Peyton Manning or Tom Brady ?

[Co_Town_Michael]

Same Argument.

Different day.

 

[Jeezyfan4ever]

ohhhh... so u wouldn't perform better if u knew the other teams agenda right? gotcha

Ima prove you when wrong when I get home

 

[Jeezyfan4ever]

I am a Peyton Manning fan... how is he overrated if hes top 3 top 2 in all QB statisics/records .. Most wins inna decade ever with 110 plus.... 4 mvps (5 with sb mvp) .. i've said this shit mad times already and i been here for like 4 days n shit lol ... Peyton Manning isn't overrated.... He does everything for the Colts... Tom Brady has an all star coaching staff and always had a better defense.... Peyton Manning makes every thing happen for Indy... he's what LeBron was to the Cavs. Just cuz Peyton Manning doesn't win a ring every single year doesn't mean he's overrated he gotta ring and he went to the super bowl last year .... and i'll bet any money he'll be back at the sb soon if not this year.

Really wjats does he does for his team

 

[kAjUn]

Tie

But according to the public peyton manning

I think there are alot of tom brady haters

They come up with all types of shit to discredit him even when he proves that shit wrong

 

[Co_Town_Michael]

Honestly if I had to choose.
Brady >>>>>
3 rings >>>> 1 ring

 

[NatTurner1972]

Fuck the Pats but Brady Baltimore Ravens #1 View attachment 7410

 

[Rondo9Rajon]

ohhhh... so u wouldn't perform better if u knew the other teams agenda right? gotcha

His two MVP seasons came after spygate you ignorant Manning nuthugger and once again

"Listen, there's people stealing signals all the time before that," Cowher said. "You have ways to hide those things. We had wristbands for our defense. I remember trying to get offensive plays and see what the formations were. Everybody knows.

"You're trying to gain a competitive edge. Did that go beyond it? To a degree. Do I think that helped them win football games? No. You still have to go out and play the game. I still have a hard time believing that was a difference in a game."

Bill Cowher

http://espn.go.com/blog/afceast/post/_/id/10084/cowher-patriots-are-team-of-decade

 

[Coo Coo Cal's Beanie]

son....what allstar offense line has he had? besides jeff saturday who else is elite on that line? you obiviously dont know what you're talking about.....peyton came in with a bunch a nobodies beside marshall faulk and marvin harrison.....everybody else was drafted later on (dallas clark, reggie wayne, freeney, mathis) but becoming a great team doesnt happen overnight....how did he get exposed last season? from throwing ints? lol that aint the first time he's thrown ints....he still holds the rookie record for most ints in a season....c'mon brady didnt have much less...an all star coaching staff....a defense better than the colts and a better running game...shit had corey dillon running all over the colts defense

Bolded is 2 HOF players. More than what Tom Brady had when he started. Thanks for that point dumbass.
Corey Dillon was already into the last years of his career in NE so dont even start that shit. He had one thousand yard season for them. Manning's had an allpro offense all but 3 years there. His first 2 years and last year. Over the course of his career he's had Marshall Faulk, Edgerrin James, Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, Brandon Stokely, Dallas Clark, joseph addai. All good to great offensive weapons. 4 of them HOFers. He didnt win shit until he had Tony Dungy's dominant cover 2 defense with Dwight Freeney and Robert Mathis as defensive ends. On top of that he wasnt even impressive in that superbowl win. He wouldve lost if Rex Grossman was a decent quaterback. Name the offensive players that Brady had during his superbowl wins that compare to Peyton Mannings. I'll wait.

I am a Peyton Manning fan... how is he overrated if hes top 3 top 2 in all QB statisics/records .. Most wins inna decade ever with 110 plus.... 4 mvps (5 with sb mvp) .. i've said this shit mad times already and i been here for like 4 days n shit lol ... Peyton Manning isn't overrated.... He does everything for the Colts... Tom Brady has an all star coaching staff and always had a better defense.... Peyton Manning makes every thing happen for Indy... he's what LeBron was to the Cavs. Just cuz Peyton Manning doesn't win a ring every single year doesn't mean he's overrated he gotta ring and he went to the super bowl last year .... and i'll bet any money he'll be back at the sb soon if not this year.

Coaches coach and players play. That shit is irrelevant nigga. Jim Mora was a 13 win coach. Tony Dungy brought the Tampa2 defense to Indy which carried them to the title. Peyton Manning had GREAT coaches in Indy the fuck u talkin about? Every year the Pats lose their offensive coordinator and someone steps in to call plays. The only consistent aspect is Tom Brady. He does the same shit Manning does, except audible all gotdamn game for no reason. FACT. Brady always had a better defense and Peyton always had better weapons to inflate his stats, which u love to bring up. When Brady got offense weapons that mirrored the talent that Manning played with, he shattered all his single season records. FACT. Peyton Manning has played with more HOF players in their prime than Tom Brady. FACT. Tom Brady has 4MVPs, if you count the superbowl. Tom Brady is more of a winner. FACT. Count the rings and not meaningless regular season wins.

And what fuckin superbowl did Manning go to last year dumbass? He was eliminated in a wildcard game by Mark Sanchez. Manning has 1 superbowl appearance in his life. You both have been thoroughly sonned. No need to reply.

 

[vageneral08]

Bolded is 2 HOF players. More than what Tom Brady had when he started. Thanks for that point dumbass.
Corey Dillon was already into the last years of his career in NE so dont even start that shit. He had one thousand yard season for them. Manning's had an allpro offense all but 3 years there. His first 2 years and last year. Over the course of his career he's had Marshall Faulk, Edgerrin James, Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, Brandon Stokely, Dallas Clark, joseph addai. All good to great offensive weapons. 4 of them HOFers. He didnt win shit until he had Tony Dungy's dominant cover 2 defense with Dwight Freeney and Robert Mathis as defensive ends. On top of that he wasnt even impressive in that superbowl win. He wouldve lost if Rex Grossman was a decent quaterback. Name the offensive players that Brady had during his superbowl wins that compare to Peyton Mannings. I'll wait.

Coaches coach and players play. That shit is irrelevant nigga. Jim Mora was a 13 win coach. Tony Dungy brought the Tampa2 defense to Indy which carried them to the title. Peyton Manning had GREAT coaches in Indy the fuck u talkin about? Every year the Pats lose their offensive coordinator and someone steps in to call plays. The only consistent aspect is Tom Brady. He does the same shit Manning does, except audible all gotdamn game for no reason. FACT. Brady always had a better defense and Peyton always had better weapons to inflate his stats, which u love to bring up. When Brady got offense weapons that mirrored the talent that Manning played with, he shattered all his single season records. FACT. Peyton Manning has played with more HOF players in their prime than Tom Brady. FACT. Tom Brady has 4MVPs, if you count the superbowl. Tom Brady is more of a winner. FACT. Count the rings and not meaningless regular season wins.

And what fuckin superbowl did Manning go to last year dumbass? He was eliminated in a wildcard game by Mark Sanchez. Manning has 1 superbowl appearance in his life. You both have been thoroughly sonned. No need to reply.

2 players make an allstar team? lol silly ass statement and you proved my point again peyton didnt have much of shit until dungy and other players were drafted....brandon stokely wtf? lol you talking about shit you have no clue about....never had an top notch offensive line so the running game was below average meaning he had to throw more........oh manning has 2 superbowl appearances dummy

 

[Coo Coo Cal's Beanie]

2 players make an allstar team? lol silly ass statement and you proved my point again peyton didnt have much of shit until dungy and other players were drafted....brandon stokely wtf? lol you talking about shit you have no clue about....never had an top notch offensive line so the running game was below average meaning he had to throw more........oh manning has 2 superbowl appearances dummy

2 players dont make an allstar team. I said he had more all pro weapons. Which is factual. he started off with 2 HOFers on his team. His team went 13-3 and 10-6, 2 years before dungy arrived. So i dont wanna hear that shit. Below average run game when Edgerrin James rushed for 5 1000 yard seasons? It would have been 6 had he not missed 2 games due to injury. How about the 1300 yard season Marshall Faulk had before Edgerrin James arrived? You a fuckin retard dickrider ignoring FACTS. Their offensive line wasnt below average. Running game wasnt below average. You dont get 1300, 1500, then 1700 yards rushing from a starting running back in 3 consecutive years with a bad offensive line you moron. I forgot about that travesty superbowl loss Peyton had when he choked the game away. Another reason Brady is better. Thanks for pointing that out

 

[MillzOG]

Manning has 1 superbowl appearance in his life. You both have been thoroughly sonned. No need to reply.

rofl

self ether

 

[vageneral08]

2 players dont make an allstar team. I said he had more all pro weapons. Which is factual. he started off with 2 HOFers on his team. His team went 13-3 and 10-6, 2 years before dungy arrived. So i dont wanna hear that shit. Below average run game when Edgerrin James rushed for 5 1000 yard seasons? It would have been 6 had he not missed 2 games due to injury. How about the 1300 yard season Marshall Faulk had before Edgerrin James arrived? You a fuckin retard dickrider ignoring FACTS. Their offensive line wasnt below average. Running game wasnt below average. You dont get 1300, 1500, then 1700 yards rushing from a starting running back in 3 consecutive years with a bad offensive line you moron. I forgot about that travesty superbowl loss Peyton had when he choked the game away. Another reason Brady is better. Thanks for pointing that out

Who were those all pro weapons before the dungy era? name them.....what about the two losing record seasons he had 3-13 and 6-10 in one season the defense gave up atleast 27 points per game...you named three times where the colts had a decent running game after that what happened? no running game period so dont try to tell me some nonsense bullshit colts were never known for their running game there have been a few good moments but that's it the offensive line is straight ass everybody knows that

 

[northside7]

rofl

self ether

lol Dudes should proofread them types of post before posting but I get his point. 2 SB appearances with 1 win in which he shouldn't have gotten the MVP..

 

[Jeezyfan4ever]

i matter well copy and paste from the facts i said in the last thread

 

[b*braze]

Manning has 1 superbowl appearance in his life. You both have been thoroughly sonned. No need to reply.

umm no.........

 

[AK.aPHillYisILL]

Tom Brady and it ain't even close. I like Peyton but he's just another Dan Marino to me... Yea he got a ring but he got lucky. He damn sure as hell wasn't the MVP in that SB against the Bears either. They just gave it to him because he's Peyton fuckin Manning. I think Peyton's best days are about to be behind him. There's no fuckin way he can keep playing at a high level like he's been throughout his career. He's already 35 and should be past his prime. He's got to decline sometime... I mean the Colts aren't a good team right now. I can see the Colts having a losing season this year and not making the playoffs. The Jags are better and though I want to say the Texans are better they always seem to fuck it up.

 

[Jeezyfan4ever]

Tom Brady and it ain't even close. I like Peyton but he's just another Dan Marino to me... Yea he got a ring but he got lucky. He damn sure as hell wasn't the MVP in that SB against the Bears either. They just gave it to him because he's Peyton fuckin Manning. I think Peyton's best days are about to be behind him. There's no fuckin way he can keep playing at a high level like he's been throughout his career. He's already 35 and should be past his prime. He's got to decline sometime... I mean the Colts aren't a good team right now. I can see the Colts having a losing season this year and not making the playoffs. The Jags are better and though I want to say the Texans are better they always seem to fuck it up.

i agree with everything execpt you comparing manning to marino. You outta your mind, Could you imagine if you gave Marino all the players that Manning has had in his career on offense? I can't even imagine. It wouldn't even be a contest.

 

[JUXcaptainHOOK]

LOL @ The Patriot fans getting mad... Ok how about this.... The Colts have won the super bowl more recently than the Patriots have... The patriots havent won since like fuckin 2004 almost 10 years... da fuck ya yappin about

 

[Coo Coo Cal's Beanie]

rofl

self ether

playas fuck up too

Who were those all pro weapons before the dungy era? name them.....what about the two losing record seasons he had 3-13 and 6-10 in one season the defense gave up atleast 27 points per game...you named three times where the colts had a decent running game after that what happened? no running game period so dont try to tell me some nonsense bullshit colts were never known for their running game there have been a few good moments but that's it the offensive line is straight ass everybody knows that

dumbass did u read my post? Edgerrin James had 5 1000 yard seasons with the colts. Woulda been 6 but he missed 2 games. he had like 969 in a season. then marshall faulk had a 1300 yard season wit the colts before James. Then joseph addai had 2 1000 yard seasons with the colts. Thats a total of 9 fuckin years wit a 1000 yard RB on his team. You dont get to that with a bad offensive line. You a dumbass. He's had a more consistent running game behind him than Tom Brady has. The fuck is you talkin bout?

 

[texas409]

Personally I go with Peyton... 4 MVPs (5 including the SB) ... 2nd all time 300 yard passing games (breaking it this year), most comebacks in the 4 quarter EVER (44 plus) ... Most wins inna decade 110 plus, yes thats more than the Cowboys in the 90's.... Best QB-WR combo (Peyton-Harrison) ... 2nd most starts in history ... And just basically how he manages the games, he's really like the coach of the Indianapolis Colts.... He does it all on some LeBron on the Cavs type shit...

Brady is nice, but that whole SPY GATE shit really made me think other wise, and his Coach is one of if not thee best in the NFL ...

And when you add everything up, Peyton Manning just does more for his team than Brady does for his in my opinion....

Who ya going with?

i fucks with you my dude i cosign this entire post