Eminem has a horrible Catalogue

[H-Rap 180]

which one, ice cube or rick ross ? hahaha, fof troll..srsly

I typically dont address alias trolls but:

Especially Ice Cube, being a Black man from the West-Coast we share alot of the same cultural norms, morays, folkways, customs, and understanding.

Songs like "Black Korea", to "LiL G" to 'Today was a Good day" paint a picture of West-Coast life that I find easy to relate to and familiar.

Rozay with his "tropical" steez takes me back to the time I spent in Miami which in alot of ways is similar to L.A. were I spent many years, we share many of the same aspirations and tastes in different things especially lush production sounds and cinematic production techniques that enhance the music when in social situations.

this is all speculation and debateable subject matter, but are you telling me that you can relate to ross (pretending) to be the biggest drug dealer in florida?
The double standards are getting ridiculous here, a Ross stan is just as bad as a 50 stan. Smh at you trying to respect and emulate a criminal.
Drug dealers kill more people than any serial killer, dont try and tell me thats a good influence one the supposed 'black community' you speak of.

In my world I would know a "drug dealer" before I would a "serial-killer".

I respect any Black man that takes care of his family and has respect for his mother, I have zero respect for a white man that makes racist rap songs and disrespects his mother.

Im a member of the "black community" unlike yourself so any fool ignorant enough to say a drug-dealer kills more people than an actual serial killer is ignorant indeed.

SMH @ you respecting and emulating a man that raps about homosexual-incest and having sex with animal.

 

[_God_]

Well with Cam'ron at your number 3 I've come to the conclusion that for your full of shit.

coming form an uneducated coon, i understand where your coming from, ccam'ron is better lyricistm better wordplay , better production, rapped longside legends, got put on by a legend, a real one, not a homosexual coon who is famous off of work from 20 years ago, represents for the the real streets, battled legends and won, jayz, 50 cent and nas, founded an imprint which is still relevant today, which gave birth to another legend in Max b, set trends in hip hops from clothes to video styles which still last today emeinem has done none of that or came close, he is heralded becuz he's white and if hip hop is gonna be excepted mainstream, the main stream wud rather have a white person be the face

 

[_God_]

IMO:

SSLP 4.5/5

MMLP 4.5/5

TES 4/5

Encore 2/5

Relapse 3.5/5

Recovery 2.5/5

overall it's an above average catalog, deal.

he has no albums over a 2.5/5

 

[stupot0607]

SSLP - Decent, MMLP - Classic, Em Show - Decent, Encore - Awful, Relapse - Awful, Recovery - Awful....

 

[choppa_style]

eminem show i had to play that shit at least 10 times back to back when i first got it when it came out. Last year I had recovery and played it once and keep it rolling. I ain't hear Reasonable Doubt til i was like 16 or 17 but i still go back

and play it now. Like i couldn't really rock wit Relapse cuz of the shock lyrics like now that shit ain't cool like it was cool when i was in seventh grade and ain't know no better but now its a different story. Now i did like Beautiful off Relapse

that seems like the songs he should be making now. His style has changed and lot of his punchlines are forced , Relapse had that wack accent , Recovery he kinda started to get back to his old self but again the punchlines . I think he

should touch more on everyday topics like he did on infinite, in songs like beautiful , i'm not afraid, you know up lifting stuff and cut out the forced punchlines and shock lyrics and he would be better off.

You said a lot of words, but what's the point man? Are you saying he isn't replayable because you think he should rap about inspirational stuff and doesn't cater to your specific desires??

 

[choppa_style]

In my world I would know a "drug dealer" before I would a "serial-killer".

I respect any Black man that takes care of his family and has respect for his mother, I have zero respect for a white man that makes racist rap songs and disrespects his mother.

Im a member of the "black community" unlike yourself so any fool ignorant enough to say a drug-dealer kills more people than an actual serial killer is ignorant indeed.

SMH @ you respecting and emulating a man that raps about homosexual-incest and having sex with animal.

So you were a drug dealer at some point and ran a drug run criminal empire?? Wtf are you doing on this message board man??

To be honest, if Eminem really is a racist, I would think you would be the one to relate to him the most. Your pro-Ice Cube/anti-Eminem statements have revealed you as a pretty racist dude.

 

[_God_]

So you were a drug dealer at some point and ran a drug run criminal empire?? Wtf are you doing on this message board man??

To be honest, if Eminem really is a racist, I would think you would be the one to relate to him the most. Your pro-Ice Cube/anti-Eminem statements have revealed you as a pretty racist dude.

stop acting like a housenigga and reading shit you dont see, and i am racist, i dont like white ppl, im better than white ppl, white ppl are inferior, but my rasicm towards white ppl isnt the reason Eminems catalogue is horrible, the music is not good muaic, nor is it good hip hop music, it isnt hip hop music at all, and the music on his albums dont show anything to me to regard him as an elite rapper or a even a mediocre rapper, if we are just talking about whites in hip hop they are other ones that make good hip hop such as Paul Wall and Max Kellerman and Collie Budz (yes he is reggae but reggae and hip hop go hand in hand)

 

[H-Rap 180]

So you were a drug dealer at some point and ran a drug run criminal empire?? Wtf are you doing on this message board man??

To be honest, if Eminem really is a racist, I would think you would be the one to relate to him the most. Your pro-Ice Cube/anti-Eminem statements have revealed you as a pretty racist dude.

Most people from my background have dabbled in drug-dealing and have friends family and associates that have been involved in the drug game on various levels.

Criminal empire?? Did you get that phrase from a comic-book or a movie??

Its more easy for me to identify with a drug-dealer than it is a serial-killer/rapist. Rapping about raping your mother and being molested by your father is unimpressive to me.

To be honest if Emenim really is a racist me being a Black man I would find him despicable and typical.

But your Pro-Emenim/anti Ice-Cube statements have revealed that you are a pretty racist dude.

 

[H-Rap 180]

stop acting like a housenigga and reading shit you dont see, and i am racist, i dont like white ppl, im better than white ppl, white ppl are inferior, but my rasicm towards white ppl isnt the reason Eminems catalogue is horrible, the music is not good muaic, nor is it good hip hop music, it isnt hip hop music at all, and the music on his albums dont show anything to me to regard him as an elite rapper or a even a mediocre rapper, if we are just talking about whites in hip hop they are other ones that make good hip hop such as Paul Wall and Max Kellerman and Collie Budz (yes he is reggae but reggae and hip hop go hand in hand)

We gotta stop calling these white kids "niggas" they prefer the word "cracker".

 

[InMyLifeTime91]

wow this a shock threead like a muthafucka... eminem got one of the best catalogues out...

his curtains closed greatest hits album shits on jayz greatest his album.. his first 3 albums r classics... he got the second best catalogue bhind jayz and maaaaybe nas

 

[_God_]

wow this a shock threead like a muthafucka... eminem got one of the best catalogues out...

his curtains closed greatest hits album shits on jayz greatest his album.. his first 3 albums r classics... he got the second best catalogue bhind jayz and maaaaybe nas

so what songs from eminems albums ppl quote in everyday life what songs beside lose yourself is actually remembered by eminem? jay has handfuls, and i know plenty of ppl who have came out of nowhere or started a conversation with "its hard not to kill niggas" or "what you eat dont make me shit" "we dont believe you, you need more ppl" there isnt anything from eminem thats impacted ppls thoughts or evry day conversation, he is a manufactured false prophet of white ppl to try and get their hands on hip hop, and not to mention his horrible singles just a mockery of music etc the real slim shady and my name is and all those other jokes

 

[HipHop90]

coming form an uneducated coon, i understand where your coming from, ccam'ron is better lyricistm better wordplay , better production, rapped longside legends, got put on by a legend, a real one, not a homosexual coon who is famous off of work from 20 years ago, represents for the the real streets, battled legends and won, jayz, 50 cent and nas, founded an imprint which is still relevant today, which gave birth to another legend in Max b, set trends in hip hops from clothes to video styles which still last today emeinem has done none of that or came close, he is heralded becuz he's white and if hip hop is gonna be excepted mainstream, the main stream wud rather have a white person be the face

I don't see how you can say Cam'ron has better lyricism and wordplay that just straight up isn't true, better production? Maybe so but Cam'ron does do any production himself so can't take the credit. For the note I think Infinite, SSLP, MMLP and Eminem Show are all great albums MMLP being the only classic and his work after that...well he aint my cup of tea anymore but he's definately done a job for Hip Hop, showing it isn't just specific to one culture and can be enjoyed by anyone, whoever you are or how you are brought up.

 

[Avenged Sevenfold]

coming form an uneducated coon, i understand where your coming from, ccam'ron is better lyricistm better wordplay , better production, rapped longside legends, got put on by a legend, a real one, not a homosexual coon who is famous off of work from 20 years ago, represents for the the real streets, battled legends and won, jayz, 50 cent and nas, founded an imprint which is still relevant today, which gave birth to another legend in Max b, set trends in hip hops from clothes to video styles which still last today emeinem has done none of that or came close, he is heralded becuz he's white and if hip hop is gonna be excepted mainstream, the main stream wud rather have a white person be the face

Lol at you calling someone uneducated but you can't spell FROM correctly.

 

[onepunch]

wow this a shock threead like a muthafucka... eminem got one of the best catalogues out...

his curtains closed greatest hits album shits on jayz greatest his album.. his first 3 albums r classics... he got the second best catalogue bhind jayz and maaaaybe nas

Are you stupid or just young, dumb, and full of cum? Have you ever heard a RAKIM, EPMD, REDMAN, SCARFACE, L.L. Cool J., TRIBE CALLED QUEST, ICE CUBE, PUBLIC ENEMY, BIG DADDY KANE, TOO SHORT album? all of the before mentioned have catalouges shitting on the whiteboy homosexual rape your mother and dog in the same night racist whiteboy cracker rapper named eminem...

 

[rapmastermind]

3 Great Albums 1 good album 2 terrible albums= equal above avg catalogue

I agree with this:

SSLP - 4.5 MICS
MMLP - 5 MICS
TES - 4 MICS
E - 2.5 MICS
REL - 3 MICS
REC - 3.5 MICS

Sadly Eminem peaked with the "Eminem Show" and that album still wasn't better than his 1st two. But saying Eminem has a "HORRIBLE" catalog is a little extreme. His 1st 3 albums are solid enough to compete with the best in Hip Hop History. The problem is when we get into GOAT discussion with Em cause his best albums fail in comparison to some of Hip Hop Greatest LP's. "SSLP" was a dope album, top to bottom. Had some light filler but overall solid debut. "MMLP" just shocked the game with a thunder bolt. Just when you thought he could of just been another "White emcee gimmick" he wasn't, he was spittin on that LP. "TES" he flipped it again and went more personal and more deep. I think "TES" is a great album but what hurts it is the beats weren't that great. I know people that say it's his best album but I don't see it, he wasn't spitting better on "TES" as he was on his 1st two LP's which to me was the pinnacle of Eminem.

As for the bottom half of Em's catalog, "Encore" was so bad it's unlikeable till this day. Only 2 or 3 bangers at best the rest was all throwaway material. "Relaspe & Recovery" are the same album to me. Both had bangers but were very uneven, "Recovery" was slightly better but not that much. His callabo projects with "D12" were average. "8 Mile" soundtrack was dope. "Re-up" was average. Overall it's a pretty good catalog but when you think of Jay with "RD and BP", NaS with "ILL and STILL", Biggie with "RTD and LAD" and Pac with "MATW and AEOM" and Rakim with "PIF and FTL" you can see where Eminem is going to fall short on the GOAT list. His skills can't be deny, nor his Impact. He has a solid catalog so when the book are written he will be considered one of the Best. But THE BEST, Like Top 5? his catalog will prevent him from breakin in. Take Eminem's best album and put it up against Biggie, Pac, Jay, NaS and Rakim's best and you will notice something. It fails in comparison. As for the "Subject Matter" Debate. Art is Art. I listen to artist I can and can't relate too. It's about the music at the end of the day. Eminem can rap about killing his mom and all that other mess but if the song is dope it's dope. Sure he gets repetitive with it but overall Eminem is an amazing artist and emcee.

 

[onepunch]

I agree with this:

SSLP - 4.5 MICS

MMLP - 5 MICS

TES - 4 MICS

E - 2.5 MICS

REL - 3 MICS

REC - 3.5 MICS

Sadly Eminem peaked with the "Eminem Show" and that album still wasn't better than his 1st two. But saying Eminem has a "HORRIBLE" catalog is a little extreme. His 1st 3 albums are solid enough to compete with the best in Hip Hop History. The problem is when we get into GOAT discussion with Em cause his best albums fail in comparison to some of Hip Hop Greatest LP's. "SSLP" was a dope album, top to bottom. Had some light filler but overall solid debut. "MMLP" just shocked the game with a thunder bolt. Just when you thought he could of just been another "White emcee gimmick" he wasn't, he was spittin on that LP. "TES" he flipped it again and went more personal and more deep. I think "TES" is a great album but what hurts it is the beats weren't that great. I know people that say it's his best album but I don't see it, he wasn't spitting better on "TES" as he was on his 1st two LP's which to me was the pinnacle of Eminem.

As for the bottom half of Em's catalog, "Encore" was so bad it's unlikeable till this day. Only 2 or 3 bangers at best the rest was all throwaway material. "Relaspe & Recovery" are the same album to me. Both had bangers but were very uneven, "Recovery" was slightly better but not that much. His callabo projects with "D12" were average. "8 Mile" soundtrack was dope. "Re-up" was average. Overall it's a pretty good catalog but when you think of Jay with "RD and BP", NaS with "ILL and STILL", Biggie with "RTD and LAD" and Pac with "MATW and AEOM" and Rakim with "PIF and FTL" you can see where Eminem is going to fall short on the GOAT list. His skills can't be deny, nor his Impact. He has a solid catalog so when the book are written he will be considered one of the Best. But THE BEST, Like Top 5? his catalog will prevent him from breakin in. Take Eminem's best album and put it up against Biggie, Pac, Jay, NaS and Rakim's best and you will notice something. It fails in comparison.

This makes sence

 

[choppa_style]

stop acting like a housenigga and reading shit you dont see, and i am racist, i dont like white ppl, im better than white ppl, white ppl are inferior, but my rasicm towards white ppl isnt the reason Eminems catalogue is horrible, the music is not good muaic, nor is it good hip hop music, it isnt hip hop music at all, and the music on his albums dont show anything to me to regard him as an elite rapper or a even a mediocre rapper, if we are just talking about whites in hip hop they are other ones that make good hip hop such as Paul Wall and Max Kellerman and Collie Budz (yes he is reggae but reggae and hip hop go hand in hand)

You didn't create hip-hop so you don't decide what is and isn't considered hip-hop. As for Em not being an elite rapper, anyone with half a brain can tell he has skills. You're clearly just hating on the dude.

Most people from my background have dabbled in drug-dealing and have friends family and associates that have been involved in the drug game on various levels.

Criminal empire?? Did you get that phrase from a comic-book or a movie??

Its more easy for me to identify with a drug-dealer than it is a serial-killer/rapist. Rapping about raping your mother and being molested by your father is unimpressive to me.

To be honest if Emenim really is a racist me being a Black man I would find him despicable and typical.

But your Pro-Emenim/anti Ice-Cube statements have revealed that you are a pretty racist dude.

So in other words, no, you can't relate to any rappers. So your "arguement" that Em's catalogue sucks because you can't relate to him is pretty much pointless.

 

[H-Rap 180]

You didn't create hip-hop so you don't decide what is and isn't considered hip-hop. As for Em not being an elite rapper, anyone with half a brain can tell he has skills. You're clearly just hating on the dude.

So in other words, no, you can't relate to any rappers. So your "arguement" that Em's catalogue sucks because you can't relate to him is pretty much pointless.

You didn't create hip-hop so you don't decide what is and isn't considered hip-hop. As for Em not being an elite rapper, anyone with half a brain can tell he has skills. You're clearly just hating on the dude.

So in other words, no, you can't relate to any rappers. So your "arguement" that Em's catalogue sucks because you can't relate to him is pretty much pointless.

Blacks and Latinos creating HipHop in the inner cities and I happen to be a Black man from the inner city.

You poor soul I never once made an "arguement" that emenims catalog sucked, you must be confused.

I relate better to music from my own cultural background easier than I do music from different cultural backgrounds. Most people do.

 

[_God_]

You didn't create hip-hop so you don't decide what is and isn't considered hip-hop. As for Em not being an elite rapper, anyone with half a brain can tell he has skills. You're clearly just hating on the dude.



So in other words, no, you can't relate to any rappers. So your "arguement" that Em's catalogue sucks because you can't relate to him is pretty much pointless.

knowing what hip hop is, and how he started, it has nothing to do with eminems music

 

[juelz21]

[/B]

Are you stupid or just young, dumb, and full of cum? Have you ever heard a RAKIM, EPMD, REDMAN, SCARFACE, L.L. Cool J., TRIBE CALLED QUEST, ICE CUBE, PUBLIC ENEMY, BIG DADDY KANE, TOO SHORT album? all of the before mentioned have catalouges shitting on the whiteboy homosexual rape your mother and dog in the same night racist whiteboy cracker rapper named eminem...

too short really lol ! get the fukk outta here eminem would rap circles around too short and most of of your whole list.