Great song but you shouldnt have sung it!!! Right song, wrong artist thread!

[blackrain]

I've always felt like either Christina Aguilera or even Beyonce shoulda been given Rihanna's "Unfaithful"...I think The Dream shoulda gave "She Needs My Love" to Day26...he can't sing well enough to give the harmonies he attempted to sing on that song the true justice it deserves...

 

[Punisher__]

Mariah Carey should've sung "Be Without You." Mary just lacks the vocal control to really attempt those types of ballads, and she was pitchy throughout.

 

[The Smooth One]

808s & Heartbreaks...

Kayne's selfish ass shoulda given Love Lockdown to John Legend to perfect... And done something with all those other shits on the album.

 

[G.R.I.P. Money $$$]

speedin is wacc as fuck period...

 

[The Smooth One]

Mariah Carey should've sung "Be Without You." Mary just lacks the vocal control to really attempt those types of ballads, and she was pitchy throughout.

*Cosigned*

Mary is falling off lowkey. I hope she doesn't, but it's becoming apparent.

 

[The Smooth One]

I've always felt like either Christina Aguilera or even Beyonce shoulda been given Rihanna's "Unfaithful"...I think The Dream shoulda gave "She Needs My Love" to Day26...he can't sing well enough to give the harmonies he attempted to sing on that song the true justice it deserves...

Dream shoulda stuck as a mediocre songwriter. I accepted Ne-yo gets a pass, but you gotta draw the line somewhere.

 

[Cake4real]

I don't agree with the Mary thing. I don't have a particular song but I think Ciara and Ashanti should have given up some of their songs to other artist.

 

[The Smooth One]

Yea I kinda went too far... At least Be Without You was good... her other songs since, have kinda just fizzled.

 

[Meet The Sniper]

808s & Heartbreaks...

Kayne's selfish ass shoulda given Love Lockdown to John Legend to perfect... And done something with all those other shits on the album.

Hell yeah.

Also Beyonce shoulda gave Diva to someone else less annoying. If I didn't like the bitch enough already...

 

[blackrain]

Mariah Carey should've sung "Be Without You." Mary just lacks the vocal control to really attempt those types of ballads, and she was pitchy throughout.

funny that's actually one of the few songs by Mary J that I do like...

 

[dimples]

I always thought Ray J's One Wish would have been so much better with someone else singing. Song was nice but hiis voice just sounded all strained and kinda annoying. Not quite sure who I'd have replace him though.

 

[inia]

"Rain On Me" by Ashanti would have been great if sung by Faith Evans, Monica, or Teedra Moses

Strong co-sign. Don't get me wrong, I enjoy the song the way it is, but Ashanti's vocal is too dull and lifeless for such a dramatic tear-jerker. My girl Faith woulda done it justice.

I have some songs that make me feel the same way as the threadstarter does. Just can't think of specific examples right now...

 

[blackrain]

I always thought Ray J's One Wish would have been so much better with someone else singing. Song was nice but hiis voice just sounded all strained and kinda annoying. Not quite sure who I'd have replace him though.

yeah...Ray J is an ok writer but terrible singer...I think Timbaland should've gave Icebox to somebody else too...Omarion fucked that song up vocally

 

[Cake4real]

I was just thinking about the "Ice Box" song....yeah you're right

 

[Jay107]

"valley of death" was a beat toomp intended on giving to Jay-Z...i would have like to heard Jay's take on that beat..

 

[arbitration]

Keyshia Cole's "I Found You". To this day, I SMH @ what could have been. This song had it all --> killer instrumentals with shimmering violins and acoustic guitar, nice background. It would have been an all-time great song if they found someone who could who could sing the part in the chorus "I found ... you". Keyshia sounds like she's going through an epileptic seizure.

[video=youtube;Hsq4YN8l6SM]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hsq4YN8l6SM[/video]

 

[usmarin3]

Anything by Keri Hilson, bitch can't sing period

 

[rip.dilla]

Anything by Keri Hilson, bitch can't sing period

LMAO... you're just one funny dude

 

[Craig Robinson]

OMG by usher....(well it's not a great song either) but he's way too talented of a singer to be "singing" that song...shoulda left it to chris brown