: Freeman > Cutler

4th: Cam > Mcnabb

Jay Cutler is better than Josh Freeman and Matt Ryan

 

[GettinLo]

Jay Cutler is better than Josh Freeman and Matt Ryan

What u smoking?

 

[kAjUn]

NFC EAST

Eli Manning

Mike Vick

Tony Homo

Rex Grossman

NFC SOUTH

Drew Brees

Matt Ryan

Josh Freeman

Cam Newton

NFC NORTH

Aaron Rodgers

Jay Cutler

Matt Stafford

Donovan Mcnabb

AFC EAST

Tom Brady

Mark Sanchez

Chad Henne

Ryan Fitzpatrick

AFC NORTH

Ben Rothlisberger

Joe Flacco

Colt Mccoy

Andy Dalton

AFC SOUTH

Matt Schaub

Matt Hasselbeck

Blaine Gabbert

Kerry Collins

damn good question but i'm going to have to roll with nfc east

 

[R.D.]

What u smoking?

that shit that make you spit facts. Jay Cutler with no receivers took his team to the conference game. Where was Matt Ryan ? Josh Freeman been getting extremely overrated lately. He had a good year last year. Now let him prove that the cupcake schedule had nothing to do with it.

 

[BlackxChild]

I wanna say the nfc south, but I gotta go with the nfc east. I feel like Romo is better than Freeman, and I would take Mike Vick on my squad before I would Matt Ryan, even with all that bitchassness that Vick showed after the game, and Brees and Manning both led their teams to superbowl so they almost cancel each other out, but Brees is the overall better qb. Cam hasn't done enough for me to say that he's better than Grossman at this point, so I gotta give the edge to Grossman. That's my assesment of that there topic.

Tony romo is better than matt ryan and josh freeman. You can argue that brees never wouldve made it to a sb without his D leading the league in turnovers bc Brees turns the ball over more than Cutler (look it up)

 

[BlackxChild]

that shit that make you spit facts. Jay Cutler with no receivers took his team to the conference game. Where was Matt Ryan ? Josh Freeman been getting extremely overrated lately. He had a good year last year. Now let him prove that the cupcake schedule had nothing to do with it.

Rex Grossman went to a superbowl I guess that makes him better than Cutler..... Only an idiot thinks playoff wins = a QB being better.

 

[BlackxChild]

Matt Ryan was over-hyped from the door IMO... Freeman is better than him RIGHT NOW... Cam in 3 games on a horrible team is proving that he's got talent right now to compete at the highest levels and that his upside is that of an elite QB... I see Matt Ryan as a Joe Flacco... just manage the game and don't lose it QB whereas Cam and Josh are the types where you tell em "Go win the game for us"

Matt Ryan goes through his progressions and knows how to read a defense hes better than Flacco.

 

[R.D.]

Rex Grossman went to a superbowl I guess that makes him better than Cutler..... Only an idiot thinks playoff wins = a QB being better.

Naww im just making a point about what the so called bum Jay Cutler was able to accomplish behind a horrible o line and no receiving threats. What makes Matt Ryan better than Cutler ?

 

[BlackxChild]

I know right? people already trying to name him one of the top QB's. He has 1 win so far. Give him time to do something noteworthy. If he takes Carolina to the playoffs this year then i'll give him his props but he ahs to show and prove first.

The funny thing is have you guys seen how many int where dropped that cam threw? Atleast Cam is developing faster than Flacco.

 

[BlackxChild]

Naww im just making a point about what the so called bum Jay Cutler was able to accomplish behind a horrible o line and no receiving threats. What makes Matt Ryan better than Cutler ?

Funny thing is I actually think Cutler is better and I think the bears made Rex look worse than he really was and Ive always thought Rex was better than Mcnabb.

 

[coop9889]

Naww im just making a point about what the so called bum Jay Cutler was able to accomplish behind a horrible o line and no receiving threats. What makes Matt Ryan better than Cutler ?

Cutler is more turnover prone, makes worse decisions. Slightly less accurate.

Not as much of a leader, less likable. Less potential.

 

[R.D.]

Cutler is more turnover prone, makes worse decisions. Slightly less accurate.

Not as much of a leader, less likable. Less potential.

being likable makes you a better player ?

@ underlined based on what ? Ryan's surrounded by weapons and a great running games

 

[coop9889]

Yes, being likable has an effect, especially in the locker room. It affects your leadership skills.

And potential based on how cutler's production has declined since 2008 whereas ryan had his best season last season. And he's younger.