Lets settle this, Who better Jayz or Nas

[real_hh_rep]

Catalogue - Nas
Subject Matter - Nas
Lyrics - Nas
Beats - well, it's debatable, but I like Nas production
Flow - Jay
Emotion - Jay

Winner - Nas

 

[blackstarr]

The people have spoken....Nas the greatest

 

[stupot0607]

Nas has a better catalogue, better flow, better lyrics, better guest features.......

so i guess Nas won.

 

[Melanin_Enriched]

Jay has a better flow?
and when Nas does show emotion it's >>>>>>Jay's emotion

 

[blazn101]

Both are great, but since we're going on just lyrics...

 

[love yal]

Nas and Jay-Z that's a tough choice. Nas is having a tour and Jay-Z is dropping an Album with Kanye west....

My vote: tie

 

[daboyag1]

lol @ "settle this" though, this is hip hop, nothing will ever be settled

 

[juelz21]

nas >> better

 

[t. webb]

It's a toss up...somedays I say Nas, somedays it's Jay....

 

[soul rattler]

Jay Electronica >>> Nas

 

[soul rattler]

Beats - well, it's debatable, but I like Nas production

Winner - Nas

No, it's not debatable. And the bolded is never possible.

 

[Bigavelli]

Nas is defintley in the top 15 G.O.A.T.

Jay Z is around the 55-60 mark IMO

 

[DMTxTHC]

The rapper that dropped Ether...

 

[hiphophova]

Nas, Jay over all just cant make music.

Nas is the better rapper and better musician in my opinion.

 

[dnyce215]

nasty nas is a rebel to america

 

[Bigavelli]

Nas, Jay over all just cant make music.

Nas is the better rapper and better musician in my opinion.

Yeah Jay Z's catalouge is 1 of the weakest in Hip Hop period

Too many really poor Album's Volume 2, Volume 3, The Dynasty, The Blurprint 2, Kingdome Come, Blueprint 3

Few decent Album's like Blueprint

Few Average Album's like American Gangster

Good Album with Reasonable Doubt

As far as Content/Subject Matter Jay Z is too 1 dimensional lacks any Substance overall and predominantly has Rapped about selling coke and money every Album

Lacks in the Hook department too relies on features for Hook's

Strongest asset is Flow

Jay Z's Freestyles are better than his Song's IMO

 

['nino'jacob]

Nas GOAT on the internet, Jay-z the GOAT in real life

 

[KeepinItHundred]

both are great. as of lately though... HHID and kingdom come were both average. untitled and american ganster both had some good shit on there. we'll have to wait until nas' drops his solo and jay and ye drop the who WTT to compare them to the BB3 and DR.

 

[Bigavelli]

Catalouge Nas>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Jay Z

Song Writing/Lyricism Nas>>>>>>>>>>>>>Jay Z

Content/Subject Matter/Substance Nas>>>>>>>>>Jay Z

Hook Writing/Performing Nas>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Jay Z

Story Telling Nas>>>>>>>>>>>>>Jay Z

Emotion Nas>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Jay Z

Voice Nas>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Jay Z

Flow Jay Z>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Nas

Beat Selection Jay Z Nas

Illmatic, It Was Written, Stillmatic, Lost Tapes>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Reasonable Doubt ( Jay Z's beat Album)

Nas worst Album's Nastradamus, Streets Disciple, Hip Hop Is Dead>>>>>>>>>>>>>Jay Z's worst Album's Volume 2, Volume 3, The Dynasty, The Blueprint 2, Kingdome Come, The Blueprint 3

Nas average Album's God's Son and Untitled>>>>>>>>>>>>Jay Z's average Album's The Black Album

Distant Relatives Duo Album>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Best Of Both World

'New York State Of Mind', 'The Message' 'Made You Look', 'If I Ruled The World', 'Shoot Em Up' P'urple', 'Rewind' 'Memory Lane'>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Any Jay Z Song

'Ether'>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>'Takeover'

 

[qawshun]

And for the record, i doubt this will ever be settled, lol.

co sign i got nas by a nose but jay right there with him