The Carter 2 vs Reasonable Doubt

[mryounggun]

Is this a trick question? RD - hands down. (Although I DO think C2 is a near classic album).

 

[JayToTheZ]

Why would you compare these 2 albums?
Why not compare RD and 500 Degrez?

 

[Bigavelli]

The Carter 2 is by far Lil Waynes best Album

Reasonable Doubt is by far Jay Z's best Album

 

[YamoleySensei]

Reasonable Doubt, you dot-head Pakistani whore....

 

[dalyricalbandit]

No contest rd wins

 

[Bigavelli]

Is this a trick question? RD - hands down. (Although I DO think C2 is a near classic album).

Neither are classic IMO both are just good Album's

Carter 2>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Reasonable Doubt IMO

 

[thesynthesis]

carter 2

u shud have done bp vs carter 2

 

[mryounggun]

Neither are classic IMO both are just good Album's

Carter 2>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Reasonable Doubt IMO

How old are you...where are you from...and who is your favorite artist?

 

[dalyricalbandit]

How old are you...where are you from...and who is your favorite artist?

come on everyone know this its Marshall

 

[Bigavelli]

carter 2

u shud have done bp vs carter 2

Carter 2 is superior to Blueprint

Reasonable Doubt is the closest but overall Carter 2 is the better Album from Production to Song's to replay value to Lyrics

 

[runningwolf1980]

broham...............

 

[thesynthesis]

Carter 2 is superior to Blueprint

Reasonable Doubt is the closest but overall Carter 2 is the better Album from Production to Song's to replay value to Lyrics

naw i feel bp > carter 2

bp is a fire album, the production does carry it somewhat, but it's still jay probably at his best

never got the backwards hype about RD, minus a few cuts, overall sounds average and incomplete

 

[dalyricalbandit]

some one ban this red dot

 

[Bigavelli]

naw i feel bp > carter 2

bp is a fire album, the production does carry it somewhat, but it's still jay probably at his best

never got the backwards hype about RD, minus a few cuts, overall sounds average and incomplete

Reasonable Doubt is by far Jay Z's best Album but yeah you right about the Album bit does have some good Song's but some average too but overall Jay Z's best Album by a long distance

The Blueprint is decent nothing more nothing less best thing about it like you said is the Production by Just Blaze & Kanye West on the Album

 

[mryounggun]

RD is Jay's best work...not by much though. The Black Album is pretty close. Same with Wayne C2 is his best, but C1 is pretty close. Just my 2 cents.

 

[CJ]

Why is this thread still open

 

[booty-gif-dot-com]

This one will be a generational vote..

If you over 25 its going to be RD

if you under 25 its going to be CARTER!

I vote for Jigga on this one! RD came out 15 years ago and we still talking about it.. Time will tell if Weezys best work will hold up that long or will his stuff just be music that sounded good for its era but didnt hold up.. well see!

 

[Bigavelli]

RD is Jay's best work...not by much though. The Black Album is pretty close. Same with Wayne C2 is his best, but C1 is pretty close. Just my 2 cents.

The Black Album is above average carried by Production

Reasonable Doubt has a some average and a few weak tracks and a few good tracks and is by far Jay Z's best Album

 

[mryounggun]

The Black Album is above average carried by Production

Reasonable Doubt has a some average and a few weak tracks and a few good tracks and is by far Jay Z's best Album

Name one weak track off of RD? Your answer will be VERY telling.

 

[stealthbomber]

reasonable doubt for sure, carter 2 was good but niggas act like its a classic album, da drought 3 was better.