Peyton Manning or Tom Brady ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter New Editor
  • Start date Start date
JUXcaptainHOOK;3111479 said:
How? Peytons 44 comebacks in the 4th to Bradys 28 proves he's more clutch b ....just cuz Peyton threw a pick 6 in the super bowl cuz a messed up route ran by R. Wayne mean he's not clutch... Peyton is known for being so great BECAUSE of his clutchness

postseason record

Manning
Really? 9 wins 10 loses wow he clutch

Brady
14 wins - 5 loses

end thread
 
Last edited:
I know it was just pre season... but homie from the Patriots put up 45 points last night light... lemme guess... he's the next great QB too right? Fuck outta here... Face the facts, its the system they have which played more of a role in Brady's rings as to Peyton Manning doing it basically individually and working harder for it
 
Last edited:
ghost!;3112951 said:
your right but that's not what i'm getting at..

Peyton has run the same offensive scheme since he was a rookie in indy

are the pats and brady running the same offensive scheme since 2000? .. No....07-09 they went away from their orig offensive to cater towards what they had with brady and moss, hence why they got rid of moss and brought back branch



so going back to what the orig. poster said..how switching peyton to the pats offense would make him a wizard..he has to read and react the same way he does in indy...my point. its not a system/scheme that makes them successful it's the players....

I thought they got rid of him cause he was pouting about not getting paid?
 
Last edited:
vageneral08;3111873 said:
that's what happened in the last thread and guess who win by landslide??? peyton

Majority of the population thinks Peyton is better

Even with that said it still don't change my view that they're equal
 
Last edited:
kAjUn;3123433 said:
I thought they got rid of him cause he was pouting about not getting paid?

that and they felt they were more effective as an offensive when they werent dealing with a diva wide out., that's why they brought branch back as well.

kAjUn;3123442 said:
Majority of the population thinks Peyton is better

Even with that said it still don't change my view that they're equal

the nfl players picked brady over manning....
 
Last edited:
ghost!;3123542 said:
that and they felt they were more effective as an offensive when they werent dealing with a diva wide out., that's why they brought branch back as well.

the nfl players picked brady over manning....

I know but weren't they just voting off of last season?

Cause all I kept hearing was you gotta go with Tom he was the mvp of 2011
 
Last edited:
kAjUn;3124967 said:
I know but weren't they just voting off of last season?

Cause all I kept hearing was you gotta go with Tom he was the mvp of 2011

yea thats all it was just the AP voting from last year....

we shall see who wins this year match up in week 13 ... i still think the colts are gonna meet the Patriots this years playoff... its been long enuff... "the road to the sb has to go thru New England" like they said in 07
 
Last edited:
I go with Peyton. His neck is still healing after surgery though so don't know how much he'll do this season.
 
Last edited:
kAjUn;3123442 said:
Majority of the population thinks Peyton is better

Even with that said it still don't change my view that they're equal

well you and few others feel that way but someone gotta win the vote
 
Last edited:
JUXcaptainHOOK;3134068 said:
yea thats all it was just the AP voting from last year....

we shall see who wins this year match up in week 13 ... i still think the colts are gonna meet the Patriots this years playoff... its been long enuff... "the road to the sb has to go thru New England" like they said in 07

I don't know, I keep hearing that Manning's injury is worse than is being let out. He couldn't even turn his damn neck! If that's true, Indy won't do much this year. Plus, they looked terrible agains the Rams in the preseason game. I mean downright ugly.
 
Last edited:
rapbizla;3137799 said:
I don't know, I keep hearing that Manning's injury is worse than is being let out. He couldn't even turn his damn neck! If that's true, Indy won't do much this year. Plus, they looked terrible agains the Rams in the preseason game. I mean downright ugly.

lol very false....he can move his neck he was throwing in training camp but not running the 1st team offense which will be big gamble because that o-line hasnt gotten the feel of playcalls from manning especially the rookies
 
Last edited:
kAjUn;3124967 said:
I know but weren't they just voting off of last season?

Cause all I kept hearing was you gotta go with Tom he was the mvp of 2011

It wasnt....they talked about each player for their careers, a lot of them talked about brady winning superbowls as well.
 
Last edited:
JUXcaptainHOOK;3122872 said:
I know it was just pre season... but homie from the Patriots put up 45 points last night light... lemme guess... he's the next great QB too right? Fuck outta here... Face the facts, its the system they have which played more of a role in Brady's rings as to Peyton Manning doing it basically individually and working harder for it

I wouldn't say Brady had better coaching. It's not like Dungy and Moore were dog shit. like I said Dungy's staff with Moore etc wasn't chop liver. Polian is not a garbage GM. He knows what he's doing. Marvin Harrison, Dallas Clark, Reggie Wayne, Jeff Saturday, etc...are not scrubs.
 
Last edited:
vageneral08;3136693 said:
well you and few others feel that way but someone gotta win the vote

you right, but dont you think manning will win cause he more popular then brady, same shit with jeter when he got voted in the all start everyone knew he wasnt suppose be in the allstar with a .250 avg but guess what fans voted himm in cause everyone knows who jeter
 
Last edited:
Jeezyfan4ever;3139019 said:
you right, but dont you think manning will win cause he more popular then brady, same shit with jeter when he got voted in the all start everyone knew he wasnt suppose be in the allstar with a .250 avg but guess what fans voted himm in cause everyone knows who jeter

no manning is not more popular than brady they're bout the same.......every since the "rivalry" was created people now anticipate the game the regluar season game when they play each other
 
Last edited:
vageneral08;3139700 said:
no manning is not more popular than brady they're bout the same.......every since the "rivalry" was created people now anticipate the game the regluar season game when they play each other

you wildin manning is the most popular QB in the league by far cause of commercial, his father played in the NFL
 
Last edited:
Jeezyfan4ever;3140217 said:
you wildin manning is the most popular QB in the league by far cause of commercial, his father played in the NFL

lol like brady doesnt have ad's in the magazine or on tv.....peyton's father past experience has nothing to do with peyton and his success
 
Last edited:

Members online

Trending content

Thread statistics

Created
-,
Last reply from
-,
Replies
253
Views
0
Back
Top
Menu
Your profile
Post thread…