Father Beats Man to Death after catching the Man Molesting his Daughter...

  • Thread starter Thread starter New Editor
  • Start date Start date
Plutarch;4516123 said:
I never really liked the ic's new rating system. Seems very high schoolish to me. But it does tell you who has a problem with your posts. So what's really hood Soloman the Wise?
I thought your responses were wack plain and simple as the reaction put it, the title was to the point and not misleading in the bit dude had every right to defend his daughter even at the expense of the other mans life. In fact it was his duty to remove that predator as a father and decent human being, if not for his daughter for the other victims dude most likely did that to(predators do not just start in old age they generally start as teenagers) and other future victims he would have got. Anyone saying anything in conflict to that point is wack to me... "Shrugs"

 
Last edited:
Plutarch;4517541 said:
Fair enough?

Soloman the Wise;4517015 said:
I thought your responses were wack plain and simple as the reaction put it, the title was to the point and not misleading in the bit

I only said that your title looked misleading because it said "father beats man to death after catching the man molesting his daughter", but then the article seems to imply twice that the the man attempted (unsuccessfully) to molest the daughter. So I was only confused about that part.

Soloman the Wise;4517015 said:
dude had every right to defend his daughter even at the expense of the other mans life. In fact it was his duty to remove that predator as a father and decent human being, if not for his daughter for the other victims dude most likely did that to(predators do not just start in old age they generally start as teenagers) and other future victims he would have got. Anyone saying anything in conflict to that point is wack to me... "Shrugs"

We all know that the father had every right to protect his daughter. And I've said that in my post. But I have to disagree that the father had every right to end dude's life and that it was his "duty" to do so. I call bs on that for obvious? reasons. Honestly I think that opinion is pretty typical and base.

I also think that we're assuming a lot for a story that we know very little about. It's definitely possible, but not certain that he had previous victims and would have had future victims.

see the deception is in the article wording not my title while he was attempting to sexually molest the child the initial unwanted touching even though non sexual is also molestation its by the grace of all things good he caught him before he got to the sexual part. The police investigated did not arrest because everything he said appears to be true so they handed it over to a grand jury to decide if he was excessive, justified and or accidental with his actions. As a father I say he was justified he I would send money to if he needed help in a legal fund. I do not know if you are a parent or not I hope not if that is how you really feel, but then if you are I would hope you never have to experience this type of scenerio for the sake of your child because it sounds like you would not avenge them...
 
Accidents happen. If he deliberately tried to kill him he deserves to go to prison, but if it was more like getting mad and beat up on the guy to a mess in anger and the guy accidentally died, then i think he should get off the hook.

 
Soloman the Wise;4518454 said:
see the deception is in the article wording not my title while he was attempting to sexually molest the child the initial unwanted touching even though non sexual is also molestation its by the grace of all things good he caught him before he got to the sexual part.

Okay, so the article wording was off. So the guy did molest the daughter. Okay I understand now. I hope you didnt take it personal like I was taking a dig at you. I just saw what seemed like an inconsistency and called that out. Well I thought it was an honest misunderstanding.

And yes, it is very fortunate that the father caught the guy in time. That's a blessing.

Soloman the Wise;4518454 said:
The police investigated did not arrest because everything he said appears to be true so they handed it over to a grand jury to decide if he was excessive, justified and or accidental with his actions. As a father I say he was justified he I would send money to if he needed help in a legal fund. I do not know if you are a parent or not I hope not if that is how you really feel, but then if you are I would hope you never have to experience this type of scenerio for the sake of your child because it sounds like you would not avenge them...

I hope that we're on the same page here. I'd like to clarify that I support the father's actions (like I said in my first post) and he absolutely did the right thing. I think that self-defense is a virtue. What I was arguing about was a different scenario/hypothetical situation. I would send the man money too if he needed financial support.

I wouldn't hope that what happened to the father happened to anyone. I know how serious and traumatizing child/sexual abuse is. But all this doesn't contradict the argument that I was making. God forbid, if the same thing happened to me, I would of course protect my child. I never implied that I wouldn't.

I think that this all boils down to my interpretation of the difference between revenge and justice. Imo the two are absolutely not the same thing. And no matter how popular revenge is, I would never support it. The father was about protecting his daughter, not avenging her. Big difference. He even showed remorese after the act. So chances are that he would not approve of people cheering him on. Hell, taking another man's life is a traumatic experience in itself. Or so I would think.
 
As a father of a soon to be 5 year old daughter all I can say is I would have done the exact same thing and lived with the consequences.
 
I see nothing wrong here..in fact i think they should pass a law that states.If you happen to catch a predator in the act of sexually molesting a child you have the right to use deadly force.
 
there is no deception

the girl was taken to a hospital to be examined and has since been released-said no evidence so far has led investigators to doubt his story

the newspapers nice way of saying dude was caught raping the lil girl

 

Members online

Trending content

Thread statistics

Created
-,
Last reply from
-,
Replies
37
Views
0
Back
Top
Menu
Your profile
Post thread…