My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy...One Year Later.

[Mister B.]

Classic? Uhhhhh......

I can't say so. If Late Registration hasn't hit "classic" status by now, this won't either.

Still very good though.

 

[Lil B The Base God]

that album is no classic dior paint is.

 

[the_focused_one]

The album is not a classic, but it is very dope.

My reasons for why it is isn't a classic:

- No SOLO production by Kanye

- Only half the verses are Kanye's... way too many features...

- Take away the skits, there's 11 tracks of music, only 9 of which I like...

- Half of Kanye's subject matter is just about fucking (and unfortunately it's spilled over into Watch the Throne as well)...

Great Album overall, but nowhere near classic... better then Graduation IMHO..

 

[Mrslim1]

The album is not a classic, but it is very dope.

My reasons for why it is isn't a classic:

- No SOLO production by Kanye

- Only half the verses are Kanye's... way too many features...

- Take away the skits, there's 11 tracks of music, only 9 of which I like...

- Half of Kanye's subject matter is just about fucking (and unfortunately it's spilled over into Watch the Throne as well)...

Great Album overall, but nowhere near classic... better then Graduation IMHO..

Bolded not a good reason . It doesnt take away from the quality of the production .

 

[CoolJoe]

I'm amazed at how people overrate the shit out of College Dropout,Kanye sounded like an amateur on that album

Jesus walks was only good cuz of the Beat,Fuck jesus I don't give a fuck where that cracka walked

Spaceship,2 words,school spirit,we dont care? Lmao ya'll like that type of shit?

I dont want to hear a church hymn in between songs

Fuck outta here fuck college dropout just like illmatic its overrated by sheep wit no sense of direction

What's bad about that song?

 

[the_focused_one]

Bolded not a good reason . It doesnt take away from the quality of the production .

Ok. I'll give you that... I just feel like Kanye didn't put his best effort into this album, and this was a sign of that IMO...

 

[Mrslim1]

Ok. I'll give you that... I just feel like Kanye didn't put his best effort into this album, and this was a sign of that IMO...

Not so sure about that . He made a movie for the album . Went back to so called " real " Hip Hop . U cant use that to discredit him . I mean would u say that " I Want You " wasnt as good as it could have been because Marvin Gaye didnt have solo production on every track ? Thats kind of argument is just specific to Hip Hop . As far as your other point you are entitled to your opinion . But the Solo production this is kinda weak