Is Getting an MBA a Waste of Time? | 5 Alternatives to an MBA | Real-World Business Education

  • Thread starter Thread starter New Editor
  • Start date Start date

Maximus Rex

New member
Marine-Corps-Logo-e1447922621669.jpg


MBA Alternative #4 – Join An Organization That Develops Leaders

Real leadership is developed in the real world. You can make a deep impact on communities by joining the Peace corps or the Salvation Army or contribute to the military’s progress by joining the Marine Corps. Whether your mission is to promote understanding between American volunteers and the communities they serve or to win battles for the nation, you’ll quickly learn that a leader leads from the front and you always lead by example. You may have to take a pay-cut and put off lucrative careers in other industries, but joining one of these institutions is a great alternative to an MBA. The values you make part of your internal system through your experience with one of these institutions will guide you for decades.

Instead of relying on a business school education to help you succeed, you start to practice skills that make a tangible difference. You get to participate in projects that show your ability to impact in the real world, by working on practical problems.


Self-Employed-Entrepreneur.jpg


MBA Alternative #5 – Start A Business

I highly recommend starting your own business – no matter how small. Entrepreneurship as a subject has been added to many MBA curriculums in recent years. But you don’t need to spend two years stuck in class and foot a hefty bill for tuition to get started.

For valuable lessons that can’t be taught at school, you need to stop dipping your toes in the water and dive right in. Operating a business is going to expose you to marketing, advertising, finance, accounting, operations, strategy and management. Key skills you may not get to learn through a fixed curriculum. You will most likely fail initially, but stick with it and you’ll get the hang of it. It took 5 months for me to register my first sale.

If you had to hire someone to work in your company, whom would you prefer – a candidate who built a successful and profitable business in two years or a candidate who sat through lectures and reviewed case studies and business models to obtain a degree?

An MBA is right for some people, but not for the majority. Commit within reason to an action plan rather than resorting to the security of theoretical learning. Instead of cocooning yourself in the protective bubble of academic life, ask yourself some tough questions and choose to tackle problems and challenges in the real world.


 
Last edited:
An mba program really teaches business philosophy it gets your mind ready to think like a business man/CEO and puts you into direct contact with people who think the same.
 
zzombie;8696045 said:
An mba program really teaches business philosophy it gets your mind ready to think like a business man/CEO and puts you into direct contact with people who think the same.

Selling drugs does the same thing if you really do it lol.
 
_Lefty;8696059 said:
zzombie;8696045 said:
An mba program really teaches business philosophy it gets your mind ready to think like a business man/CEO and puts you into direct contact with people who think the same.

Selling drugs does the same thing if you really do it lol.

Nah not really
 
zzombie;8696067 said:
_Lefty;8696059 said:
zzombie;8696045 said:
An mba program really teaches business philosophy it gets your mind ready to think like a business man/CEO and puts you into direct contact with people who think the same.

Selling drugs does the same thing if you really do it lol.

Nah not really

Capitalism ain't as hard as people would like to think.
 
I have one.. I am not sure if I would be where I am in my career without it because your whole approach to business changes after you're taught certain concepts. You've been exposed to them prior but in the classroom at least for me it clicked.

One thing I can say for sure is that it doesn't hurt. A white person with aspirations of being in upper management at a fortune 500 company may be able to get by without it. But as a minority. I think you will need all the help you can get if that's your goal.

At the end of the day it depends..
 
_Lefty;8696084 said:
zzombie;8696067 said:
_Lefty;8696059 said:
zzombie;8696045 said:
An mba program really teaches business philosophy it gets your mind ready to think like a business man/CEO and puts you into direct contact with people who think the same.

Selling drugs does the same thing if you really do it lol.

Nah not really

Capitalism ain't as hard as people would like to think.

It's as easy as some people think either
 
It depends on your career goals, the position and trajectory of your career, and your ability to learn from and demonstrate your work experience.

Every college degree is overpriced in America tho...

Doesent mean it isn't valuable or won't provide a return on investment.
 
Last edited:
zzombie;8696240 said:
_Lefty;8696084 said:
zzombie;8696067 said:
_Lefty;8696059 said:
zzombie;8696045 said:
An mba program really teaches business philosophy it gets your mind ready to think like a business man/CEO and puts you into direct contact with people who think the same.

Selling drugs does the same thing if you really do it lol.

Nah not really

Capitalism ain't as hard as people would like to think.

It's as easy as some people think either

I'll give you that.
 
Wuwop;8696395 said:
How do you get experience with this degree?

Internships and work experience. Back in the day, MBA's were generally popular and mostly found amongst individuals who had about 10-15 years of work experience, now they have become so saturated that 23 year olds now have MBA's with no experience at all. The benefits of having an MBA have greatly declined. There are programs where you can test out of an MBA and be awarded the degree in less than 6 months.

My cousin made her way to the top of one of the largest health care companies here in America with only an associates degree; the company paid for her bachelors, but she still lacks an MBA and is making 6 figures without an MBA, and she's a Black woman, so I don't agree with the statement about minorities.

It's also logical to note that not all MBA's are created equal.

 
Last edited:
Asantewa;8696559 said:
Wuwop;8696395 said:
How do you get experience with this degree?

Internships and work experience. Back in the day, MBA's were generally popular and mostly found amongst individuals who had about 10-15 years of work experience, now they have become so saturated that 23 year olds now have MBA's with no experience at all. The benefits of having an MBA have greatly declined. There are programs where you can test out of an MBA and be awarded the degree in less than 6 months.

My cousin made her way to the top of one of the largest health care companies here in America with only an associates degree; the company paid for her bachelors, but she still lacks an MBA and is making 6 figures without an MBA, and she's a Black woman, so I don't agree with the statement about minorities.

It's also logical to note that not all MBA's are created equal.

Just to clarify.. I did not say that climbing the ladder would be impossible without it. I just said that it helps.. Outside of that I agree with everything you said..

By the time I graduated I was in that 10-15 year experience group which is why the concepts clicked because I had real world experience to lean on..
 
Asantewa;8696559 said:
Wuwop;8696395 said:
How do you get experience with this degree?

Internships and work experience. Back in the day, MBA's were generally popular and mostly found amongst individuals who had about 10-15 years of work experience, now they have become so saturated that 23 year olds now have MBA's with no experience at all. The benefits of having an MBA have greatly declined. There are programs where you can test out of an MBA and be awarded the degree in less than 6 months.

My cousin made her way to the top of one of the largest health care companies here in America with only an associates degree; the company paid for her bachelors, but she still lacks an MBA and is making 6 figures without an MBA, and she's a Black woman, so I don't agree with the statement about minorities.

It's also logical to note that not all MBA's are created equal.

Where did your fam start?

How long did it take her to move up and how old is she?

And was her goal to get her own business? or run another persons?

 
I have an mba and I can honestly say going through the schooling to get it was the best thing for me. The people I met while doing it changed my life
 
Wuwop;8696583 said:
Asantewa;8696559 said:
Wuwop;8696395 said:
How do you get experience with this degree?

Internships and work experience. Back in the day, MBA's were generally popular and mostly found amongst individuals who had about 10-15 years of work experience, now they have become so saturated that 23 year olds now have MBA's with no experience at all. The benefits of having an MBA have greatly declined. There are programs where you can test out of an MBA and be awarded the degree in less than 6 months.

My cousin made her way to the top of one of the largest health care companies here in America with only an associates degree; the company paid for her bachelors, but she still lacks an MBA and is making 6 figures without an MBA, and she's a Black woman, so I don't agree with the statement about minorities.

It's also logical to note that not all MBA's are created equal.

Where did your fam start?

How long did it take her to move up and how old is she?

And was her goal to get her own business? or run another persons?

UnitedHealth Group, she started on the bottom and made her way to the top. She's 37 now, but she started their in her early 20s and moved up, she got her associates at 28 while their, and moved up, which is shocking with just an associates; but they paid for her bachelors which she just completed about a year ago; and she's making 6 figures (which she was also making with just an associates degree), as I stated with no MBA.

I don't think she's thinking about starting her own business though.

 
Last edited:
IMO getting an MBA in order to "get a job" is overkill and a waste of time and money...

And getting an MBA to "start your own business" may be by itself insufficient or a misplacement of time and money; depending on the context ...

I see an MBA best suited in situations where you want to acquire high ranking/Executive leadership positions in a well established company.

In these cases, the MBA is complimenting the skills and experience you already have while equipping you with the business acumen to make far-reaching strategic decisions.

It also has a greater chance of paying itself off, as you'd be using it to climb into high Six Figure territory...

Of course getting an MBA isn't the only way to do that either ...

 
Last edited:
Peace_79;8696804 said:
IMO getting an MBA in order to "get a job" is overkill and a waste of time and money...

And getting an MBA to "start your own business" may be by itself insufficient or a misplacement of time and money; depending on the context ...

I see an MBA best suited in situations where you want to acquire high ranking/Executive leadership positions in a well established company.

In these cases, the MBA is complimenting the skills and experience you already have while equipping you with the business acumen to make far-reaching strategic decisions.

It also has a greater chance of paying itself off, as you'd be using it to climb into high Six Figure territory...

Of course getting an MBA isn't the only way to do that either ...

Well articulated.. Exactly what I was trying to say...
 

Members online

Trending content

Thread statistics

Created
-,
Last reply from
-,
Replies
33
Views
77
Back
Top
Menu
Your profile
Post thread…