How is Eminem anywhere near a top 10 rapper based on catalog alone?

[WilliamWallace1]

Cos of The Slim Shady LP, The Marshall Mathers LP, The Eminem Show. His first 3 albums.

Thread done.

 

[DMTxTHC]

How is Eminem anywhere near a top 10 rapper based on catalog alone?

He isn't.

 

[Already Home_17]

bcuz maybe people enjoy his catalog......?

 

[Chi-Town Bully]

It's all preference, we not all go have the same top 10.

 

[grumpy_new_yorker]

CS.

Dude has mad lyrical skill no question, but he let it go to waste on making goofy pop shit/kill my mom and girlfriend shit. All his albums are garbage. Never understood how he sold so many albums. Must be a lot more idiots out there then I thought.

 

[Gen. Stasia]

He's not.

 

[usmarin3]

classic albums are considered championship rings right, it's the ultimate prize as a artist. How you a goat when you can't win rings. I doesn't matter how nice you can rhyme if you can't put together a great body of work.

 

[WilliamWallace1]

bcuz maybe people enjoy his catalog......?

And that is people more than any other rapper based on a concrete fact his sales

 

[WilliamWallace1]

It's all preference, we not all go have the same top 10.

Thread done

 

[Lab Baby]

He's definitely a top 5 spitter in the game. Catalogue wise... not so much. 99-02 Em was on a GOAT run (all 3 albums are 5 mics, fuck a hater), but after that, son went downhill. Still had bars, but the drugs and the goofy shit fucked up his catalogue. And by the time he got to Recovery, he was spittin lines like "call me Elton John cuz I'm a mean cocksucker". So GOAT list, he's fallen from the 10th spot. But he's still one of my favorite MCs. I disagree with Encore being the worst album ever though, shit had some bangers on it.

 

[usmarin3]

bcuz maybe people enjoy his catalog......?

And that is people more than any other rapper based on a concrete fact his sales

LOL at sales, that's like saying Avatar is the greatest movie ever because it grossed the most money.

it's catalog >skillset>sales

 

[akomax]

CS.

Dude has mad lyrical skill no question, but he let it go to waste on making goofy pop shit/kill my mom and girlfriend shit. All his albums are garbage. Never understood how he sold so many albums. Must be a lot more idiots out there then I thought.

of course u forgot to include urself ...

 

[illedout]

slim shady aint in my top 10..

I have never bought/bootlegged a slim shady album..

I dont check for slim shady release dates or concerts..

I think his beat making skills are terrible..

his subject matter is shallow, cheesy white boy shit..

and his voice is annoying as fuck..

 

[Gen. Stasia]

He's definitely a top 5 spitter in the game. Catalogue wise... not so much. 99-02 Em was on a GOAT run (all 3 albums are 5 mics, fuck a hater), but after that, son went downhill. Still had bars, but the drugs and the goofy shit fucked up his catalogue. And by the time he got to Recovery, he was spittin lines like "call me Elton John cuz I'm a mean cocksucker". So GOAT list, he's fallen from the 10th spot. But he's still one of my favorite MCs. I disagree with Encore being the worst album ever though, shit had some bangers on it.

None of those albums are better than Reasonable Doubt tho. And even tho I love Reasonable Doubt its lower teir Classic in terms of Illmatic and Ready To Die so how in the FUCK are they 5 mics?

 

[a_list]

he's not......

 

[WilliamWallace1]

CS.

Dude has mad lyrical skill no question, but he let it go to waste on making goofy pop shit/kill my mom and girlfriend shit. All his albums are garbage. Never understood how he sold so many albums. Must be a lot more idiots out there then I thought.

of course u forgot to include urself ...

bcuz maybe people enjoy his catalog......?

And that is people more than any other rapper based on a concrete fact his sales

LOL at sales, that's like saying Avatar is the greatest movie ever because it grossed the most money.

it's catalog >skillset>sales

But like everyone sayin in this thread it's just your opinion but with sales not even sales but with a huge percentage of people who do think he is top 5 that is something concerete to go by over just your opinion you just bein a net poster but sales, the amount of people who got him in their top 5 is somethin concerete to go by. And weren't you the same clown who said the Blueprint 3 ain't a sh!tty wack album because of sales? lol this was ya same argument in that thread you lil joker roll. Bi polar are we?

 

[CracceR]

 

[usmarin3]

Did this nigga just say all three Eminem albums are 5 mics, bruh stop the fucking nonesense. I don't even consider Nas, Jay, Face second tier dope albums (IWW, Vol 1, American Gangster,Life is Good) classics and i know they all are better than SSLP,MMSHOW,MMLP.

Ya'll throw around the classic rating way too fucking much.

 

[Stew]

If Biggie can be one why cant Em?

U say he doesnt have any classics, I say he has 1.

U say his bad album is fucking terrible, I say its just not good.

 

[CJ]

William Wallace must be that shady hoe