Should Michael Vick Start Next Game?

[shootemwon]

Problem with Vick is he's ranked too high by people IMO. People who think Vick should start, where do you rank him amongst current QB's?

When all the current QB's in the league come hanging around the Linc asking for a job, I'll consider where Vick ranks.

Til that happens, there's only one guy who Vick needs to be ranked against: Kolb. I think he's better than Kolb.

That other teams have QB's who are better than Vick has nothing to do with the decision at hand. You can only start your own team's players.

 

[cobbland]

Problem with Vick is he's ranked too high by people IMO. People who think Vick should start, where do you rank him amongst current QB's?

He had a very high winning percentage as a starter in Atlanta, and he didn't have much talent around him.

 

[R.D.]

When all the current QB's in the league come hanging around the Linc asking for a job, I'll consider where Vick ranks.

Til that happens, there's only one guy who Vick needs to be ranked against: Kolb. I think he's better than Kolb.

That other teams have QB's who are better than Vick has nothing to do with the decision at hand. You can only start your own team's players.

well said, good sir

 

[bow to royalty]

When all the current QB's in the league come hanging around the Linc asking for a job, I'll consider where Vick ranks.

Til that happens, there's only one guy who Vick needs to be ranked against: Kolb. I think he's better than Kolb.

That other teams have QB's who are better than Vick has nothing to do with the decision at hand. You can only start your own team's players.

I didn't ask who should the Eagles trade for to start over Vick. I'm just trying to understand where people guage his talent. People have named his pros, cons, accomplishments, etc. So I'm just wondering who else you would say has a talent level similar to his.

 

[Swiffness!]

vick is top 5 all time

 

[playmaker88]

vick is top 5 all time

Agreed top 5 athletes in the NFL of all time.

 

[SouthEastBeast]

Agreed top 5 athletes in the NFL of all time.

Should Vic start? Yes he should. He is the best the Eagles have at that position. Every black athlete goes through a event where they fuck up and must win the public back. Vic has his chance now.

 

[playmaker88]

Should Vic start? Yes he should. He is the best the Eagles have at that position. Every black athlete goes through a event where they fuck up and must win the public back. Vic has his chance now.

Yea i been said he should start.

 

[hood president]

Problem with Vick is he's ranked too high by people IMO. People who think Vick should start, where do you rank him amongst current QB's?

QBs better than Vick right now

P.Manning
D.Brees
T.Brady
P.Rivers
T. Romo
D.Mcnabb
B. Favre
A. Rogers
B. Rothlesberger
M Schaub
There ya go. Those guys are better than him from what ive seen I think he better than Ryan and Palmer. I think vick under Andy Reid(or any good, solid coach) is as good as Flacco was last year except with a running ability. I think thats fair.

I want him to start against Detroit so he can show teams he can play QB effectively and start for another franchise.

 

[#1 pick]

QBs better than Vick right now

P.Manning
D.Brees
T.Brady
P.Rivers
T. Romo
D.Mcnabb
B. Favre
A. Rogers
B. Rothlesberger
E. Manning

There ya go. Those guys are better than him from what ive seen. I think vick under Andy Reid is as good as Flacco was last year except with a running ability. I think thats fair.

I want him to start against Detroit so he can show teams he can play QB effectively and start for another franchise.

V. Young
J. Flacco
M. S... Texans
M. Hasselbeck
as well. Don't get me wrong, Vick is more talented than a lot of guys in the top 10 much less the top 5. But for right now, this is where I rank him.

 

[R.D.]

V. Young
J. Flacco
M. S... Texans
M. Hasselbeck
as well. Don't get me wrong, Vick is more talented than a lot of guys in the top 10 much less the top 5. But for right now, this is where I rank him.

STFU....you listed VY and instantly lost credibility. I would also consider taking Romo and Eli(i think he's over rated) off original list

 

[hood president]

V. Young
J. Flacco
M. S... Texans
M. Hasselbeck
as well. Don't get me wrong, Vick is more talented than a lot of guys in the top 10 much less the top 5. But for right now, this is where I rank him.

Well i forgot about schaub so ill add him and ill take Eli off .

He even with Flacco, Romo and a Healthy Hasselback imo

 

[bow to royalty]

K, so with these lists, we can eliminate any "he's elite" talk?

 

[hood president]

K, so with these lists, we can eliminate any "he's elite" talk?

Ehh...Guess not but he is a good QB and better than what the media gives him credit for. But hey if he is probably #11 out of 32 teams which is good

 

[ninefiveninesix]

Vick should start at least the next few games until Kolb is ready.....but understand all Mike has to do is play his position and he will be the starting quarterback of the Philadelphia Eagles by Week 8....Kolb is soft as hell....dude don't have it.....

 

[shootemwon]

I didn't ask who should the Eagles trade for to start over Vick. I'm just trying to understand where people guage his talent. People have named his pros, cons, accomplishments, etc. So I'm just wondering who else you would say has a talent level similar to his.

We can have a big open-ended debate about where Vick stands among other QB's in the league, but let's save it for another thread. This one is about whether Vick or Kolb should be the starting QB.

Even if Vick was wacker than every other team's starting QB, if he's better than Kolb, he should be the Eagles starter.

He is better than Kolb. He should be the starter. How Vick compares to McNabb, Romo, Manning, Roethlisberger, or others is not relevant in making this decision.

 

[playmaker88]

We can have a big open-ended debate about where Vick stands among other QB's in the league, but let's save it for another thread. This one is about whether Vick or Kolb should be the starting QB.

Even if Vick was wacker than every other team's starting QB, if he's better than Kolb, he should be the Eagles starter.

He is better than Kolb. He should be the starter. How Vick compares to McNabb, Romo, Manning, Roethlisberger, or others is not relevant in making this decision.

Basically .. and to answer bows question.. no one..

Vince has similarities but they are different.. Vick posseses a different type of electricity

 

[bow to royalty]

Basically .. and to answer bows question.. no one..

Vince has similarities but they are different.. Vick posseses a different type of electricity

Wow...Vick as best QB in the league...

electricity is excitement...i'm talking best QB

 

[shootemwon]

Wow...Vick as best QB in the league...

electricity is excitement...i'm talking best QB

What does any of this matter when Vick is riding the bench, watching Kolb throw the Eagles season away. What's important now is Reid and the Eagles listening to reason and putting the right man in the starter position.

Then I'll go ahead and talk with you about what makes Vick a serious QB. But if Vick rides the bench most of this season, it's gonna pointless measuring him up against the great starters.

 

[bow to royalty]

What does any of this matter when Vick is riding the bench, watching Kolb throw the Eagles season away. What's important now is Reid and the Eagles listening to reason and putting the right man in the starter position.

Then I'll go ahead and talk with you about what makes Vick a serious QB. But if Vick rides the bench most of this season, it's gonna pointless measuring him up against the great starters.

What does anything said in this entire thread matter? This shit's not a poll put up by Andy Reid as to whether he should start or not, and he's not reading anyone's opinion on here