Is Aaron Rodgers Better than Favre?

[bankrupt baller]

damn yo rodgers dropped 8 catches

 

[tru_m.a.c]

damn yo rodgers dropped 8 catches

and fumbled it 3 other times

and missed the block that resulted in a sack when a TD was available

 

[FlyFreeCt]

ARod still better than Favre...

 

[Rey Negro]

He still is. Just had a better season then Favre ever had(coming off a playoff run better then favre ever had also) and shits on him in every aspect of being a QB.

Breh. Matt Stafford passed for 5,000 yards and 41 touchdowns.

Montana never had a season as good as that. Neither did Kelly, Elway or Moon. I guess Stafford is better lol. See how retarded that sounds? For one, QB play is questionable in this era. Brett old ass was 40 years old and tossing up 4100 yards, 33 touchdowns & 7 ints. For two, legends earned their respect. 3 or 4 years ain't enough to start talking greasy to niggas who were consistently great for decades. Go that way. You probably was on the Vick hype train last year too.

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

Breh. Matt Stafford passed for 5,000 yards and 41 touchdowns.

Montana never had a season as good as that. Neither did Kelly, Elway or Moon. I guess Stafford is better lol. See how retarded that sounds? For one, QB play is questionable in this era. Brett old ass was 40 years old and tossing up 4100 yards, 33 touchdowns & 7 ints. For two, legends earned their respect. 3 or 4 years ain't enough to start talking greasy to niggas who were consistently great for decades. Go that way. You probably was on the Vick hype train last year too.

That's all true

Glad you agree with me.

 

[fightforolddc]

Yes. Easily.

Favre might be the most overrated player in NFL history. He single-handedly lost his team so many big games ... Rodgers right now is easily better than Favre ever was.

 

[Rey Negro]

That's all true

Glad you agree with me.

lmao. i would kill to see you say that in a barbershop filled with older niggas.

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

Rodgers does EVERYTHING better then favre.

That's the point

 

[Rey Negro]

Yes. Easily.

Favre might be the most overrated player in NFL history. He single-handedly lost his team so many big games ... Rodgers right now is easily better than Favre ever was.

So did Peyton Manning. QBs lose. Wait til Rodgers plays for 10 years, if he makes it that long and see how many smudges his legacy has.

 

[Rey Negro]

Just off the top of my head I can remember Favre throwing 6 picks against the Rams, throwing a fly ball to Brian Dawkins 4th and 26 game, INT to lose the game against the Giants in the NFC championship, INT to Tracy Porter against the Saints .... Favre STAY blowing it when the season's on the line. Rodgers will never do that and definitely not time and time again.

Just off the top of my head I can remember Peyton throwing away the Superbowl to N.O. I remember him getting trampled the death by the Jets in 2002. 41 to fucking zero. He only passed for 130 yards. I remember Peyton being manhandled by New England (4 interceptions & 35.5 passer rating). Breh. the list goes on & on LOL

The same shit yall criticize Favre for, Peyton did. Making poor decisions in crunch time. Only winning once.

I guess in 5 years if Andrew Luck has a ring & better stats, we'll be calling Peyton trash.

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

Breh....you're logic is flawed. You basically said Stafford a better QB than every NFL legend we grew up on.

I said he had a better season.

Arod had a Better season AND he's better then Favre.

Thats the difference

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

Just off the top of my head I can remember Peyton throwing away the Superbowl to N.O. I remember him getting trampled the death by the Jets in 2002. 41 to fucking zero. He only passed for 130 yards. I remember Peyton being manhandled by New England (4 interceptions & 35.5 passer rating). Breh. the list goes on & on LOL

The same shit yall criticize Favre for, Peyton did. Making poor decisions in crunch time. Only winning once.

I guess in 5 years if Andrew Luck has a ring & better stats, we'll be calling Peyton trash.

Both Peyton and Favre are documented Choke artists what's your point?

 

[fightforolddc]

Just off the top of my head I can remember Peyton throwing away the Superbowl to N.O. I remember him getting trampled the death by the Jets in 2002. 41 to fucking zero. He only passed for 130 yards. I remember Peyton being manhandled by New England (4 interceptions & 35.5 passer rating). Breh. the list goes on & on LOL

The same shit yall criticize Favre for, Peyton did. Making poor decisions in crunch time. Only winning once.

I guess in 5 years if Andrew Luck has a ring & better stats, we'll be calling Peyton trash.

I don't fuck with Peyton either but he's nowhere near the choke artist as Favre. Come on I'm giving you all these times where this kat single-handedly LOST THE SEASON for his teams. By himself with his awful decision. Peyton has not come up big but the Colts weren't losing playoff games just because of him blowing it.

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

Is he more accurrate? No,

Quicker release? Nope

Better decision maker? LOL hell no

Better on the move? Nope

Better footwork? Nah

More clutch? Nope

Favre has a stronger arm, but arod's got a cannon also.

I fail to see how favre is better. Rodgers is favre without the stupid interceptions.

No one has YET to answer this lol. That's how I know you guys agree. Your just arguing for the sake of Nostalgia.

 

[fightforolddc]

Aside from that, like dude said before ... does Favre even got a better arm than Rodgers? I've seen Rodgers throw 70 yards on the move.

 

[Rey Negro]

I said he had a better season.

Arod had a Better season AND he's better then Favre.

Thats the difference

You not really proving your point breh....

Is it stats, skills, what? You jumpin over the place. You can't be arguing stats in a league where three QBs passed over 5,000 yards in one year. And if its skill, thats your personal opinion. And you're doing a horrible job at explaining it.

 

[fightforolddc]

Favre has the GOAT arm, I'll give him that. By Arod has a cannon also

In what terms though? Distance or velocity or what?? I was watching a highlight tape of John Elway one time and his throws were moving so fast ... like they were in fast forward or something. In terms of distance, I don't even think Favre threw better than Jamarcus Russell. Russell couldn't hit a guy 5 yards away but he could bomb the hell out of it.

Shit I seen Jeff George throw a hail mary that had to have traveled like 80 yards in the air. Don't think Favre could do that.

 

[Rey Negro]

Packers before Brett came to Green Bay

1986 NFL NFC Central 4th 4 12
1987 NFL NFC Central 3rd 5 9
1988 NFL NFC Central 5th 4 12
1989 NFL NFC Central 2nd 10 6
1990 NFL NFC Central 4th 6 10
1991 NFL NFC Central 4th 4 12

Packers before Rodgers took over

2003 NFL NFC North 1st 10 6
2004 NFL NFC North 1st 10 6
2005 NFL NFC North 4th 4 12
2006 NFL NFC North 2nd 8 8
2007 NFL NFC North 1st 13 3

One kid came to a bad team and was thrown the sharks immediately. The other kid was given a championship caliber team after sitting on the bench for years.

 

[Rey Negro]

Favre after his 7th year - 1997, age 28 years old
5x Pro-Bowl Selections
3x NFL MVP
3x All-Pro
3x NFC Player of the Year
2 Superbowl Appearances
1 Superbowl
4,413 yards 38 tds 13 ints 99.5 (1995 Season)
3,899 yards 39 tds 13 ints 95.8 (1996 Season)
3,867 yards 35 tds 16 ints 92.6% (1997 Season)
11-5 Record (1995 Season)
13-3 Record (1996 Season)
13-3 Record (1997 Season)

Rodgers after his 7th year - 2011, age 28 years old
2x Pro-Bowl Selections
Superbowl MVP
1 Superbowl
4,434 yards 30 tds 7 ints 103.2% (2009 Season)
3,922 yards 28 tds 11 ints 101.2% (2010 Season)
4,643 yards 45 tds 6 ints 122.5% (2011 Season)
11-5 Record (2009 Season)
10-6 Record (2010 Season)
15-1 Record (2011 Season)

That's both of those niggas at the same time in their careers. Favre accomplished more. Rodgers had better stats (*** for playing in an easier league though). It's no guarantee Rodgers gets another ring.

 

[Mvpbrodie93]

Lol Rodgers didn't start until like 4 years ago, so posting stats after 7 years is useless.

Rodgers is better because he's better then favre in every aspect of being a QB

He's more efficient, turns the ball over less, more accurate a FAR better decision maker and in another league is a clutch performer.(as Favre has lost game after game for his team in the playoffs in his career)

He shits on him statistically and just had a better season then Favre has ever had.

In 2 years we wont be having this argument.

And btw the no contact rule was instituted in 1978. He was playing under the same rules as Arod