Illmatic VS..... The Diary?

[kjrain12]

Personally, I don't think the Diary is even close. It's an overrated album as it is, but from a poetic standpoint, Scarface has better albums. ("The Fix", "Made")

 

[genocidecutter]

Damn this is hard question

 

[Mr_Kennedy]

I think The O.C's Word Life album is closer competition to Illmatic.

 

[Built 4 cuban linx]

illmatic

 

[goldenja]

Personally, I don't think the Diary is even close. It's an overrated album as it is, but from a poetic standpoint, Scarface has better albums. ("The Fix", "Made")

how is it overrated?? who actually talks about it nowadays?

 

[goldenja]

this whole having a no poll thing is killing me

 

[Trollio]

the diary vs iww is a better comparison

 

[goldenja]

the diary vs iww is a better comparison

im not gonna lie, I thought about that since I did that atleins vs iww a while back....

but the reasons stated above are why I did.