How ya feel about this bullsh!t NBA All-star game voting

  • Thread starter Thread starter New Editor
  • Start date Start date

mystery brown

New member
That's why the NFL voting is the best system. The NBA All-Star voting became a joke the 1st time they let the fans determine who starts. Now, it's just a HUGE popularity contest.

The same thing that T-Mac is (or isn't, in this case) doing this year, the dumb-ass fans did for Yao Ming last year, where he didn't play pretty much from the start of the regualr season till January, and got voted #1 overall to start in the West.

Hilarious at best. Complete bullshit and an utter mockery to the game at worst.
 
Last edited:
hell yea... i get what they were trying to do but it just isnt working. Great players are getting shafted while dudes who don't even touch the court are getting voted for.
 
Last edited:
cosign all of ya ^^

i mean, i understand lettin the fans vote...cus if it werent for us fans the game wouldnt be this big, but gotdayum fans look retarded when shit like this happens

Deron Williams is 1 of the best PG's in the league and still hasnt been to an All star game....
 
Last edited:
It's a shame that McGrady and Iverson are slated to start. Shaq will probably get the 2nd center spot in the east even though Noah, Horford or Brook Lopez deserves it
 
Last edited:
jamacia;12617 said:
Its who the FANS wanna see in the game. If they want AI or T Mac then it is what it is.

I hear you, but All star games=leverage for contracts. Fans are messing with players money. Not the stars like Bron or Kobe, because they will get max money regardless. When D-Will is a free agent, he may not have an all-star game to his name despite being a top 2 or 3 pg by all accounts
 
Last edited:
How is Chris Kaman not on the ballot?

Why is Kevin Durant not a starter and gonna be a reserve?
 
Last edited:
jamacia;12617 said:
Its who the FANS wanna see in the game. If they want AI or T Mac then it is what it is.

If the game is good, then the fans will watch regardless....im not sayin it shouldnt be up to the fans, but they're should be some kind of regulations to the vote
 
Last edited:
millz_flybridge;13287 said:
If the game is good, then the fans will watch regardless....im not sayin it shouldnt be up to the fans, but they're should be some kind of regulations to the vote

yeah true no d-will or KD is absurd
 
Last edited:
I feel you, but these are my all-star rosters

West:

Steve Nash

Kobe Bryant

Tim Duncan

Dirk Nowitzki

Amare Stoudemire

East:

Dwyane Wade

Kevin Garnett

Dwight Howard

LeBron James

Vince Carter
 
Last edited:
millz_flybridge;13287 said:
If the game is good, then the fans will watch regardless....im not sayin it shouldnt be up to the fans, but they're should be some kind of regulations to the vote

The only way around it is to not put Iverson or McGrady on the ballots, so the fans dont have that option to vote for. But this game is never about who is more deserving but who the fans wanna see play. If the fans wanna see McGrady over Steve Nash then thats how its is. But thats where the coaches come in....
 
Last edited:
jamacia;16701 said:
The only way around it is to not put Iverson or McGrady on the ballots, so the fans dont have that option to vote for. But this game is never about who is more deserving but who the fans wanna see play. If the fans wanna see McGrady over Steve Nash then thats how its is. But thats where the coaches come in....

yea see thats what im sayin, i think there should be some sort of rule like....to get on the ballot you should have a minimum of 20games played (for the season) or somethin along those lines, same way you need to shoot a minimum amount of freethrows to become a part of the free throw percentage list.

it doesnt make any sense that McGrady is on the list, and Chris Kaman aint on the ballot! that nigga is averagin a double-double.
 
Last edited:
See....even Jesus Shuttlesworth knows this is some bullshit.

http://sports.espn.go.com/nba/allstar2010/news/story?id=4833965

Allen takes issue with fans' voting role

Celtics guard Ray Allen thinks it's time to limit fans' influence in All-Star voting with Allen Iverson and Tracy McGrady, despite having little to no impact this season, both headed into the final hours of voting in position to start.

Unwanted by their teams, Iverson and McGrady are still adored by their fans, who still consider them stars even though their stats say otherwise.

The Memphis Grizzlies quickly parted ways with Iverson. The Houston Rockets are trying to trade McGrady.

Maybe the players can swap stories of their rocky roads while covering each other at the All-Star Game.

"I like the fact that the fans get the opportunity to vote and pick who they'd like to see in the All-Star Game, but I don't think it should be 100 percent," Allen said this week.

Allen said the fan voting has made the game "watered down" and called for a change in the process.

Allen said fans should have 50 percent of the vote, with the other 50 percent being divided evenly between the media and the players. He said players know who is playing the best, and believes with his idea, "you'd look at five guys starting the All-Star team regardless of hype or highlight."

The NBA likes things the way they are.

"We look at it as a great way to engage the fans," NBA spokesman Brian McIntyre said. "We think it's a good system."

The NBA went to fan voting for the starters in the mid-70s and this season made it even more available to its fans by allowing them to vote by text messaging.

Paper balloting has already closed, but votes can be cast until 11:59 p.m. ET on Monday night on nba.com or by texting a player's last name to 6-9-6-2-2 (MYNBA). Starters will be announced Thursday night.

McGrady has a good chance of being passed, as his lead over Steve Nash for the second guard spot in the Western Conference was only 2,375 votes when the most recent update was released on Jan. 7.

He hasn't been able to strengthen his case since then, since he'd already been granted a leave from the Rockets while they try to find a trade.

He's played sparingly in only six games this season since coming back from knee surgery, and Allen thinks commissioner David Stern should consider a rule mandating a player appear in a minimum number of games to be eligible.

"Tracy, if he played, I'm sure he'd play well enough to be an All-Star player because he's done that his career," Allen said. "But again, that's taking away from another player in the Western Conference that's having a great year, that's been playing, that deserves to be in there."

Iverson had a better shot of holding on to his No. 2 spot in the East, leading Vince Carter by more than 185,000 votes. He's listed with West players on the paper ballot after starting the season in Memphis, but his votes count in the East since he signed with the Philadelphia 76ers.

He hasn't played at an All-Star level this season, but fans may be looking at what he's done in the past.

"A lot of times voting reflects career achievement as well as yearly achievements," McIntyre said.

Allen also mentioned getting the coaches, who pick the reserves, involved in selecting the starters. Even that may not guarantee the most deserving 10 players, since coaches could have their own opinions about who belongs in the All-Star game.

During Shaquille O'Neal's unproductive, injury-plagued final season in Miami in 2008, former Knicks coach Isiah Thomas said he planned to vote him as a reserve anyway, recalling when he played that respected older players such as Julius Erving still made All-Star teams late in their careers.

That's why Charlotte coach Larry Brown supports Iverson's election.

"I've seen Willie Mays and those older guys start based on what they've done in their career in baseball and we've had that happen in basketball for years, guys that have made a contribution," Brown said. "That's why the fans are involved and I think it's kind of neat that they are involved. They support the league, they vote for their favorite players. I always look at a guy's body of work."

That's fine for some, but it means worthy players are going to be left out. Unlike baseball, which mandates every team be represented in its All-Star Game, the NBA has only 12 spots per conference to fill.

"You figure if there's 24 players that get named to the All-Star team, there's always 30 that deserve it, and you figure that's six that should be on the All-Star team," Allen said.

Toronto forward Chris Bosh had little chance of starting the game in his hometown of Dallas, sitting well behind LeBron James and Kevin Garnett despite a terrific first half. Yet he doesn't want to change the voting format.

"It's all about the fans," he said. "It's all about who they want to see because they generate the dollars, they're going to watch the game, so they're going to vote for their favorite players and that's probably how it should be."
 
Last edited:
Dick Shitman;12036 said:
It's a shame that McGrady and Iverson are slated to start. Shaq will probably get the 2nd center spot in the east even though Noah, Horford or Brook Lopez deserves it

They're big name stars in the game it wouldnt be the same without them plus who's gonna replace them? well t-mac can be replace but who's gonna take a.i. spot rondo??? lmao
 
Last edited:

Members online

Trending content

Thread statistics

Created
-,
Last reply from
-,
Replies
30
Views
70
Back
Top
Menu
Your profile
Post thread…