OBJECTIVELY is Eminem Top 10 DOA?

[Mr.LV]

Does Eminem have a better discography than

Ghostface...no

2pac.... no

Nas..... no

Kanye west....no

Scarface......no

BIG....no

Common....no

Jay Z ....no

Ice Cube.... no

LL Cool J..... no

 

[Go figure]

Does Eminem have a better discography than

Ghostface...no

2pac.... no

Nas..... no

Kanye west....no

Scarface......no

BIG....no

Common....no

Jay Z ....no

Ice Cube.... no

LL Cool J..... no

Cmon bruh....BIG discography really?

 

[Go figure]

Is Em a top 10 rapper?

Your fav artist: "Yes"

IC: no he is racist

Did yall get thru high school?

Yeah we did, and also have degrees. I already broke this shit down on the first page, Elmer's glue eating ass nigga.

Your break down was ass tho.

Name your top lyricists or stop quoting me

 

[Mr.LV]

Does Eminem have a better discography than

Ghostface...no

2pac.... no

Nas..... no

Kanye west....no

Scarface......no

BIG....no

Common....no

Jay Z ....no

Ice Cube.... no

LL Cool J..... no

Cmon bruh....BIG discography really?

BIG has 2 classic albums ......does Eminem even have 2 classic albums no

 

[dwade206]

Does Eminem have a better discography than

Ghostface...no

2pac.... no

Nas..... no

Kanye west....no

Scarface......no

BIG....no

Common....no

Jay Z ....no

Ice Cube.... no

LL Cool J..... no

Throw PE and Ra on that list and close thread; done

 

[Go figure]

Does Eminem have a better discography than

Ghostface...no

2pac.... no

Nas..... no

Kanye west....no

Scarface......no

BIG....no

Common....no

Jay Z ....no

Ice Cube.... no

LL Cool J..... no

Cmon bruh....BIG discography really?

BIG has 2 classic albums ......does Eminem even have 2 classic albums no

What u judge classics by?

Cuz ill give him marshall mathers lp and eminem show

 

[kingtob330]

Imo the lil white boy was corny and what he rapped about was whack. I can't relate

 

[Mr.LV]

Does Eminem have a better discography than

Ghostface...no

2pac.... no

Nas..... no

Kanye west....no

Scarface......no

BIG....no

Common....no

Jay Z ....no

Ice Cube.... no

LL Cool J..... no

Cmon bruh....BIG discography really?

BIG has 2 classic albums ......does Eminem even have 2 classic albums no

What u judge classics by?

Cuz ill give him marshall mathers lp and eminem show

Classic = timeless music

 

[Stew]

Does Eminem have a better discography than

Ghostface...no

2pac.... no

Nas..... no

Kanye west....no

Scarface......no

BIG....no

Common....no

Jay Z ....no

Ice Cube.... no

LL Cool J..... no

U know what, I'm not gonna give my beef with the Kanye and Biggie spots cause you're a respectable poster who doesn't go on insult rages lol and I'm sure knows his stuff but I'm willing to bet most don't own or even know half the music posted from these artist lol I know this for a fact.

 

[bck145]

Does Eminem have a better discography than

Ghostface...no

2pac.... no

Nas..... no

Kanye west....no

Scarface......no

BIG....no

Common....no

Jay Z ....no

Ice Cube.... no

LL Cool J..... no

That's not entirely true....he is better than ghost,big,kanye.......like I said from the start...hes better than rappers who other ppl have in their top 10

 

[Mr.LV]

Does Eminem have a better discography than

Ghostface...no

2pac.... no

Nas..... no

Kanye west....no

Scarface......no

BIG....no

Common....no

Jay Z ....no

Ice Cube.... no

LL Cool J..... no

U know what, I'm not gonna give my beef with the Kanye and Biggie spots cause you're a respectable poster who doesn't go on insult rages lol and I'm sure knows his stuff but I'm willing to bet most don't own or even know half the music posted from these artist lol I know this for a fact.

I just think it's very hard to crack the top 10 in Rap music based off discography, hell it's hard to crack the top 20 when you start adding in duos and groups.

 

[THE_R_]

LYRICALLY?...NO QUESTION

OVERALL, HE'S TOP 25-ISH...

 

[Stew]

Does Eminem have a better discography than

Ghostface...no

2pac.... no

Nas..... no

Kanye west....no

Scarface......no

BIG....no

Common....no

Jay Z ....no

Ice Cube.... no

LL Cool J..... no

U know what, I'm not gonna give my beef with the Kanye and Biggie spots cause you're a respectable poster who doesn't go on insult rages lol and I'm sure knows his stuff but I'm willing to bet most don't own or even know half the music posted from these artist lol I know this for a fact.

I just think it's very hard to crack the top 10 in Rap music based off discography, hell it's hard to crack the top 20 when you start adding in duos and groups.

And I wouldn't argue against anybody who feels that way who knows their shit, that's a respectable opinion, no 5 niggas, even the most knowledgeable cats out there are gonna have the same opinion lol u gonna argue against Killer Mike cause he has 3000 in his top 10? Fuck no :joy: but some of these niggas tho, they can get it lol

 

[TheGOAT]

Not in my Top 10 but based on criteria in OP (impact & skill) he gets a yes vote from me

 

[Go figure]

Niggas still love to give it up even when the person mentioned disrespects y'all

What does this have to do with rap skill?

I already explained that on the first page, short school bus riding ass nigga. Never once have I heard a brother say, "Damn, last night in the whip, I had to take it back to the Eminem Show to get my mind right." Or, "When that Real Slim Shady joint came on, the club went crazy." Fuck outta here.

Oh...i stopped reading at "decent lyricist at best" foh

Name some of your top lyricists

Well if you stopped reading, the fuck you wanna about my top lyricists?

"Cant back up my argument" post

Whos your best lyricists....10 better than Em. stop talking like ur somebodys gf

 

[Go figure]

Does Eminem have a better discography than

Ghostface...no

2pac.... no

Nas..... no

Kanye west....no

Scarface......no

BIG....no

Common....no

Jay Z ....no

Ice Cube.... no

LL Cool J..... no

Cmon bruh....BIG discography really?

BIG has 2 classic albums ......does Eminem even have 2 classic albums no

What u judge classics by?

Cuz ill give him marshall mathers lp and eminem show

Classic = timeless music

I can dig that cuz i know ppl that dont care much for BIGs catalog but can acknowledge his impact, skill level and influence and will still put him top 5 OBJECTIVELY.

just dont think the same is happening for Em in this thread.

 

[natural born sinners]

Skills wise, yes. I would say he alot closer to ten than top 5 bc of alot of wack songs in his catalog.

 

[a_list]

Dude got prolly over 8 albums and I only like prolly 3 of his songs....

 

[Beta]

I'm still laughing over the awards show shit lol

What was he thinking?

 

[Lefty_]

Top 10 impact.

Top 10 storyteller.

Top 10 flow.

Top 10 Technically....

Low teens, early 20s discography.

He had 3 good albums to start with. A few bad ones. I thought relapse could have been really dope, but he messed it up with his voice inflections or whatever he was trying to do.

First white boy to break through commercially, had the greatest year an artist could possibly have in 2002. He has a lot of dope, dope verses that don't involve bullshit like his mom, or fantasizing as being a serial killer, has many unforgivable songs and verses(I'm looking at you "Fack").

All that aside, If you put Em in a booth with a beat, and tell him to just go in... He's in the conversation. Period.