JokerzWyld;c-9663240 said:
Moonlight wasn't an impressive film to me. I couldn't care less about the homosexuality in the film. It felt fake. The dialogue was sparse to the point of being non existent. The script was weak. The quality of the actors couldn't compensate for that weakness IMO.
Manchester was an average film with no character development. Casey Affleck's range as an actor in that film was inferior compared to Denzel & Viola in Fences, and Emma Stone in La La Land.
Birth of a Nation being snubbed was clearly political and very disgraceful, even for the academy. It was a strong film with strong actors, a strong plot, etc. Hidden Figures was decent but the drama seemed contrived in an unrealistic way to bolster a feminist position. Fences was most deserving of Best Picture in that category with the films included. I'm not surprised it lost though; when has the academy ever gotten it right?
No i really disagree on Fences ,it still looked like alot like a stage play. It had Great dialogue and performances (from Denzel and Viola) but was not the best picture , nowhere near.
Moonlight deserves best picture the cinematography, the colors used ,the grit , it felt like that part of miami and had better use of music and nuance. Also three different actors playing the same person at three different stages in their lives and all performance being that on point , if you cant appreciate that direction or the themes then you dont like or understand cinema.
Moreover how is hidden figures a feminist position movie when its actually a true story that needed exposure and telling?
Birth of a Nation had amateur directing and editing, the story was not well told.
Its subjective but they do get it right in that category most times than not:
Great Best Pictures in the last 18 years imo
12 Years a Slave
The King's Speech
No Country for Old Men
Slumdog Millionaire
The Departed
Million Dollar Baby
The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King
A Beautiful Mind
Gladiator
American Beauty