Rate This...

[5th Letter]

You made this thread already.

http://community.allhiphop.com/show...m-s-catalouge&highlight=Rate+Eminem+catalouge

 

[gee757]

Thread back fire

jamacia this is about that other thread dont b callin me slow when ya dumb azz aint doin ya job cuz ya so quick 2 lock a dretox thread but u will let a gaylias thread live dont play dumb wit me.,,,,

 

[8 Mile]

Eminem did not produce anything on the slim shady lp....and produced very little on the mmlp.

Every Song apart from My Name Is, Role Model & Rock Bottom were Co Produced by Eminem on The Slim Shady LP, go check the Album credits if you own the Album

The Way I Am, Stan, Marshall Mathers, Drug Ballad, Under The Influence & Criminal were all Produced by Eminem which is 6 Song's outta 14 on the Album so that is about half the Album he Produced

 

[5th Letter]

jamacia dont b callin me slow when ya dumb azz aint doin ya job cuz ya so quick 2 lock a dretox thread but u r let a gaylias thread live dont play dumb wit me.,,,,

Dude I am not on here 24/7 I dont see everything so if you have an issue with a thread PM me or report it. You're probably older than me yet you act retarded.

 

[bankrupt baller]

The Marshall Mathers LP = top 5 greatest Album's of all time in history regardless of genre

The Slim Shady LP = greatest Hip-Hop Album ever in history

The Eminem Show = in the top 5 greatest Hip-Hop Album's ever

Lose Yourself = greatest Song ever in history regardless of genre

Stan = in the top 5 greatest ever Song's in history regardless of genre

em is one of my favorite rappers but STFU!

 

[bankrupt baller]

infinite= 0/10

sslp = 8/10

mmlp = 8/10

tes = 9/10

encore 4/10

re-up = 4/10

relapse = 5/10

encore gets a 4 but infinit gets 0.......explain

 

[biggar]

Dretox won't breathe until she converts all Nas and Jay fans to Em fans.

 

[gee757]

Dude I am not on here 24/7 I dont see everything so if you have an issue with a thread PM me or report it. You're probably older than me yet you act retarded.

jamacia again dont play stupid wit me u b lettin clownz like AJax or wat eva threadz live thatz y i said u was a bitch cuz u wouldnt close da shit & u seen that dumb shit but wat eva i just want'd 2 say that....

 

[5th Letter]

jamacia again dont play stupid wit me u b lettin clownz like AJax or wat eva threadz live thatz y i said u was a bitch cuz u wouldnt close da shit & u seen that dumb shit but wat eva i just want'd 2 say that....

*sigh *

 

[isayas]

There is no Nas album that's less than an 7.5, and that goes to Street's Disciple.

 

[BaaLooN]

DAM... YALL HATED ENCORE, I THINK ITS WAYYYYYYYYYYY BETTER THEN RELAPSE...

The Slim Shady LP = 10/10

The Marshall Mathers LP = 10/10

The Eminem Show = 10/10

Encore = 8.9/10

Relapse Refill = 4/10

 

[hnic1978]

Even with Street's Disciple and Nastradamus they BOTH have 3 or more classic songs on each one!!!

 

[Stew]

SSLP- 8/10
MMLP- 9/10
Em Show- 10/10
Encore- 6/10
Relapse- 8/10

 

[down2earth]

There is no Nas album that's less than an 7.5, and that goes to Street's Disciple.

This right here......you guys have to be really sick in the head to rate a Nas album anything less than a 7/7.5. Nastradamus/STree's Discple are his two supbar albums ( i can't really choose between one or the other). That being said, they are still decent albums and the rest of his albums are fire as hell. His catalogue is solid, arguably the best in hip-hop period.

 

[therealist_]

Illmatic - 10/10
IWW - 10/10
I Am - 8.5/10 ... (One of my personal favorites)
Nastradamus - 6/10
Stillmatic - 10/10 (i cant stand "My Country" though)
Gods Son - 7.5/10
Streets Disciple - 7/10
HHID - 7/10
Untitled - 8.5/10
Distant Relatives - 9.5/10
The Lost Tapes - 9/10

My top 5 out his catalog -

1.) Stillmatic
2.) IWW
3.) ILLmatic
4.) I Am.
5.) Distant Relatives

 

[Stew]

Illmatic = 10/10
It Was Written = 9/10
I Am = 7/10
Nastradamus = 6/10
Stillmatic = 9.5/10
God's Son = 8/10
Street's Disciple = 7/10
Hip-Hop Is Dead = 7/10
Untitled = 9/10
Distant Relatives- 10/10

 

[the_omniscient]

Illmatic-8.5/10

It Was Written-8/10

I Am-8/10

Nastradamus-7/10

Stillmatic-9.5/10

God's Son-8.5/10

Street's Disciple-7.5/10

Hip Hop is Dead-8/10

Self-titled-8/10

Lost Tapes really shouln't count because that was just a compliation of the tracks that leaked. How Nas would have ordered those tracks or whether some/all of those songs would have made the final cut of "I Am" is up for debate.

 

[hrap-120]

Illmatic = 10/10
It Was Written = 9.5/10
I Am-Nastradamus = 7/10
Stillmatic = 9/10
God's Son = 8/10
Street's Disciple = -7.5/10
Hip-Hop Is Dead = 8/10
Untitled = 9/10
Lost Tapes in there = 9.5/10

 

[aquizzle]

There is no Nas album that's less than an 7.5, and that goes to Street's Disciple.

Nah Nastradamus is a solid 3-4

 

[the_omniscient]

Just to let you know, this thread has been done before. It's good discussion though. I liked Eminem Show more than most people and like Relapse less than most people. Some of you ought to be careful about how you rate Encore; do you really rate that album down there with a Crunchy Black or Soulja Boy album?

Anyway, the ratings:

Infinite-8/10

SSLP-8.5/10

MMLP-8/10

Eminem Show-9//10

Encore-7/10

Relapse-7.5/10